BFL Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
ab Rodriguez said:
Bacchus Marsh INS:
Scott Sherlock (Werribee VFL)
Dean Heta (Wodonga Raiders)
Ryley Stuhldreier (Sth Barwon)
Alex Sweet (Melton Centrals)
Dylan prozzo ? (Ballan)
Todd Delahey ? (Ballan)marsh
Dillon Viojo-Rainbow (VFL)*
Brenton Payne (VFL)*
Jacob Wheelehan (VFL)*
Daniel Foley (VFL)*

Bacchus Marsh OUTS:
Damien Cupido (Bairnsdale)
Cam Richardson (Gordon)
Ricky Hawkins (Darley)
Ben Speight (Wangaratta)*didn't play a game

Darley INS:
Heath Scotland (Doncaster)
Jackson Carrick (Hepburn/roosters)
Brian Graham (Wyndham Vale)
Chris Graham (Wyndham Vale)
Abe Kur (VFL)*
Dan Roy (Sth Barwon)
Jay Pearson (Dooncaster)
Lachlan Herring (Ballan)
Kyle Doyle (Ballan)
Nick Thacker (Ballan)
Ricky Hawkins (Bacchus Marsh)


Darley OUTS:
Steve Kennedy (Altona)
Richard Knight (Altona)
Anthony Chui (Retired?)
Scott McAllister (Retired?)

Melton INS:
Ben Archard (Central Murray FL)
Tom Button (VFL)*
Angus Grigg (Aberfeldie)
Matthew Gunn (Caroline Springs)
Matt Huckstepp (EDFL)
Dylan Kight (Return from cricket)
Matt Poland (Hoppers Crossing)


Melton OUTS:
Lachlan Sidebottom (Heathcote FL)
Matthew Notman (Melton Sth)
Corey Patmore (EDFL)


Melton South INS:
Brendan Fevola (Deer Park)
Mark Lynch (Aberfeldie)
Matthew Notman (Melton)
Adam Houli (Deer Park)
Mozzie Houli (EDFL)
Ben Peters (Gordon)
Mitch Banner (VFL)*
Nick Kommer (AFL)
Jeremy Krojs (Gordon)
+ God knows who else :drunk:

Sunbury OUTS:
Josh Burgess (Sunbury Kangaroos)
Jack Landt (Doutta Stars)
Ben & Jesse Mcinneny (Sunshine)
Joe Redfern (NSW)
Grant Valles (Overseas first half of year)
Chris Tsardakis (RDFL)


*Denotes Home Club
Click to expand...
Thanks for that
Still think that Bacchus marsh are still the team to best
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Little secret said:
I suppose it would of been a great idea for south to shell out the coin and let other clubs promote fev playing there early on in the season and make big bucks
Click to expand...

I have seen a few photos on social media of Fev, is he planning on playing.. He looks like he is on the Lance Whitnall diet and certainly does not look like he has been putting in hard yards on the track and in match condition. Is he really going to play, or just coach?
 
Graceland said:
Didn't South play hard ball when clearing Notman when he 1st decided to go to Melton?Now the shoe is on the other foot


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Click to expand...
Melton Sth cleared Matty Notman straight away when he wanted to leave. He was contracted but had a falling out with a previous coach. So we cleared him with hope down the track he might return. Why would we want a bloke as good as noddy was be at yr club if he didn't want to be there. He was cleared and wished all the best. It bloody hurt when he dominated against us but that's footy. He wanted to come back finish playing with his mates and to help coach.
Take this to the bank we will be going to appeals next week but if it doesn't work out he misses a year of footy because he won't go back to Melton. And for someone who gave Melton 4 years of great service I reckon he needs to be respected and granted his wish.
But believe me if any player wants to leave us to go to Melton in the future it will be made very hard. Let's just hope it all works out for Matt who just wants to play footy with his mates.
 
its tiger time said:
Melton Sth cleared Matty Notman straight away when he wanted to leave. He was contracted but had a falling out with a previous club. So we cleared him with hope down the track he might return. Why would we want a bloke as good as noddy was be at yr club if he didn't want to be there. He was cleared and wished all the best. It bloody hurt when he dominated against us but that's footy. He wanted to come back finish playing with his mates and to help coach.
Take this to the bank we will be going to appeals next week but if it doesn't work out he misses a year of footy because he won't go back to Melton. And for someone who gave Melton 4 years of great service I reckon he needs to be respected and granted his wish.
But believe me if any player wants to leave us to go to Melton in the future it will be made very hard. Let's just hope it all works out for Matt who just wants to play footy with his mates.
Click to expand...

Not questioning this bloke in this instance but you never here of blokes changing clubs to sides are going to be battlers to "play with their mates"
 
its tiger time said:
Melton Sth cleared Matty Notman straight away when he wanted to leave. He was contracted but had a falling out with a previous coach. So we cleared him with hope down the track he might return. Why would we want a bloke as good as noddy was be at yr club if he didn't want to be there. He was cleared and wished all the best. It bloody hurt when he dominated against us but that's footy. He wanted to come back finish playing with his mates and to help coach.
Take this to the bank we will be going to appeals next week but if it doesn't work out he misses a year of footy because he won't go back to Melton. And for someone who gave Melton 4 years of great service I reckon he needs to be respected and granted his wish.
But believe me if any player wants to leave us to go to Melton in the future it will be made very hard. Let's just hope it all works out for Matt who just wants to play footy with his mates.
Click to expand...


Always find it completely ridiculous that a club would not clear a player.. Its actually absurd that they actually need to be cleared to change clubs. The only grounds for a player not being cleared is if he has signed a sign on fee and is contracted or for some ressies players if they havent paid there subs and owe the club money.. Outside of that it is a free market and ridiculous that a player can not choose where he wants to play footy each year.
 
ItsAllAboutMe said:
Always find it completely ridiculous that a club would not clear a player.. Its actually absurd that they actually need to be cleared to change clubs. The only grounds for a player not being cleared is if he has signed a sign on fee and is contracted or for some ressies players if they havent paid there subs and owe the club money.. Outside of that it is a free market and ridiculous that a player can not choose where he wants to play footy each year.
Click to expand...

So by your own reasoning, he should not be cleared. He signed a contract. There is no way South will win an appeal over a clearance for a contracted player. Ask Horbury at Redan. As for sign on fees, they are banned & would never even be considered by an appeals tribunal. If clubs are still stupid enough to throw around sign on fees & the player does a runner, tough. The message to players is simple. If you sign a contract to play for a club, don't try to back out of it if a better offer comes along.
 
merrigan said:
So by your own reasoning, he should not be cleared. He signed a contract. There is no way South will win an appeal over a clearance for a contracted player. Ask Horbury at Redan. As for sign on fees, they are banned & would never even be considered by an appeals tribunal. If clubs are still stupid enough to throw around sign on fees & the player does a runner, tough. The message to players is simple. If you sign a contract to play for a club, don't try to back out of it if a better offer comes along.
Click to expand...
Works in business and afl
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

merrigan said:
So by your own reasoning, he should not be cleared. He signed a contract. There is no way South will win an appeal over a clearance for a contracted player. Ask Horbury at Redan. As for sign on fees, they are banned & would never even be considered by an appeals tribunal. If clubs are still stupid enough to throw around sign on fees & the player does a runner, tough. The message to players is simple. If you sign a contract to play for a club, don't try to back out of it if a better offer comes along.
Click to expand...

Half of this is correct, AFL Vic are pretty cut and dry on their rulings when it comes to contracts.

As for sign on fees, they are not banned, they are "frowned upon".
 
Itsmyshow said:
Half of this is correct, AFL Vic are pretty cut and dry on their rulings when it comes to contracts.

As for sign on fees, they are not banned, they are "frowned upon".
Click to expand...

According to clause 10.3 of AFL Vics salary cap policy they are not allowed. Or banned. Regardless, they are not a valid reason to refuse a clearance. Contracts are.
 
merrigan said:
According to clause 10.3 of AFL Vics salary cap policy they are not allowed. Or banned. Regardless, they are not a valid reason to refuse a clearance. Contracts are.
Click to expand...

You're reading the first version, AFL lawyers had the clause removed because it couldn't be enforced.
 
Itsmyshow said:
You're reading the first version, AFL lawyers had the clause removed because it couldn't be enforced.
Click to expand...

Ok thanks. Fair to say it would still be under the table stuff anyway. If it was out in the open it would have to be declared in the cap, couldn't see that happening. Seen a few clubs burnt by players not honouring sign ons in the past, I don't know why they persist with it. A famous ex St.Kilda star took sign ons from 3 different clubs then did a runner to WA a few years back.
 
There are so many ways around the salary cap that its silly to bother.. Fev will no doubt host a sportsman night where he could get 100% of revenue, he pays Brent Thornton & Nick Kommer to speak $10k. So many examples of how clubs will easily get around staying within the salary cap.
 
ItsAllAboutMe said:
There are so many ways around the salary cap that its silly to bother.. Fev will no doubt host a sportsman night where he could get 100% of revenue, he pays Brent Thornton & Nick Kommer to speak $10k. So many examples of how clubs will easily get around staying within the salary cap.
Click to expand...
All of that is included in the cap which is why their paperwork needs to be in order. For their sake I hope they don't get investigated. That would be a terrible shame.
 
Alabama Slammer said:
All of that is included in the cap which is why their paperwork needs to be in order. For their sake I hope they don't get investigated. That would be a terrible shame.
Click to expand...

That situation would be a private business matter so why would it be in the salary cap?
 
ItsAllAboutMe said:
What if he leased the function rooms from the club and held the function independently of the footy club..
Click to expand...

If investigated, they would put it under the cap.

AFL Vic will be eager to land a big fish breach early, the actual scope of their powers to include things like this is quite broad.
 
Itsmyshow said:
If investigated, they would put it under the cap.

AFL Vic will be eager to land a big fish breach early, the actual scope of their powers to include things like this is quite broad.
Click to expand...


So you can't run a sportsmens night at your own club cause the afl Vic know they have loop holes and that will make them look silly? Making it hard for blokes to make an income outside of afl if that's the case
 
ab Rodriguez said:
Bacchus Marsh INS:
Scott Sherlock (Werribee VFL)
Dean Heta (Wodonga Raiders)
Ryley Stuhldreier (Sth Barwon)
Alex Sweet (Melton Centrals)
Dylan prozzo (Ballan)
Todd Delahey (Ballan)
Dillon Viojo-Rainbow (VFL)*
Brenton Payne (VFL)*
Jacob Wheelehan (VFL)*
Daniel Foley (VFL)*

Bacchus Marsh OUTS:
Damien Cupido (Bairnsdale)
Cam Richardson (Gordon)
Ricky Hawkins (Darley)
Coby Millar (VAFA)
Ben Speight (Wangaratta)*didn't play a game

Darley INS:
Heath Scotland (Doncaster)
Jackson Carrick (Hepburn/roosters)
Brian Graham (Wyndham Vale)
Chris Graham (Wyndham Vale)
Abe Kur (VFL)*
Dan Roy (Colac)
Jay Pearson (Dooncaster)
Lachlan Herring (Ballan)
Kyle Doyle (Ballan)
Nick Thacker (Ballan)
Ricky Hawkins (Bacchus Marsh)


Darley OUTS:
Steve Kennedy (Altona)
Richard Knight (Altona)
Anthony Chui (Retired?)
Scott McAllister (Retired?)
Jarrod Edwards (Retired?)
Mitch Banner (VFL/South)

Melton INS:
Ben Archard (Central Murray FL)
Tom Button (VFL)*
Angus Grigg (Aberfeldie)
Matthew Gunn (Caroline Springs)
Matt Huckstepp (EDFL)
Dylan Kight (Return from cricket)
Matt Poland (Hoppers Crossing)


Melton OUTS:
Lachlan Sidebottom (Heathcote FL)
Matthew Notman (Melton Sth)
Corey Patmore (EDFL)


Melton South INS:
Brendan Fevola (Deer Park)
Mark Lynch (Aberfeldie)
Matthew Notman (Melton)
Adam Houli (Deer Park)
Mozzie Houli (EDFL)
Ben Peters (Gordon)
Mitch Banner (VFL)*
Nick Kommer (AFL)
Jeremy Krojs (Gordon)


Sunbury OUTS:
Josh Burgess (RDFL)
Jack Landt (Doutta Stars)
Ben & Jesse Mcinneny (Sunshine)
Joe Redfern (NSW)
Grant Valles (Overseas first half of year)
Chris Tsardakis (RDFL)
Matt Medcraft (Queensland)
Jack Sullivan (Work)

*Denotes Home Club
Click to expand...

Few updates. Medcraft to Qld
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

TheGreatBambino
  • Sticky
BFL discussion 2024
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
142
Views
13K
Spudman
S
TheGreatBambino
BFL discussion 2023
17 18 19 20 21
Replies
509
Views
61K
TheGreatBambino
TheGreatBambino

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top