Best Priority pick duo

[enosis7]

If you get Carlton and Collingwood fans pumping up each other's draft picks, you know something terribly wrong must have been written.

 

[Athomas]

You would know alot about losing, wouldn't ya? The last time you guys won a final I could go and grab a great view of NYC from the twin towers.

I wasn't the 1 bragging about how good a player of Carlton's was in a losing team. (He was very good though, but you still lost ).

 

[DannyJ]

Roughy/Buddy.

It must have been hard to come to that conclusion

What a duo

 

[Grandmaster_B]

Granny B is Super_phaser nee Yze_Magic (for the older posters)

What does that mean?

 

[Deledio_Judd]

Buddy & Roughead easy

 

[Powersaur]

Goddard & Wells would have been nice

 

[Team Mo']

Goddard & Wells would have been nice

sssh....


Did anyone mention that Sylvia and McLean are in this poll yet the likes of Pav, Murphy and Pendlebury are left out.

Just though I'd point it out.

 

[Team Mo']

Which duo is/will be the best from teams who have snagged two top 5 picks?

If you had the option of trading McLean and Sylvia for Buddy and Roughead would you do it?

 

[Grandmaster_B]

If you had the option of trading McLean and Sylvia for Buddy and Roughead would you do it?

No.

Neither of those guys have played game like Sylvia did last weekend.

And after this draft we will be set for superstar tall forwards with Watts and Butcher.

 

[skelly12]

No.

Neither of those guys have played game like Sylvia did last weekend.

And after this draft we will be set for superstar tall forwards with Watts and Butcher.

Bit early to tank isn't it?

 

[Demonheart]

Bit early to tank isn't it?

Do you honestly think we're good enough to tank this year?

Either we're crap or we're a great team who's tanking, bigfooty just can't make up it's mind

 

[hellfire]

Sidenote - I chose the 5 I believe to be worthy. I am aware that Cartlon (Murphy/Kennedy) and Collingwood (Thomas/pendlebury) also had twpo top 5 picks in recent years, but they are weak duos with little to no upside.

Thanks for the laugh.

 

[hellfire]

Brock and Sylvia had over 60 touches and 5 goals between them on the weekend.

Oh... well in that case, they MUST be the best of the lost!

That one match just makes the rest of their shitness disappear!

Murphy and Pendlebury are top 10 mids in the comp this year. Thomas has been better than Sylvia despite going in a draft 2 years later, and Kennedy is looking the goods.

 

[bomberz08]

Buddy and Roughy, the rooey and kosi

Murphy/ Kennedy and thomas/pendles are better than sylvia and mclean.

You definetely should have included them

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Only one of those duo's has taken their team to a flag.

 

[hellfire]

Only one of those duo's has taken their team to a flag.

Not really a great gauge.

Two of those teams have won one premiership in history between them, one team bottomed out and is rebuilding now, and the other is Richmond.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Not really a great gauge.

Two of those teams have won one premiership in history between them, one team bottomed out and is rebuilding now, and the other is Richmond.

Well, it's pretty safe to say that we wouldn't have won a flag without them, even as 22yr olds.

If Kossie wasn't such a clutz him and Roo would have more a say in this poll.

 

[Barry Zuckercorn]

Welcome back Super_Phaser

You have always been my all time favourite poster! I love you!

 

[DOCKER MAN]

Buddy and Roughy, the rooey and kosi

Murphy/ Kennedy and thomas/pendles are better than sylvia and mclean.

You definetely should have included them

Also Haselby and Pavlich, would probably be 2nd after Roughead and Buddy in this pole IMO

 

[RPetterd15]

No.

Neither of those guys have played game like Sylvia did last weekend.

And after this draft we will be set for superstar tall forwards with Watts and Butcher.

yes syliva had a very good game but he hasn't been all too good his whole career so why don't you shut your mouth to stop the verbal diarrhea.And you must only watch melbourne players in games cause buddy has had a lot of games like sylvias, and murphy kennedy are a very good 2 players in top5 same with pendles and thomas. pendles, murphy, buddy, roughead, pavlich, etc have been playing consistant good footy so u can't say they haven't played a game like sylvias they've probably played quite a few better.

 

[Team Mo']

No.

Neither of those guys have played game like Sylvia did last weekend.

And after this draft we will be set for superstar tall forwards with Watts and Butcher.

Neither have been BOG or neither have played onball?

You're really not fooling anyone. We all know who you are. There is not subtly to any of your work so the humour is lost. And you're really clutching at straws when you actually make yourself believe you'd take two plodders over arguably the two best KP's in the game.