best team

[Kangas_Big_Fan]

with the players playing now what do u thonk would be the best side?

SoS Carey Buckley Hird Llyod West Kouta would defently be in
Pickett Ratten Farmer Lynch have a really good chance

what do u guys/girls think

 

[Fat Red]

Don't quite get the question, Kangas. Are you asking us to pick a team from the current lists?

 

[jod23]

Sos and Carey definites?? I dont think so, maybe a couple of years ago but today id rather Hay and Holland.

A midfield of Buckley Mcleod Ratten and Cousins would be something!

 

[kretchy]

Add the midfield the likes of voss scotty west and camporeale

 

[Kangas_Big_Fan]

yeah with the current list of players the best team Fat Red

 

[PiesPremiers]

Originally posted by Kangas_Big_Fan
with the players playing now what do u thonk would be the best side?

SoS Carey Buckley Hird Llyod West Kouta would defently be in
Pickett Ratten Farmer Lynch have a really good chance

what do u guys/girls think

ratten in
Kouta out

 

[PiesPremiers]

B. Lockyer Prestigiacomo Johnson
HB. Betheras Wakelin N. Davis
C. O'bree Buckley Rintoul
HF. Fraser Rocca Molloy
F. Holland Tarrant L. Davis
Foll. McKee Steinfort Adkins
Inters. Mcleod Lloyd Ratten

Emergs. West, Cousins and Hird
(couldnt quite break into this brilliant team!!)

 

[David Mensch]

B: Hardwick Hay King
HB: McKay Wellman Beaumont
C: Camporeale Ratten Voss
HF: McLeod Koutafides Hird
F: Matera Mensch(appoligies to Lloyd) Rioli
R: Primus Buckley West
Interchange: Goodwin, Grant, Tarrant, Stevens

 

[KingyOrTheKing]

Originally posted by PiesPremiers
B. Lockyer Prestigiacomo Johnson
HB. Betheras Wakelin N. Davis
C. O'bree Buckley Rintoul
HF. Fraser Rocca Molloy
F. Holland Tarrant L. Davis
Foll. McKee Steinfort Adkins
Inters. Mcleod Lloyd Ratten

Emergs. West, Cousins and Hird
(couldnt quite break into this brilliant team!!)

HA HA. You're funny PiesPremiers!!

 

[KingyOrTheKing]

BTW - The only players from north:

Pickett - Definitely!
King - Yes
Stevens - Definitely!

On current form, Carey wouldn't be near the top. He hasn't yet played an injury-free game. You can't put an injured player in the best team, even if he is the king, and performs better than most other players when he's injured!!

 

[Fat Red]

Originally posted by David Mensch
B: Hardwick Hay King
HB: McKay Wellman Beaumont
C: Camporeale Ratten Voss
HF: McLeod Koutafides Hird
F: Matera Mensch(appoligies to Lloyd) Rioli
R: Primus Buckley West
Interchange: Goodwin, Grant, Tarrant, Stevens

I like your team Menschy, but I'd have a couple of changes. Your half back line is good man by man but put together it's a bit lacking in strength. Wellman seems to me to play on the wing these days anyway.
And maybe I'm judging him against last year instead of against the competition, but I don't know if Kouta's quite there. Having said that, I can't think of anyone else playing well at CHF. Maybe I'd move you out there and find a spot for Lloydy that way.

B: Hardwick Hay King
HB: Wellman SOS Beaumont
C: Camporeale Ratten Voss
HF: McLeod Fraser Hird
F: Matera Mensch(apologies to Lloyd) Bradley
R: Primus Buckley West
Interchange: Grant, Tarrant, Stevens Darcy


I know there's a lot of Carlton players in there but that always seems to be the way, have a look at last year's All Austn team, more Carlton than Ess. Bradley is probably a biased one, but I can't believe how little attention he's getting for the fact that he's still one of our best WIWO.

 

[Voice of Reason]

Best Team 2001

B: Wirrapunda Fletcher King
HB: McKay Hay Akermanis
C: Camporeale Cousins Voss
HF: McLeod Hird Chick
F: Tarrant Lloyd Wanganeen
R: Primus Buckley Ratten
Interchange: West, Stevens, J Johnson, Gardiner

...and yes I am a little bit biased.

Also, the best team should be more than the sum of the parts, so I'm not sure if my team would work that well together.