MVP BigFooty West Coast Eagles Player of the Year 2023 - Results Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Feb 26, 2012
16,936
46,958
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
:star:1st place - #11 Tim Kelly :star:

Kelly.jpeg


Total votes - 55.74

Ranking - 1st 🥇

Games played
- 22

A completely dominant year that almost matched the famous 2021 year of Naitanui, Tim Kelly takes out the gold medal in 2023. Kelly has now finished 1st, 2nd, 2nd and 3rd since he has come to the club - not bad for a failed trade amirite?? Kelly well and truly proved this year that he is an elite midfielder of the comp and could have had a case of being AA if we had not been such a basket case. Kelly more than doubled 2nd place this year and returned 6 Best on Ground performances (including the last 4 rounds of the year in a strong finish to the season which were:
  • 33 disposals, 5 marks and 4 tackles in Round 3 v Fremantle
  • 36 disposals, 6 marks, 5 tackles and 2 goals in Round 4 v Melbourne
  • 30 disposals, 10 marks and 4 tackles in Round 21 v Essendon
  • 26 disposals, 5 tackles and a goal in Round 22 v Fremantle
  • 32 disposals, 3 marks and 4 tackles in Round 23 v the Bulldogs
  • 35 disposals and 6 marks in Round 24 v Adelaide

Well done, Tim.

Season averages
Disposals: 28.2
Marks: 3.4
Tackles: 4.7
Clearances: 5.9
Total Goals: 10

Standout stats
Ranked 14th in the AFL for Disposals per game (28.2)
Ranked 18th in the AFL for Clearances per game (5.9)
Ranked 12th in the AFL for Contested Possessions per game (13.41)
Ranked 17th in the AFL for Stoppage Clearances per game (3.55)

Round. . .Votes
1. . . . .0
2. . . . .3.23
3. . . . .3.83 (BOG)
4. . . . .4.88 (BOG)
5. . . . .1.30
6. . . . .3.56
7. . . . .0.88
8. . . . .0.72
9. . . . .3.64
10. . . .0.96
11. . . .0.08
12. . . .2.58
13. . . .2.73
14. . . .BYE
15. . . .1.50
16. . . .DNP
17. . . .0.64
18. . . .3.89
19. . . .0
20. . . .2.97
21. . . .4.92 (BOG)
22. . . .3.89 (BOG)
23. . . .4.60 (BOG)
24. . . .4.92 (BOG)

Total. . . .55.74

2022 Comparison: 2nd to 1st :arrowup:

John Worsfold Medal placing: 1st (200 votes)

BigFooty Poster with the biggest crush - Keys (67 votes) & LittleFires (65 votes)
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Feb 26, 2012
16,936
46,958
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
I'll get to individual votes when I feel like it - likely this weekend sometime.

As usual, everyone who voted in every game or missed just one is automatically going to receive a votes breakdown and those posters are:

Voted in every game
KBLT
LittleFires
BeornJ
triplegee
Keys
omgfridge
Bleedblueandgold
MrWoollie
ArdentEagle
Mr Shankly
Alesana

Missed one game
peeky
Mulldogg
Carbine Chaos
Shifty1
Kapowie1 (you technically voted in every game but as you voted for Hurn in Round 17 when he didn't play I had to strike those votes from the record)

If you're not on this list and you want your individual voting breakdown then let me know
 

Mulldogg

Premiership Player
Apr 22, 2011
3,659
7,417
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Liverpool FC
Missed one game
peeky
Mulldogg
Carbine Chaos
Shifty1
Kapowie1 (you technically voted in every game but as you voted for Hurn in Round 17 when he didn't play I had to strike those votes from the record)

If you're not on this list and you want your individual voting breakdown then let me know
Yep, was in Bali for the Derby and the Dees v Blues game was on ABC Australia in the hotel. Missus and kids had Bali belly so I stayed in and missed it.

Was really a blessing to put up with a different kind of shitshow compared to that record Derby defeat!

Thanks for your efforts tallying the votes Squash 👍
 

MrWoollie

Club Legend
Jul 28, 2008
1,988
3,665
England
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Lincoln City Imps, West Perth
I swear that happened last year too.

I only got one, I mustn't play favourites like some. I know I was harsher on Kelly than most (I think)
And CC voted in less games than I did.

Just the one crush for me as well. And I had to wait until second place to get it!
Pretty surprised I gave so many votes to Hunt.
Same, fellow Hunt Crushee.

Well done again Squashface. You can retire knowing you did well and that your efforts were appreciated.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Mar 1, 2011
6,138
7,031
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Leeds United
I'll get to individual votes when I feel like it - likely this weekend sometime.

As usual, everyone who voted in every game or missed just one is automatically going to receive a votes breakdown and those posters are:

Voted in every game
KBLT
LittleFires
BeornJ
triplegee
Keys
omgfridge
Bleedblueandgold
MrWoollie
ArdentEagle
Mr Shankly
Alesana

Missed one game
peeky
Mulldogg
Carbine Chaos
Shifty1
Kapowie1 (you technically voted in every game but as you voted for Hurn in Round 17 when he didn't play I had to strike those votes from the record)

If you're not on this list and you want your individual voting breakdown then let me know
Oh s**t! Can you tell me which games I missed?
 
Feb 26, 2012
16,936
46,958
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Best on Ground performances

Round 1

North Melbourne (87) d West Coast (82) by 5 points
BOG: Luke Shuey (27 disposals, 4 marks, 8 tackles, 1 goal) 4.26 votes

Round 2

West Coast (100) d GWS (81) by 19 points
BOG: Jamaine Jones (27 disposals) 4.45 votes

Round 3

Fremantle (108) d West Coast (67) by 41 points
BOG: Tim Kelly (33 disposals, 5 marks, 4 tackles) 3.83 votes

Round 4

Melbourne (126) d West Coast (63) by 63 points
BOG: Tim Kelly (36 disposals, 6 marks, 5 tackles, 2 goals) 4.88 votes

Round 5

Geelong (136) d West Coast (89) by 47 points
BOG: Jake Waterman (20 disposals, 7 marks, 4 goals) 4.76 votes

Round 6

Port Adelaide (109) d West Coast (69) by 40 points
BOG: Bailey Williams (21 disposals, 2 marks, 3 tackles, 37 hitouts) 4.64 votes

Round 7

Carlton (152) d West Coast (44) by 108 points
BOG: Jayden Hunt (23 disposals, 5 marks, 3 tackles) 4.21 votes

Round 8

Richmond (104) d West Coast (58) by 46 points
BOG: Oscar Allen (15 disposals, 7 marks, 4 goals) 4.63 votes

Round 9

Gold Coast (113) d West Coast (43) by 70 points
BOG: Liam Duggan (32 disposals, 4 marks, 4 tackles) 4.79 votes

Round 10

Hawthorn (142) d West Coast (26) by 116 points
BOG: Dom Sheed (30 disposals, 8 mark, 5 tackles, 2 goals) 4.19 votes

Round 11

Essendon (96) d West Coast (46) by 50 points
BOG: Jayden Hunt (34 disposals, 9 marks, 2 tackles) 4.87 votes

Round 12

Collingwood (120) d West Coast (57) by 63 points
BOG: Elliot Yeo (26 disposals, 5 marks, 3 tackles) 4.85 votes

Round 13

Adelaide (174) d West Coast (52) by 122 points
BOG: Bailey Williams (20 disposals, 2 marks, 2 tackles, 35 hitouts, 1 goal) 5.00 votes

Round 15

Sydney (205) d West Coast (34) by 171 points
BOG: Luke Shuey (28 disposals, 5 marks, 8 tackles) 4.64 votes

Round 16

St Kilda (85) d West Coast (77) by 8 points
BOG: Luke Shuey (28 disposals, 2 marks, 9 tackles) 4.87 votes

Round 17

Brisbane (116) d West Coast (35) by 81 points
BOG: Brady Hough (22 disposals, 14 marks, 2 tackles) 4.39 votes

Round 18

Richmond (98) d West Coast (60) by 38 points
BOG: Brady Hough (18 disposals, 6 marks) 3.93 votes

Round 19

Carlton (140) d West Coast (69) by 71 points
BOG: Andrew Gaff (30 disposals, 10 marks, 1 goal) 3.88 votes

Round 20

West Coast (72) d North Melbourne (67) by 5 points
BOG: Bailey Williams (23 disposals, 5 marks, 4 tackles, 24 hitouts) 3.50 votes

Round 21

Essendon (73) d West Coast (72) by 1 point
BOG: Tim Kelly (30 disposals, 10 marks, 4 tackles) 4.92 votes

Round 22

Fremantle (134) d West Coast (33) by 101 points
BOG: Tim Kelly (26 disposals, 5 tackles, 1 goal) 3.89 votes

Round 23

West Coast (92) d Western Bulldogs (85) by 7 points
BOG: Tim Kelly (32 disposals, 3 marks, 4 tackles) 4.60 votes

Round 24

Adelaide (123) d West Coast (78) by 45 points
BOG: Tim Kelly (35 disposals, 6 marks) 4.92 votes
 

fidstar

Brownlow Medallist
May 9, 2013
15,726
10,869
AFL Club
West Coast
Fremantle (108) d West Coast (67) by 41 points
Melbourne (126) d West Coast (63) by 63 points
Geelong (136) d West Coast (89) by 47 points
Port Adelaide (109) d West Coast (69) by 40 points
Carlton (152) d West Coast (44) by 108 points
Richmond (104) d West Coast (58) by 46 points
Gold Coast (113) d West Coast (43) by 70 points
Hawthorn (142) d West Coast (26) by 116 points
Essendon (96) d West Coast (46) by 50 points
Collingwood (120) d West Coast (57) by 63 points
Adelaide (174) d West Coast (52) by 122 points
Sydney (205) d West Coast (34) by 171 points
St Kilda (85) d West Coast (77) by 8 points
Brisbane (116) d West Coast (35) by 81 points
Richmond (98) d West Coast (60) by 38 points
Carlton (140) d West Coast (69) by 71 points

Oh the wonderful memories.
 
Feb 26, 2012
16,936
46,958
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
ArdentEagle you voted in every game

Tim Kelly 40 votes
Oscar Allen 26 votes
Jayden Hunt 25 votes
Bailey Williams 25 votes
Jamaine Jones 22 votes
Shannon Hurn 21 votes
Elliot Yeo 17 votes
Luke Shuey 16 votes
Tom Barrass 13 votes
Alex Witherden 13 votes
Jamie Cripps 12 votes
Liam Duggan 12 votes
Jake Waterman 12 votes
Jack Petruccelle 11 votes
Elijah Hewett 11 votes
Dom Sheed 11 votes
Rueben Ginbey 11 votes
Andrew Gaff 9 votes
Brady Hough 8 votes
Jeremy McGovern 7 votes
Noah Long 7 votes
Sam Petrevski-Seton 5 votes
Tom Cole 4 votes
Liam Ryan 2 votes
Jai Culley 2 votes
Callum Jamieson 1 vote
Connor West 1 vote
Josh Rotham 1 vote

Player you loved: Shannon Hurn (16 votes more than average)
Player you hated: Liam Duggan (7 votes less than average) & Brady Hough (6 votes less than average)
 
Feb 12, 2008
10,259
19,704
AFL Club
West Coast
ArdentEagle you voted in every game

Tim Kelly 40 votes
Oscar Allen 26 votes
Jayden Hunt 25 votes
Bailey Williams 25 votes
Jamaine Jones 22 votes
Shannon Hurn 21 votes
Elliot Yeo 17 votes
Luke Shuey 16 votes
Tom Barrass 13 votes
Alex Witherden 13 votes
Jamie Cripps 12 votes
Liam Duggan 12 votes
Jake Waterman 12 votes
Jack Petruccelle 11 votes
Elijah Hewett 11 votes
Dom Sheed 11 votes
Rueben Ginbey 11 votes
Andrew Gaff 9 votes
Brady Hough 8 votes
Jeremy McGovern 7 votes
Noah Long 7 votes
Sam Petrevski-Seton 5 votes
Tom Cole 4 votes
Liam Ryan 2 votes
Jai Culley 2 votes
Callum Jamieson 1 vote
Connor West 1 vote
Josh Rotham 1 vote

Player you loved: Shannon Hurn (16 votes more than average)
Player you hated: Liam Duggan (7 votes less than average) & Brady Hough (6 votes less than average)
Thanks heaps Squashy....I really appreciate the work you've put in over the years keeping this thread running.

xoxox Ardent
 
Feb 26, 2012
16,936
46,958
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Keys you voted in every game

Tim Kelly 67 votes
Liam Duggan 34 votes
Oscar Allen 25 votes
Jamaine Jones 17 votes
Luke Shuey 16 votes
Elliot Yeo 16 votes
Rueben Ginbey 16 votes
Jayden Hunt 15 votes
Bailey Williams 14 votes
Shannon Hurn 13 votes
Jeremy McGovern 12 votes
Dom Sheed 12 votes
Brady Hough 12 votes
Alex Witherden 10 votes
Tom Barrass 10 votes
Elijah Hewett 10 votes
Jake Waterman 8 votes
Andrew Gaff 6 votes
Noah Long 6 votes
Liam Ryan 5 votes
Jack Petruccelle 5 votes
Jamie Cripps 5 votes
Sam Petrevski-Seton 4 votes
Xavier O'Neill 2 votes
Jai Culley 2 votes
Ryan Maric 1 vote
Tom Cole 1 vote
Jack Darling 1 vote

Player you loved: Liam Duggan (15 votes more than average)
Player you hated: Jayden Hunt (12 votes less than average)
 

Kapowie1

Team Captain
Oct 15, 2016
356
602
AFL Club
West Coast
I'll get to individual votes when I feel like it - likely this weekend sometime.

As usual, everyone who voted in every game or missed just one is automatically going to receive a votes breakdown and those posters are:

Voted in every game
KBLT
LittleFires
BeornJ
triplegee
Keys
omgfridge
Bleedblueandgold
MrWoollie
ArdentEagle
Mr Shankly
Alesana

Missed one game
peeky
Mulldogg
Carbine Chaos
Shifty1
Kapowie1 (you technically voted in every game but as you voted for Hurn in Round 17 when he didn't play I had to strike those votes from the record)

If you're not on this list and you want your individual voting breakdown then let me know

Still not sure what I was thinking there. Playing the catch up voting game on IOS device is tricky on the app.
It was definitely worth it in the end. My love of Noah and Oscar will get me through the off season


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back