Best priority pick?

[Donakebab]

Since the priority pick as we know it is on it's way out, who do you believe will be seen as the best selection as a number 1 priority pick?




Obviously older players have already shown more promise, so for the younger players try and look further down the road and how you think they will develop.

 

[iGNITER]

Riewoldt. Hands Down.

 

[dutchy12]

Where's Tom Scully? Seriously this kid will be the best midfielder in the comp in four years. Immensly better than Gibbs, Murphy, Cotchin and co at the same age.

 

[Heisenberg_]

Where's Tom Scully? Seriously this kid will be the best midfielder in the comp in four years. Immensly better than Gibbs, Murphy, Cotchin and co at the same age.

Go away idiot, he hasnt played a game or even been drafted yet you moron

 

[Donakebab]

Where's Tom Scully? Seriously this kid will be the best midfielder in the comp in four years. Immensly better than Gibbs, Murphy, Cotchin and co at the same age.

He hasn't even been drafted yet. Even if he is taken at #1, it might not be with a priority pick. Why ask such a stupid question?

 

[Crooza]

Another vote for Nick Riewoldt. Love watching the guy play

 

[Capt_Concussion]

Where's Tom Scully? Seriously this kid will be the best midfielder in the comp in four years. Immensly better than Gibbs, Murphy, Cotchin and co at the same age.

I thought Melbourne supporters were meant to be intelligent upper class people. They shouldn't come out with this drivel. History is full of dud top 10 picks, don't count your (our) chickens before they hatch.

Voldt for me. Powerful player, powerful leader.

 

[tim_saints]

Riewoldt by a mile .

 

[Spluff]

Riewoldt has been head and shoulder above the rest so far.

[EDIT - Alright, stop voting Hodge, hawks supporters]

 

[Notorious_29]

Riewoldt, followed by Hodge.

 

[jonoman89]

Easily Roo.

 

[GrandBlue]

Riewoldt shits on all of them from the clouds.

 

[kane249]

Was going to say where's Chris Judd, then I realised although he was a priority pick he wasn't a number 1 pick like the rest

So Riewoldt easily

 

[Jatz]

yeah roo easily

 

[HARKER]

Bit tough throwing a 20 year old kid amongst mostly seasoned performers.

Riewoldt now obviously, but Kreuzer will be an absolute star, and then some.

 

[cannons]

Bit tough throwing a 20 year old kid amongst mostly seasoned performers.

Riewoldt now obviously, but Kreuzer will be an absolute star, and then some.

I agree, he is nowhere near the other guys at the moment, but he has some ability.

Absolute star? Well, I'm not totally convinced of this, but he should definitely be a very good player.

 

[CM Sean]

Luke Hodge in my opinion.

 

[watermelonslice]

Luke Hodge just squeezes out Riewoldt IMO.

 

[carnasaint55]

I demand to know the flogs who voted for Deledio and Cooney. At least Kreuzer has his youth on his side as a possible REASON to vote for him...

Roo MILES above the rest. Hodge a distant second.

 

[Boiled Geezer]

I demand to know the flogs who voted for Deledio and Cooney. At least Kreuzer has his youth on his side as a possible REASON to vote for him...

Roo MILES above the rest. Hodge a distant second.

Votes look like links. Just click on the number of votes and you can check.

 

[tazhawk]

Luke Hodge just squeezes out Riewoldt IMO.

Luke Hodge was not a priority pick

The Hawks traded with Freo to get the number 1 pick they used on Hodgey

 

[Boiled Geezer]

Luke Hodge was not a priority pick

The Hawks traded with Freo to get the number 1 pick they used on Hodgey

Fremantle traded their first priority pick for Trent Croad, so it is still valid.

The only #1 priority pick the OP missed was Marc Murphy.

 

[watermelonslice]

Luke Hodge was not a priority pick

The Hawks traded with Freo to get the number 1 pick they used on Hodgey

Oh. Maybe mods should correct the poll then.

 

[Boiled Geezer]

Oh. Maybe mods should correct the poll then.

Why? Technically he was taken with a priority pick. It was allocated to Fremantle, but they traded it to Hawthorn.

 

[watermelonslice]

Why? Technically he was taken with a priority pick. It was allocated to Fremantle, but they traded it to Hawthorn.

Well that's what I thought. But apparently he's not a priority draft pick? So I'm a bit confused.