Best Under 18 Players In Wrfl And Bfl

Status
Not open for further replies.

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Joined
Apr 23, 2006
Posts
550
Likes
0
Location
shifted to D50
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
you werent at the club in 1945, doesnt mean your premiships dont count....... back to an interesting topic and avoiding post embarrassing himself..


hardest players in 18's!!!

alrite.. we leave it at that
you live off the success of other players from a different era

Hardest Players:
B. Sheils
R. Greene
J. Pelns

there isnt any other players harder.. so end to that
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Joined
Feb 23, 2007
Posts
72
Likes
0
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
You want to play this game do you ? You want a list of names ?Try this one.....

McKenzie, Puhar, Barrett, Collins, Cascone, Oates, Salmon, Fowler.....

Where were they poached from ? Who did the development with those guys ? Thats right, not Spotswood.

4 Premierships in a row ? Won on the back of players poached from Altona.

Here's a tip.

Come back and tell us how good of a club you are when you can develop your own talent !
get facts right goose werent poached left cause altona boys didnt have good nos' ******** coach and wanted to play b's these boys wanted to play a' footy with a club who had a future not like altona and who ran 2 18s few years a go to help altona out then cleared guys back
 
Joined
Feb 23, 2007
Posts
72
Likes
0
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
I think you should be the one getting your facts right chump. There is absolutely no point in arguing this with me. I know the ins and outs of the entire saga. I was involved !

And not poaching you say ?

Tell me this, how many Under 18 flags have Spotty won since they have been forced to develop their own players ? Since the well of Altona and Willy players crossing over dired up ? Well ...... ????? Oh thats right. Big fat ZERO.

I don't want to argue this point, because from a Spotty perspective they did absolutely nothing wrong. But the truth is everyone knows that the players were poached and coaxed to stay. Everyone also knows that what Spotty got away with for far too long was and is WRONG. Do you know why it is harder to change junior clubs ? Why the league changed the rules ? Well heres the reason for ya ! The rules were changed soley becuase of the way Spotty went about things. There are far more clubs then Altona and Williamstown that were not happy with what was going on !
so tell us the reasons the boys put on clerance forms they the exact reasons i stated some of the boys where advised by jets to get to spotty to better there chances. which they did what did u want them to stay and play div 2. why did the league allow them to go obviously for there own good

we took footy clubs to new level

so how many players did willy poach last year and altona this year same thing get over it altona have had problems keeping kids for years
 
Joined
Apr 23, 2006
Posts
550
Likes
0
Location
shifted to D50
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
so tell us the reasons the boys put on clerance forms they the exact reasons i stated some of the boys where advised by jets to get to spotty to better there chances. which they did what did u want them to stay and play div 2. why did the league allow them to go obviously for there own good

we took footy clubs to new level

so how many players did willy poach last year and altona this year same thing get over it altona have had problems keeping kids for years

altona has poached nil this year. Grant was axed last year and then offered the job at altona. That is not poaching. The two players came with him off their own back, altona had nothing to do with that
 
Joined
Feb 23, 2007
Posts
72
Likes
0
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Firstly. There is no place on the clearance form for a "reason" to leave.

As I said, I don't want to argue, because talking to anyone from Spotty about this contentious issue is like talking to a brickwall. Nothing will ever come of the discussion.

Apart from this issue, I have no problems with Spotty what-so-ever. They are generally a great bunch of blokes and a great club to visit. And even now, I am over the entire saga. I just thought it was a pertinent point to bring up when you were bragging about how good your Under 18's have been.

At the time they played by the rules. Rules which have now been changed to allow for a more even playing field. Something that can only benefit all Under 18 players by the way.

As for being advised by the Jets. Well thats a different kettle of fish altogether, and something I do not wish to get into at all. I have no time for the Jets.

With regards to Altona "poaching" players. Altona have in no way actively sought out players from other clubs. They have come to Altona of their own accord.

End discussion.
ok will leave at that but there is a part on form
(there was then) to give reason for moving between clubs

we will say they all came on there own accord. and like one of your guys has stated once they pull on the jumper there altona threw and threw, suppose we can say the say so all our flags won by spotty boys

but around about the same time wasnt there an offer made to bachar houli to cross to altona for 60 a game. but thats right the coach was only joking.

so will end it now
 
Joined
Feb 11, 2007
Posts
45
Likes
0
AFL Club
Collingwood
"he took him, blah blah blah, poach this poach that" oh boo hoo, if you were both involved in that 'saga' then you are clearly not involved in the 18s anymore and thats what this thread is about you ********er$, get a life and go hang yourselves if your whinging about an under 18 competition 3-4 years ago.
 
Joined
Sep 10, 2006
Posts
311
Likes
0
AFL Club
Melbourne
the fact of the matter is all those blokes went to a good club and now have a premiship medal if not several after being there for a few years, you ask them what they classify themselves as, there roots to altona are dead and buried and they are thanful for it, that is from them not me!.. Maybe your bitter because you had the opportunity to cross but didnt then got thumped in a grandfinal get over it, we know where the premiships went to stop sooking and lets actually talk about the real issue of this post!!!!!!



BEST UNDER 18 FOOTBALLERS IN WRFL AND BFL 2007!!!!!
 

Kegs44

Club Legend
Joined
Jun 16, 2005
Posts
1,517
Likes
0
Location
no where
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Geelong
the fact of the matter is all those blokes went to a good club and now have a premiship medal if not several after being there for a few years, you ask them what they classify themselves as, there roots to altona are dead and buried and they are thanful for it, that is from them not me!.. Maybe your bitter because you had the opportunity to cross but didnt then got thumped in a grandfinal get over it, we know where the premiships went to stop sooking and lets actually talk about the real issue of this post!!!!!!



BEST UNDER 18 FOOTBALLERS IN WRFL AND BFL 2007!!!!!
Screw the BFL, no-one that writes on this thread is from the BFL

and noshame, granty didnt poach us, we followed him!
 
Joined
Feb 23, 2007
Posts
72
Likes
0
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
"he took him, blah blah blah, poach this poach that" oh boo hoo, if you were both involved in that 'saga' then you are clearly not involved in the 18s anymore and thats what this thread is about you ********er$, get a life and go hang yourselves if your whinging about an under 18 competition 3-4 years ago.
wrong again teriyaki (sure you dont play ping pong) still involved in 18s
if not for blokes like cmat26 your club dont run pal
 
Joined
Sep 10, 2006
Posts
311
Likes
0
AFL Club
Melbourne
You have no idea do you ! There is no point in continuing this arguement with you. It is clearly obvious you don't have the intellectual capacity to see the real issues and talk about them in an appropriate manner. This issue was finished three posts ago. Let it be.

an old idiot like you should just give it a rest and try and get your club on its feet than get on here and worry about how badly your club cant match up to the better ones, chin up poof!


back to the hard nuts of 18's....

shiels
elliot
green
 
Joined
Feb 12, 2007
Posts
134
Likes
0
Location
altona
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Who cares who poached who and whatever went on .... spotty please just stop living in the past.. we all know over the years you have been a very successful club ( noone is doubting that) but im sick and tired of hearing about the past .. lets talk about whats goin on now.. and at the moment yous do seem to be struggling, who cares if u were so good a while ago when ur sh*t now and stop acting like division 2 premierships dont count because if spotswood was in the situation we were in you would certainly claim it.. we were only playin the teams that we were drawn agasint and a premiership is a premiership you still have to win it. altona are on the way to rebuilding a successful senior club and even though its still a few years away i garantee eventually when we are on top spotty will be down low because of some of the spastics they are bringing up through the system
 
Joined
Jan 9, 2007
Posts
96
Likes
0
Location
Goalsquare
AFL Club
St Kilda
an old idiot like you should just give it a rest and try and get your club on its feet than get on here and worry about how badly your club cant match up to the better ones, chin up poof!
u truly are an ignorant moron michael

cmat26 has asked drop the topic for 3 posts now. your the ************** that keeps bringn it up

the next time you post.. dont evn mention it and then itll b droped
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom