Best Young Ruckman

[cotter101]

Average stats for Leunberger, Naitanui and Goldstein.

Leuenberger: Kicks 7.8, Handballs 7.8, Disposals 15.5, Marks 4.1, Hitouts 32.9, Tackles 2.4, Goals 0.2.

Naitanui: Kicks 5.1, Handballs 7.9, Disposals 13, Marks 2.4, Hitouts 18.9, Tackles 3.9, Goals 0.8.

Goldstein: Kicks 7.2, Handballs 6.5, Disposals 13.7, Marks 3.5, Hitouts 35.3, Tackles 4.4, Goals 0.6.

Bold= that a player won that stat.

Leuenberger wins 3 stats whilst Naitanui and Goldstein win 2.

Leuenberger averages 83% of gametime

Naitanui averages 78.3% of gametime

Goldstein averages 93 % of gametime

SO I think Naitanui and Leueunberger beat Goldstein.

 

[alex 17]

Average stats for Leunberger, Naitanui and Goldstein.

Leuenberger: Kicks 7.8, Handballs 7.8, Disposals 15.5, Marks 4.1, Hitouts 32.9, Tackles 2.4, Goals 0.2.

Naitanui: Kicks 5.1, Handballs 7.9, Disposals 13, Marks 2.4, Hitouts 18.9, Tackles 3.9, Goals 0.8.

Goldstein: Kicks 7.2, Handballs 6.5, Disposals 13.7, Marks 3.5, Hitouts 35.3, Tackles 4.4, Goals 0.6.

Bold= that a player won that stat.

Leuenberger wins 3 stats whilst Naitanui and Goldstein win 2.

Leuenberger averages 83% of gametime

Naitanui averages 78.3% of gametime

Goldstein averages 93 % of gametime

SO I think Naitanui and Leueunberger beat Goldstein.

If they beat Goldstein then why were Natanui and Leuenberger never close to even getting a spot in the AA squad??

Your going by stats not consistency. As far as consistency is concerned Goldstein has comfortably been the second best ruck in the game this year with even Mumford argubly ahead of Luey and Natanui.

Goldstein is ranked #1 in the comp for hitouts to advantage which also sets him a part from the others.

 

[dane000]

If they beat Goldstein then why were Natanui and Leuenberger never close to even getting a spot in the AA squad?

how do you know that?

 

[Patron]

Average stats for Leunberger, Naitanui and Goldstein.

Leuenberger: Kicks 7.8, Handballs 7.8, Disposals 15.5, Marks 4.1, Hitouts 32.9, Tackles 2.4, Goals 0.2.

Naitanui: Kicks 5.1, Handballs 7.9, Disposals 13, Marks 2.4, Hitouts 18.9, Tackles 3.9, Goals 0.8.

Goldstein: Kicks 7.2, Handballs 6.5, Disposals 13.7, Marks 3.5, Hitouts 35.3, Tackles 4.4, Goals 0.6.

Bold= that a player won that stat.

Leuenberger wins 3 stats whilst Naitanui and Goldstein win 2.

Leuenberger averages 83% of gametime

Naitanui averages 78.3% of gametime

Goldstein averages 93 % of gametime

SO I think Naitanui and Leueunberger beat Goldstein.

Don't know where you got your gametime stats from but according to AFL.com Naitanui plays 71% and Goldstein 89%

 

[Daz]

Average stats for Leunberger, Naitanui and Goldstein.

Leuenberger: Kicks 7.8, Handballs 7.8, Disposals 15.5, Marks 4.1, Hitouts 32.9, Tackles 2.4, Goals 0.2.

Naitanui: Kicks 5.1, Handballs 7.9, Disposals 13, Marks 2.4, Hitouts 18.9, Tackles 3.9, Goals 0.8.

Goldstein: Kicks 7.2, Handballs 6.5, Disposals 13.7, Marks 3.5, Hitouts 35.3, Tackles 4.4, Goals 0.6.

Bold= that a player won that stat.

Leuenberger wins 3 stats whilst Naitanui and Goldstein win 2.

Leuenberger averages 83% of gametime

Naitanui averages 78.3% of gametime

Goldstein averages 93 % of gametime

SO I think Naitanui and Leueunberger beat Goldstein.

Haha that is ridiculous logic. Head to head, Goldy has better stats than both of them.

He's also a better user of the footy.

Don't know where you got your gametime stats from but according to AFL.com Naitanui plays 71% and Goldstein 89%

For some reason AFL.com TOG stats are based on 22 games. So Goldstein has played 89% of the full season, not 89% of the 21 games he played.

 

[Patron]

Ohk thats weird.

I don't think theirs too much argument atm that Goldstein is currently the best young ruckman.
But i don't think he's going to end up the best.

 

[lmach]

Leuenberger has beat Cox and Nic Nat comfortably tonight.

LOL he was smashed by Nic Nat a couple of weeks ago.

How i rate them:

1. Naitanui
2. Goldstein
3. McEvoy
4. Leunberger
5. Smith
6. Kruezer
7. Clarke
8. Jacobs
9. Bellchambers