Phantom Draft Big_Newon Phantom Draft

Remove this Banner Ad

briztoon

Wannabe Draft Nuffie
Nov 28, 2015
16,187
16,643
Brisbane
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Other Teams
NUFC, Philadelphia 76'ers
Please keep feedback constructive, no need to rip into someone having a crack because you don't agree on the rating of a player
There are a lot of picks here that don’t make sense, especially in regards to perceived team needs, not to mention way different rankings.


Not to mention Richmond absolutely clean up.
 

PMBangers

@Headless approved!
Nov 7, 2017
16,434
28,536
Melbourne
AFL Club
GWS
Other Teams
Manchester City, Collingwood AFLW
There are a lot of picks here that don’t make sense, especially in regards to perceived team needs, not to mention way different rankings.


Not to mention Richmond absolutely clean up.
Way different rankings aren't a bad thing, comparing and trying to understand why people rate prospects differently is a great tool.

I disagree that Richmond clean up
 

Log in to remove this ad.

blueiris

Norm Smith Medallist
Aug 16, 2010
7,156
4,263
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
**This is not a criticism**

You have Arlo Draper being drafted by both Fremantle and Bulldogs.

Josh Faye is tied to GWS, who will 100% match the bid. There is no restriction on Northern academies matching their kids in the first round.

Erasmus is a good first pick for Brisbane. Would have preferred Jacob Van Rooyen.


**this is an observation**
Whoa, buck the truck up, how is Josh Goater not drafted by anyone? I would be throwing a shoe at the television if we passed on Goater if he was still available.
JVR probably plays as a defender at AFL level injuries to Gardiner and Adams may suggest we go that way but what happens to players like Payne and Lester
 

briztoon

Wannabe Draft Nuffie
Nov 28, 2015
16,187
16,643
Brisbane
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Other Teams
NUFC, Philadelphia 76'ers
JVR probably plays as a defender at AFL level injuries to Gardiner and Adams may suggest we go that way but what happens to players like Payne and Lester
Payne needs games in to him at AFL level to develop.

Lester is depth, a break glass in emergency, type depth.

If we draft some key defender and medium sized defenders, Lester probably stays on the rookie list, then delisted when the young defenders push in to the first team.
 

Mr north man

Club Legend
Mar 12, 2016
1,943
1,316
AFL Club
North Melbourne
On behalf of North we reluctantly accept Horne and Goater.
Why Not just take Horne at 1 why muck around by bidding on Darcy and Daicos as I believe is better then both of them.
It would a shot into the arm of Horne that we have the utter respect for him as the number 1 pick not the 3rd pick.
 

Wild Bill

Brownlow Medallist
May 28, 2013
22,196
22,981
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Seattle Seahawks
Why Not just take Horne at 1 why muck around by bidding on Darcy and Daicos as I believe is better then both of them.
It would a shot into the arm of Horne that we have the utter respect for him as the number 1 pick not the 3rd pick.
I think he is smart enough to know why we would bid on the other 2 - like the Crows did with JUH.

Knocking 2 teams out of the draft improves the rest of our draft picks.
 

Joao

Brownlow Medallist
May 2, 2017
14,262
25,449
QLD
AFL Club
Fremantle
I would be beyond surprised if Freo called out a key defender first. In fact, I'd be flying over to Cockburn to start a riot. We might take a flanker but only if they had genuine speed.

The club has openly said it is chasing speed and a ruck/forward if that helps. Bizarrely we don't seem to think key forwards are a need.
 

theGav56

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 11, 2004
24,202
21,006
Bali
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
Fremantle
I would be beyond surprised if Freo called out a key defender first. In fact, I'd be flying over to Cockburn to start a riot. We might take a flanker but only if they had genuine speed.

The club has openly said it is chasing speed and a ruck/forward if that helps. Bizarrely we don't seem to think key forwards are a need.
Or, less bizarrely, we don't want to advertise our draft targets.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

End of round 23 Phantom Draft New

Big_Newon

Rookie
Jul 12, 2021
38
26
AFL Club
Richmond
1st round:

Pick 1: Collingwood: Nick Daicos

Pick 2: Western Bulldogs: Sam Darcy

Pick 3: North Melbourne: Jason Horne

Pick 4: GWS: Mac Andrew

Pick 5: Gold Coast: Josh Gibcus

Pick 6: Adelaide: Finn Callaghan

Pick 7: Hawthorn: Josh Ward

Pick 8: Carlton: Josh Rachele

Pick 9: Richmond: Matthew Roberts

Pick 10: Fremantle: Neil Erasmus

Pick 11: St Kilda: Jye Amiss

Pick 12: Gold Coast: Bodhi Uwhland

Pick 13: West Coast: Ben Hobbs

Pick 14: Essendon: Jack Williams

Pick 15: GWS: Arlo Draper

Pick 16: Sydney: Josh Sinn

Pick 17: Western Bulldogs: Sam Butler

Pick 18: Brisbane: Jacob Van Rooyen

Pick 19: Richmond: Tyler Sonsie

Pick 20: Port Adelaide: Campbell Chesser

Pick 21: Brisbane: Darcy Wilmot

2nd round:

Pick 22: Gold Coast: Toby Conway

Pick 23: North Melbourne: Josh Goater

Pick 24: Hawthorn: Matthew Johnson

Pick 25: Gold Coast: Blake Schlensog

Pick 26: Adelaide: Connor Macdonald

Pick 27: Hawthorn: Zac Taylor

Pick 28: Carlton: Joshua Browne

Pick 29: Richmond: Judson Clarke

Pick 30: Fremantle: Hugh Jackson

Pick 31: Richmond: Jesse Motlop

Pick 32: GWS: Josh Fahey

Pick 33: West Coast: Mitch Knevitt

Pick 34: Geelong: Tom Brown

Pick 35: Geelong: Blake Howes

Pick 36: Sydney: Rhett Bazzo

Pick 37: Collingwood: Jake Soligo

Pick 38: Melbourne: Lewis Rayson:

Pick 39: Geelong: Nasiah Wanganeen Milera

Pick 40: West Coast: Cooper Murley

Pick 41: St Kilda: Michito Owens

Pick 42: West Coast: Kade Dittmar
 

briztoon

Wannabe Draft Nuffie
Nov 28, 2015
16,187
16,643
Brisbane
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Other Teams
NUFC, Philadelphia 76'ers
1st round:

Pick 1: Collingwood: Nick Daicos

Pick 2: Western Bulldogs: Sam Darcy

Pick 3: North Melbourne: Jason Horne

Pick 4: GWS: Mac Andrew

Pick 5: Gold Coast: Josh Gibcus

Pick 6: Adelaide: Finn Callaghan

Pick 7: Hawthorn: Josh Ward

Pick 8: Carlton: Josh Rachele

Pick 9: Richmond: Matthew Roberts

Pick 10: Fremantle: Neil Erasmus

Pick 11: St Kilda: Jye Amiss

Pick 12: Gold Coast: Bodhi Uwhland

Pick 13: West Coast: Ben Hobbs

Pick 14: Essendon: Jack Williams

Pick 15: GWS: Arlo Draper

Pick 16: Sydney: Josh Sinn

Pick 17: Western Bulldogs: Sam Butler

Pick 18: Brisbane: Jacob Van Rooyen

Pick 19: Richmond: Tyler Sonsie

Pick 20: Port Adelaide: Campbell Chesser

Pick 21: Brisbane: Darcy Wilmot

2nd round:

Pick 22: Gold Coast: Toby Conway

Pick 23: North Melbourne: Josh Goater

Pick 24: Hawthorn: Matthew Johnson

Pick 25: Gold Coast: Blake Schlensog

Pick 26: Adelaide: Connor Macdonald

Pick 27: Hawthorn: Zac Taylor

Pick 28: Carlton: Joshua Browne

Pick 29: Richmond: Judson Clarke

Pick 30: Fremantle: Hugh Jackson

Pick 31: Richmond: Jesse Motlop

Pick 32: GWS: Josh Fahey

Pick 33: West Coast: Mitch Knevitt

Pick 34: Geelong: Tom Brown

Pick 35: Geelong: Blake Howes

Pick 36: Sydney: Rhett Bazzo

Pick 37: Collingwood: Jake Soligo

Pick 38: Melbourne: Lewis Rayson:

Pick 39: Geelong: Nasiah Wanganeen Milera

Pick 40: West Coast: Cooper Murley

Pick 41: St Kilda: Michito Owens

Pick 42: West Coast: Kade Dittmar
If you’re going to have bids matched, you need to learn which picks clubs will lose.

WB will lose pick 17. GC will lose pick 22. Collingwood will lose pick 37.
 

Dominic03

All Australian
Oct 28, 2020
831
697
AFL Club
Hawthorn
1st round:

Pick 1: Collingwood: Nick Daicos

Pick 2: Western Bulldogs: Sam Darcy

Pick 3: North Melbourne: Jason Horne

Pick 4: GWS: Mac Andrew

Pick 5: Gold Coast: Josh Gibcus

Pick 6: Adelaide: Finn Callaghan

Pick 7: Hawthorn: Josh Ward

Pick 8: Carlton: Josh Rachele

Pick 9: Richmond: Matthew Roberts

Pick 10: Fremantle: Neil Erasmus

Pick 11: St Kilda: Jye Amiss

Pick 12: Gold Coast: Bodhi Uwhland

Pick 13: West Coast: Ben Hobbs

Pick 14: Essendon: Jack Williams

Pick 15: GWS: Arlo Draper

Pick 16: Sydney: Josh Sinn

Pick 17: Western Bulldogs: Sam Butler

Pick 18: Brisbane: Jacob Van Rooyen

Pick 19: Richmond: Tyler Sonsie

Pick 20: Port Adelaide: Campbell Chesser

Pick 21: Brisbane: Darcy Wilmot

2nd round:

Pick 22: Gold Coast: Toby Conway

Pick 23: North Melbourne: Josh Goater

Pick 24: Hawthorn: Matthew Johnson

Pick 25: Gold Coast: Blake Schlensog

Pick 26: Adelaide: Connor Macdonald

Pick 27: Hawthorn: Zac Taylor

Pick 28: Carlton: Joshua Browne

Pick 29: Richmond: Judson Clarke

Pick 30: Fremantle: Hugh Jackson

Pick 31: Richmond: Jesse Motlop

Pick 32: GWS: Josh Fahey

Pick 33: West Coast: Mitch Knevitt

Pick 34: Geelong: Tom Brown

Pick 35: Geelong: Blake Howes

Pick 36: Sydney: Rhett Bazzo

Pick 37: Collingwood: Jake Soligo

Pick 38: Melbourne: Lewis Rayson:

Pick 39: Geelong: Nasiah Wanganeen Milera

Pick 40: West Coast: Cooper Murley

Pick 41: St Kilda: Michito Owens

Pick 42: West Coast: Kade Dittmar
Hawthorn: Erasmus
 
September Phantom Draft New

Big_Newon

Rookie
Jul 12, 2021
38
26
AFL Club
Richmond
Pick 1: Collingwood: Nick Daicos

Pick 2: Western Bulldogs: Sam Darcy

Pick 3: North Melbourne: Jason Horne-Francis

Pick 4: GWS: Finn Callaghan

Pick 5: Gold Coast: Josh Gibcus

Pick 6: Adelaide: Josh Ward

Pick 7: Hawthorn: Neil Erasmus

Pick 8: Carlton: Josh Rachele

Pick 9: Richmond: Ben Hobbs

Pick 10: Fremantle: Jye Amiss

Pick 11: St Kilda: Arlo Draper

Pick 12: West Coast: Josh Sinn

Pick 13: Essendon: Josh Goater

Pick 14: Sydney: Mac Andrew

Pick 15: GWS: Campbell Chesser

Pick 16: Brisbane: Jack Williams

Pick 17: Richmond (Western Bulldogs lose their pick because of Sam Darcy): Jacob Van Rooyen

Pick 18: Port Adelaide: Matthew Roberts

Pick 19: Gold Coast: Bodhi Uwhland

Pick 20: Brisbane: Darcy Wilmot

Pick 21: North Melbourne (gold coast pick gets moved back to 62 because of bodhi Uwhland): Judson Clarke

Pick 22: Hawthorn: Tyler Sonsie

Pick 23: Gold Coast: Tom Brown

Pick 24: Adelaide: Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera

Pick 25: Hawthorn: Zac Taylor

Pick 26: Carlton: Leek Aleer

Pick 27: Richmond: Rhett Bazzo

Pick 28: Fremantle: Jesse Motlop

Pick 29: Richmond: Sam Butler

Pick 30: GWS: Josh Fahey

Pick 31: West Coast: Matthew Johnson

Pick 32: Geelong: Toby Conway

Pick 33: Sydney: Blake Howes

Pick 34: Geelong: Mitch Knevitt

Pick 35: Melbourne: Conor Macdonald

Pick 36: Geelong (Collingwood lose this pick because of nick daicos): Corey Warner

Pick 37: West Coast: Josh Browne

Pick 38: Adelaide: Hugh Jackson
 

briztoon

Wannabe Draft Nuffie
Nov 28, 2015
16,187
16,643
Brisbane
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Other Teams
NUFC, Philadelphia 76'ers
Pick 1: Collingwood: Nick Daicos

Pick 2: Western Bulldogs: Sam Darcy

Pick 3: North Melbourne: Jason Horne-Francis

Pick 4: GWS: Finn Callaghan

Pick 5: Gold Coast: Josh Gibcus

Pick 6: Adelaide: Josh Ward

Pick 7: Hawthorn: Neil Erasmus

Pick 8: Carlton: Josh Rachele

Pick 9: Richmond: Ben Hobbs

Pick 10: Fremantle: Jye Amiss

Pick 11: St Kilda: Arlo Draper

Pick 12: West Coast: Josh Sinn

Pick 13: Essendon: Josh Goater

Pick 14: Sydney: Mac Andrew

Pick 15: GWS: Campbell Chesser

Pick 16: Brisbane: Jack Williams

Pick 17: Richmond (Western Bulldogs lose their pick because of Sam Darcy): Jacob Van Rooyen

Pick 18: Port Adelaide: Matthew Roberts

Pick 19: Gold Coast: Bodhi Uwhland

Pick 20: Brisbane: Darcy Wilmot

Pick 21: North Melbourne (gold coast pick gets moved back to 62 because of bodhi Uwhland): Judson Clarke

Pick 22: Hawthorn: Tyler Sonsie

Pick 23: Gold Coast: Tom Brown

Pick 24: Adelaide: Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera

Pick 25: Hawthorn: Zac Taylor

Pick 26: Carlton: Leek Aleer

Pick 27: Richmond: Rhett Bazzo

Pick 28: Fremantle: Jesse Motlop

Pick 29: Richmond: Sam Butler

Pick 30: GWS: Josh Fahey

Pick 31: West Coast: Matthew Johnson

Pick 32: Geelong: Toby Conway

Pick 33: Sydney: Blake Howes

Pick 34: Geelong: Mitch Knevitt

Pick 35: Melbourne: Conor Macdonald

Pick 36: Geelong (Collingwood lose this pick because of nick daicos): Corey Warner

Pick 37: West Coast: Josh Browne

Pick 38: Adelaide: Hugh Jackson
Just on Brisbane, I’m pretty confident our recruiters rate Jacob Van Rooyen pretty high, along with Matthew Johnson. And a lot of Lions fans like Wanganeen-Milera.

Half back no longer appears to be a high priority of need.

KPF/KPD, fast inside and outside mids appear to be the priority.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad