Best Player You've Ever Seen.

[PiesPremiers]

Any doubt i had about the best player ive ever seen were dismissed on Saturday afternoon.
Michael Voss is the perfect footballer anyone would love to have in theyre team. Great leader, Couragous, Good bloke and most important a great team man.
I have no doubt in my mind he is the best player ive seen.

 

[Thrawn]

Murray Vance. He used to be a superstar. Never know why Carlton de-listed him, he was a champion! Best that ever walked on the 'G.

 

[fugitive]

Coming from a Magpie supporter

 

[Mobbs]

For mine, Voss and Buckley were dead set evens on Saturday gawn.

In my time, I always reckoned Peter Dean was worth about three times what most folks thought of him. Still, Roos was way up there, and Jimbo Hird is a damn good player.

 

[Portia]

I don't remember seeing Russell Ebert play, but Michael Aish is the most talented footballer I've seen.

 

[NICK THE PIE MAN]

Voss and Buckley were like 2 magicians on Saturday trying to out-do eachother. Great to see.

Voss and Buckley would be high on my list.

But...Peter Daicos and Gary Ablett.

 

[catattack]

Gary Ablett

 

[LionsForever]

Michael Voss for mine. Nathan Buckley was unbeleiavable on Saturday I wanted someone to knock him so we would've been more of a bigger chance thats how big of an impact he makes to that Collingwood side .. I wish he didnt leave Brisbane but he did.

 

[LordLucifer]

Best I ever saw ??

Jezza by a country mile !!

 

[NICK THE PIE MAN]

Originally posted by LionsForever
Michael Voss for mine. Nathan Buckley was unbeleiavable on Saturday I wanted someone to knock him so we would've been more of a bigger chance thats how big of an impact he makes to that Collingwood side .. I wish he didnt leave Brisbane but he did.

I shudder to think of Brisbane's midfield if Bucks stayed in Brissy.

C: J.Akermanis M.Voss N.Buckley

R: S.Black

Holy Christ!

 

[mellowyellow]

Originally posted by catattack
Gary Ablett

I must say that Gary Ablett would be the standout for me. Of the current crop i would rate Voss and Carey.

 

[hilly]

Wayyyyyyne.....will play well for the Crows next year but as he's past his very best, Voss is the best at the moment.

 

[Blues_Brat]

Peter Motley. Shame he never had a chance to prove it to the nation, would have been a great of the AFL

 

[LionsForever]

Originally posted by NICK THE PIE MAN


I shudder to think of Brisbane's midfield if Bucks stayed in Brissy.

C: J.Akermanis M.Voss N.Buckley

R: S.Black

Holy Christ!

LMAO! Yeah that midfield would be the best midfield in the business for sure, maybe ever..

I wasn't alive when Leigh Matthews was playing footy, well I was but I would've been only young I've heard he was one of the best ever.. I'd love to watch his games.

 

[Blues4Life]

Wayne Carey in full flight was the best I've ever seen, followed by Ablett, Voss, Hird and Buckley.

 

[Everitt]

Ted Whitten (yeah i have seen him when he went around at that state of origin game at the mcg in that car like shortly before he died)
Nick Riewoldt (2 years from now)
Robert Harvey
Ian Stewart

 

[Lockyer24]

Wayne Carey is the best player I have ever seen, a small gap then Voss, then Buckley and Hird, then Ablett.

 

[meg]

Top 3 for me would be

1. Ablett
2. Voss
3. Carey

Tony Lockett wasn't too shabby either. Neither is James Hird.

 

[LionsForever]

Thats who I forgot James Hird geez how could I leave him out I may not like Essendon or many player from the team but James Hird love him or hate him hes magnificent!

 

[mic59]

Originally posted by Porthos
I don't remember seeing Russell Ebert play

Porthos, I did see Russell Ebert play and he could have run rings around Michael Aish. Never saw Barrie Robran, though. Blame that on Leigh Matthews.

 

[jerry springer]

1.carey-from 92-99 was unstopable even when injured)
2.Ablett-one of the few players who could win a match from his own boot
3.silvangi-Best defender of this generation,could also move forward,does not get enough credit because he was a defender,but i felt Carlton suffered alot from his retirement

Honourable mentions-Buckley,Platten,Voss,Daicos,Hird,Jarman,Kelly

 

[Blues4Life]

Originally posted by mic59


Porthos, I did see Russell Ebert play and he could have run rings around Michael Aish. Never saw Barrie Robran, though. Blame that on Leigh Matthews.

How could I forget Silvagni, he's my favourite all time player

He'd definetly make my top 5 list and is the best defender I've ever seen by a country mile.

 

[Fred]

For ball skills and being ahead of his time in being able to play both sides of his body - Baldock.
For sheer domination when he was 'on' - Ablett.

 

[TheMase]

Bob Skilton.

 

[hotpie]

Voss
Ablett
Carey
Buckley
Carman (on talent alone for 2-3 years but not over a long career)