Best player in AFL by jumper number

[SaintsPremiers08]

Judd > Mitchell
Mcveigh > Bateman
Lovett-Murray > Wilkes

This year Mitchell > Judd!

 

[sblack]

8 - M.Hahn (Dogs) (S.Burgoyne)

Haha...Hahn better than Shaun

 

[Gozz]

This is one of the worst threads of all time. Nobody can get it right due to bias to there own players and hatred towards rivals players eg Collingwood and Carlton. And the disrespect shown to Juddy is unbelievable, Sam Mitchell, you have to be kidding yourselves. Judd is a gun, gets tagged more heavily than anyone else, has no decent ruckman to work with and still racks up and is the best player. And Andy Walker will be giving no.1 a shake by the end of the year.

 

[swiftdog]

This is one of the worst threads of all time. Nobody can get it right due to bias to there own players and hatred towards rivals players eg Collingwood and Carlton. And the disrespect shown to Juddy is unbelievable, Sam Mitchell, you have to be kidding yourselves. Judd is a gun, gets tagged more heavily than anyone else, has no decent ruckman to work with and still racks up and is the best player. And Andy Walker will be giving no.1 a shake by the end of the year.

Can you sense the irony in your post?

 

[Mancey]

Norm Smith medalist Andrew Embley probably has a fair claim to override Travis Cloke at #32

 

[Cruiser23]

This year Mitchell > Judd!

Nope, sorry, Judd > Mitchell which ever way you look at it.

 

[Kaladin Stormblessed]

This year Mitchell > Judd!

LOL bullshit.

Do you realise how good a season Judd has actully had or you just listen to bigfooty trolls?

 

[Burzum]

Judd is first by default.

 

[Mancey]

Judd should get 3 and 5.

 

[verypoorboy]

29 - Matthew Pavlich (Fremantle), Gary Ablett (Geelong) and Brent Harvey (North Melbourne) - can not split them!!
Awesome Trio.

 

[Alphanumeric]

5 - Sam Mitchell over Boyd comfortably ( not an insult to Boyd – I rate him ) and Judd’s a fair player too

36 – Lake in the hunt against Goodwin/Bradshaw but you’d have to go with Goodwin on career

33 - Tim Callan’s 6 games not quite ready to go against J Farmer (career) M Rooke, B Reilly and a buch of not quite stars

Are you rating this on career or what?? If so Judd has to be ahead of Sam Mitchell!

 

[Spitty]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1 - B. Hall (Syd)
2 - J.Roughead (Haw)
3 - J.Bartel (Geel)
4 - D.Kerr (WCE)
5 - C.Judd (Carl)
6 - B.Johnson (Dogs)
7 - S. West (Dogs)
8 - S. Burgoyne (Port)
9 - S.Crawford (Haw)
10 - C.Bateman (Haw)
11 - J.Corey (Geel)
12 - M.Richardson (Rich)
13 - D.Thomas (Coll)
14 - J.Selwood (Geel)
15 - L.Hodge (Haw)
16 - J.Brown (Bris)
17 - A.Cooney (Dogs)
18 - M.Lloyd (Ess)
19 - D.Hille (Ess)
20 - S.Black (Bris)
21 - J.Akermanis (Dogs)
22 - R.Shaw (Coll)
23 - L.Franklin (Haw)
24 - N.Stevens ( Carl)
25 - B.Fevola (Carl)
26 - N.Dal Santo (St K)
27 - M.Stokes (Geel)
28 - J.Crouch (Syd)
29 - B. Harvey (NM) Very Close with pav and gablett
30 - M.Scarlett (Geel)
31 - B.Kirk (Syd)
32 - A.Embley (WCE)
33 - B.Reilly (Adel)
34 - J.White (Melb)
35 - R.Harvey (St K)
36 - S.Goodwin (Adel)
37 - A.Goodes (Syd)
38 - B.Jones (WCE)
39 - D.Milburn (Geel)
40 - J.Porplyzia (Adel)
41 - N.Foley (Rich)
42 - N Lovett Murray (Ess)
43 - R Hayden (Frem)
44 - N.Lappin (Bris)
45 - C.Ling (Geel)
46 - J.King (Rich)
85 - H.Taylor (Geel)

 

[ssfc0203]

Why would you pick Hille over MickyO? (Assuming you picked for impact over a career, not a single year as most of your choices reflect..)

 

[Mervyn Beasley]

I just cant believe this has gone 60 odd replies without someone posting the list of their team

 

[Falcon]

This game needs some more specific rules, best player overall or best in '08

Now I know I'm a Saints fan but no way would Medhurst be over Hayes in '08 and the same with Richardson over Riewoldt.

And Ablett and B.Harvey would be way ahead of Pavlich this year. Ablett to take my cake.

 

[Benno_900]

22 is a shocker.

Maybe Rhyce Shaw or Dylan Addison.

 

[UpForGrabs]

44 – Bock over O’Shea

Nigel Lappin, Corey Enright and David Wirrpanda all say g'day... and "who?"