Big game match ups for 2012

toeknee2

Senior List
Joined
Jan 23, 2008
Posts
224
Likes
7
Location
northcote
AFL Club
Carlton
Thread starter #1
Collingwood vs Carlton

Maxwell vs Thornton, Tarrant vs Waite, Toovey vs Walker
O'Brien vs Garlett, Reid vs Rowe, Shaw vs Betts
Wellingham vs Simpson, Swan vs Judd, Thomas vs Gibbs
Krakouer vs Yarran, Cloke vs Henderson, Didak vs Scotland
Macaffer vs Duigan, Dawes vs Jamison, Blair vs Joseph

FOLL: Jolly vs Warnock, Pendlebury vs Murphy, Ball vs Robinson


COLL INT: Sidebottom, Beams, Brown Sub: Johnson
CARL INT: Kruezer, Ellard, Laidler Sub: Carrazzo


Hawthorn vs Carlton

Guerra vs Walker, Gibson vs Waite, Suckling vs Thornton
Birchall vs Betts, Gilham vs Rowe, Puopolo vs Garlett
Smith vs Simpson, Mitchell vs Robinson, Shiels vs Gibbs
Whitecross vs Duigan, Franklin vs Jamison, Lewis vs Scotland
Rioli vs Yarran, Roughead vs Henderson, Bruest vs Russell


Foll: Hale vs Warnock, Hodge vs Judd, Sewell vs Murphy

Hawks Int: Bailey, Savage, Burgoyne Sub: Ellis
Blues Int: Kruezer, Laidler, Ellard, Sub:Carrazzo
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Jellycup_84

Senior List
Joined
Nov 1, 2008
Posts
244
Likes
46
Location
Bundaberg
AFL Club
Carlton
#2
Collingwood vs Carlton

Maxwell vs Thornton, Tarrant vs Waite, Toovey vs Walker
O'Brien vs Garlett, Reid vs Rowe, Shaw vs Betts
Wellingham vs Simpson, Swan vs Judd, Thomas vs Gibbs
Krakouer vs Yarran, Cloke vs Henderson, Didak vs Scotland
Macaffer vs Duigan, Dawes vs Jamison, Blair vs Joseph

FOLL: Jolly vs Warnock, Pendlebury vs Murphy, Ball vs Robinson


COLL INT: Sidebottom, Beams, Brown Sub: Johnson
CARL INT: Kruezer, Ellard, Laidler Sub: Carrazzo


Hawthorn vs Carlton

Guerra vs Walker, Gibson vs Waite, Suckling vs Thornton
Birchall vs Betts, Gilham vs Rowe, Puopolo vs Garlett
Smith vs Simpson, Mitchell vs Robinson, Shiels vs Gibbs
Whitecross vs Duigan, Franklin vs Jamison, Lewis vs Scotland
Rioli vs Yarran, Roughead vs Henderson, Bruest vs Russell

Foll: Hale vs Warnock, Hodge vs Judd, Sewell vs Murphy

Hawks Int: Bailey, Savage, Burgoyne Sub: Ellis
Blues Int: Kruezer, Laidler, Ellard, Sub:Carrazzo
would be rioli v joseph...

joseph has played on cyril multiple time and won multiple times
 

Scodog10

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jul 25, 2008
Posts
17,138
Likes
24,177
Location
The Linc
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Oakland Raiders
#4
Collingwood vs Carlton

Maxwell vs Thornton, Tarrant vs Waite, Toovey vs Walker
O'Brien vs Garlett, Reid vs Rowe, Shaw vs Betts
Wellingham vs Simpson, Swan vs Judd, Thomas vs Gibbs
Krakouer vs Yarran, Cloke vs Henderson, Didak vs Scotland
Macaffer vs Duigan, Dawes vs Jamison, Blair vs Joseph

FOLL: Jolly vs Warnock, Pendlebury vs Murphy, Ball vs Robinson


COLL INT: Sidebottom, Beams, Brown Sub: Johnson
CARL INT: Kruezer, Ellard, Laidler Sub: Carrazzo
FWIW Brown is now an assistant coach at Melbourne so may struggle to play too many games with the pies this year :thumbsu:
 

toeknee2

Senior List
Joined
Jan 23, 2008
Posts
224
Likes
7
Location
northcote
AFL Club
Carlton
Thread starter #7
Sorry if this has been done already. Just thought I would like to see how we matched up on each line. Collingwood supporters believe they have better backs, mids and forwards.

The hawks also think they have a better team full stop. Time will tell.

Scodog I got their team off their own website where they put together their best 22 at the end of the 2011 season.
 

Scodog10

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jul 25, 2008
Posts
17,138
Likes
24,177
Location
The Linc
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Oakland Raiders
#8
I thought it was a possibility when I first looked at the squad, but after coming off 2 separate knee injuries last year I doubt he'd play as our second ruckman (considering Jolly was the only ruckman toeknee2 named).

toeknee2 said:
Scodog I got their team off their own website where they put together their best 22 at the end of the 2011 season.
That would explain things then as I'm not a big fan of the content that has come out my club online in the past 18 months.

Sharks On A Plane said:
The failure of the GF is clearly still fresh...
Of course it is, what sort of supporter would I be if it wasn't? However I'd imagine that it's just as fresh as your's would be over the loss to West Coast when IMO you were robbed due to the Walker free kick. Both mine and your team will be looking to make amends along with the Hawks meaning an interesting season awaits us.

Also I can understand why there could be a negative reaction when the enemy posts on your board (especially when it seems to be in such a sarcastic manner), but I have a dry wit so should probably just point out that my comments were intended as a minor correction rather than a jibe :thumbsu:
 

ESKIE

Keeping it Cool.
Joined
Feb 28, 2009
Posts
24,902
Likes
31,300
AFL Club
Carlton
#9
I thought it was a possibility when I first looked at the squad, but after coming off 2 separate knee injuries last year I doubt he'd play as our second ruckman (considering Jolly was the only ruckman toeknee2 named).



That would explain things then as I'm not a big fan of the content that has come out my club online in the past 18 months.



Of course it is, what sort of supporter would I be if it wasn't? However I'd imagine that it's just as fresh as your's would be over the loss to West Coast when IMO you were robbed due to the Walker free kick. Both mine and your team will be looking to make amends along with the Hawks meaning an interesting season awaits us.

Also I can understand why there could be a negative reaction when the enemy posts on your board (especially when it seems to be in such a sarcastic manner), but I have a dry wit so should probably just point out that my comments were intended as a minor correction rather than a jibe :thumbsu:

Agree, the big Pies Blues GF may not be too far away, having pulpatations just thinking of it, :)
 

Blue Dangerfield

All Australian
Joined
Jan 29, 2012
Posts
877
Likes
823
Location
Blue Mountains
AFL Club
Carlton
#10
I feel bad for posing a question I couldn't possibly answer myself but, what does everything think for match ups in the intra club matches

for me the key ones would be jammo would need to play on the all three of the top 3 KPF contenders at some stage to really run through their paces. (maybe not in the same game)

Watson too would need to be in that same position to run him through his places.

ellard, joseph, mcclean, lucas all need to play on each other

Bower and Waite just because it would be interesting after last year.

laidler vs walker?
joseph vs gartlett
simpson vs lucas
carrots vs judd/murph/gibbs (not at once clearly)

any others?
 
Top Bottom