I hear you. Could be interesting if the mechanism worked. I think the biggest issue would be the length of time and the availability of all the managers. But it could, in theory, be done offline if everyone was on the same page. Teams could delist whomever, be assigned picks, etc.. etc.. The problem would be getting everyone together.
Happy with Dunkley for both Melb and myself. Looks like he has nice longterm upside, I really like the pick for the Dees and it's been rare when I haven't questioned our recruiting team's pick the last 2 years. Had a really tough time choosing between he, Snelling and Deluca and had the decision made for me by falling asleep without making a choice. Kinda surprised he was still there but glad one of them was.