Best VFL recruit??

[brjafi]

my vote goes to Jarrod Silvester! coburg to richmond!!!! i have faith in this guy!!

who is yours??

 

[My North]

my vote goes to Jarrod Silvester! coburg to richmond!!!! i have faith in this guy!!

who is yours??

Aaron Davey to Melbourne from Port Melbourne.

 

[onslaught]

Robin Nahas at Richmond has been pretty handy this season too.

 

[Pykie]

Dale Morris
Ben Hudson
Josh Gibson
Michael Firrito
Aaron Davey

Scott Thompson will end up far better than all of them imo, and Morris is a fantastic player.

 

[Mrs Mercuri]

Well Silvester definately isnt the best.... has been delisted by Richmond...

Aaron Davey is my pick... how he didint get drafted i dont know.

 

[brjafi]

thats embarrassing!!!!

still rate him highly as a VFL only player to come through, i obviously dont agree with richmonds choice in delisting him, might get a run at another club good luck to him

 

[Spluff]

He's too slow to make in the AFL, every other quality he has in spades, but as soon as the forward starts running he's nowhere to be seen.

 

[Mitcha]

Liam Picken anyone, comes off a rookie list and holds his spot in a side that finished third. Has Silvester and Nahas covered already. Silvester was never going to succeed at the highest level due to lack of pace and agility and has rightly been delisted, another example of Richmonds lack of expertise in any area whatsoever.

 

[Mitchell Madness]

Sam Mitchell hands down.

 

[brjafi]

Sam Mitchell hands down.

have to agree to that

 

[Trizzy]

not necessarily my vote but nick maxwell is a fair recruit, from North Ballarat to the pies

 

[blueblood25]

Liam Jurrah?

 

[Mitchell Madness]

Liam Jurrah?

dont think jurrah was recruited from the VFL, fairly sure he was recruited from NT. unless you mean players who played VFL, by that logic Lance Franklin

 

[mattys123]

dont think jurrah was recruited from the VFL, fairly sure he was recruited from NT. unless you mean players who played VFL, by that logic Lance Franklin

Well by that logic, Nathan Buckley would be rated slightly ahead of Lance the pants.

 

[Invigoration]

dont think jurrah was recruited from the VFL, fairly sure he was recruited from NT. unless you mean players who played VFL, by that logic Lance Franklin

Er what?

Lance Franklin played VFL when on an AFL list, Jurrah played played the whole year prior to being drafted. Completely different cases, although I believe Jurrah was signed on for the NT for the year he was drafted and only played for Collingwood on a special release which I guess is why it states he was still recruited from whatever his NT club was called (cbf'd looking it up).

I'd view him as a VFL recruit though.

 

[jim boy]

Matthew Egan was none-too-shabby before his foot injury

 

[ben_cats_fan]

Matthew Egan was none-too-shabby before his foot injury

Exactly what I was thinking! No love for Egan?

 

[DannyJ]

Mitchell would be close

 

[Steven Tyler]

David King. Recruited from Port Melbourne to North. Duel All Australian, duel Premiership player, Victorian Rep on several occasions, 240-odd AFL games.

 

[Pigdog]

Matthew Boyd was rookied by the Bulldogs whilst playing reserves at Frankston.

 

[GUMBLETRON]

Keith Greig or Kevin Sheedy.

 

[#29_Pavlich!!]

for 2010 big wraps for the dockers 2 in Silvagni and Barlow

 

[Innit]

Mitch for sure, made an immediate impact.
Davey in terms of the rookie draft..

Interested to see how Pods goes at the cats, personally i think it is a steal

 

[Wally Carter]

Keith Greig - Brunswick

 

[My North]

Mitch for sure, made an immediate impact.
Davey in terms of the rookie draft..

Interested to see how Pods goes at the cats, personally i think it is a steal

Agree on Pods. Rate him high.