MVP BigFooty West Coast Player of the Year 2018 - Results Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

fidstar

Brownlow Medallist
May 9, 2013
12,944
8,900
AFL Club
West Coast
bombard

Elliot Yeo 47
Jack Redden 39
Shannon Hurn 39
Jamie Cripps 27
Andrew Gaff 26
Jack Darling 23
Brad Sheppard 22
Luke Shuey 19
Nic Naitanui 16
Chris Masten 14
Mark Hutchings 13
Tom Cole 13
Scott Lycett 11
Liam Ryan 11
Dom Sheed 9
Tom Barrass 9
Josh Kennedy 7
Will Schofield 6
Willie Rioli 5
Mark LeCras 5
Jeremy McGovern 5
Lewis Jetta 3
Nathan Vardy 2
Liam Duggan 2
Jake Waterman 1
Daniel Venables 1

Players you love - Hurn (4 votes more than average), Cripps (10 votes), Masten (4.5 votes), Hutchings (7 votes), Cole (4 votes), Lycett (4 votes) & Ryan (4 votes)
Players you hate - Gaff (7 votes less than average), Shuey (4 votes), Rioli (5 votes), McGovern (10 votes) & Jetta (3 votes)


McGovern equal 20th best player? :p
 

fidstar

Brownlow Medallist
May 9, 2013
12,944
8,900
AFL Club
West Coast
Biggie

Elliot Yeo 58
Jack Redden 50
Shannon Hurn 38
Jack Darling 25
Andrew Gaff 24
Luke Shuey 22
Jamie Cripps 19
Brad Sheppard 18
Jeremy McGovern 18
Nic Naitanui 15
Tom Barrass 14
Josh Kennedy 11
Scott Lycett 10
Liam Ryan 9
Mark Hutchings 7
Liam Duggan 6
Dom Sheed 6
Chris Masten 5
Will Schofield 4
Tom Cole 4
Willie Rioli 4
Lewis Jetta 4
Nathan Vardy 3
Daniel Venables 1

Players you love - Yeo (10 votes more than average), Redden (12 votes) and Barrass (4 votes)
Players you hate - Gaff (7 votes less than average), Sheppard (5.5 votes), Masten (3.5 votes), Cole (5 votes) & you gave no votes for Mark LeCras (7 votes less than average)
 

fidstar

Brownlow Medallist
May 9, 2013
12,944
8,900
AFL Club
West Coast
And the actual correct votes for this years MVP should have been...

fidstar

Elliot Yeo 43
Jack Redden 39
Shannon Hurn 32
Andrew Gaff 31
Jack Darling 28
Jamie Cripps 26
Brad Sheppard 21
Luke Shuey 17
Scott Lycett 15
Dom Sheed 14
Josh Kennedy 13
Chris Masten 11
Lewis Jetta 11
Jeremy McGovern 11
Liam Ryan 11
Mark Hutchings 10
Mark LeCras 7
Liam Duggan 7
Nic Naitanui 7
Will Schofield 6
Willie Rioli 6
Jake Waterman 5
Tom Barrass 3
Tom Cole 1

Players I love - Cripps (9 votes more than average), Lycett (8 votes), Sheed (5 votes), Jetta (5 votes), Ryan (4 votes), Hutching (4 votes), Waterman (4 votes)
Players I hate - Yeo (5 votes less than average), Shuey (6 votes), McGovern (4 votes), Nic Nat (8 votes), Rioli (4 votes), Cole (8 votes)

Once again my votes are all over the place to the other voters. You guys just seem to get it wrong year after year!! :D
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

fidstar

Brownlow Medallist
May 9, 2013
12,944
8,900
AFL Club
West Coast
For fun (well "fun" might not be the right word), I thought I would weight the games in level of importance and see how that changed the voting.

I used the following weighting for games..

Games against bottom 8 teams - 1
Games against Top 8 teams at home - 1.25
Games against Top 8 teams away - 1.5
Finals - 2
Grand Final - 3
I also bumped the away Collingwood game at the MCG during the season to a 2 (from a 1.5), and the Richmond game to a 1.5 (from a 1.25), as they were the most important two games of the regular season.

Results...

Elliot Yeo 59.25
Jack Redden 54.25
Shannon Hurn 41.79
Andrew Gaff 39.16
Luke Shuey 35.77
Jack Darling 31.82
Brad Sheppard 27.52
Jeremy McGovern 22.73
Jamie Cripps 21.21
Nic Naitanui 19.68
Dom Sheed 18.01
Josh Kennedy 15.44
Tom Barrass 15.42
Willie Rioli 13.05
Chris Masten 10.72
Mark Hutchings 10.32
Tom Cole 9.53
Liam Ryan 9.35
Lewis Jetta 8.2
Mark LeCras 8.09
Scott Lycett 7.77
Will Schofield 6.14
Liam Duggan 4.5
Nathan Vardy 2.88
Daniel Venables 0.94
Jake Waterman 0.78
Brendon Ah Chee 0.42
Jackson Nelson 0.2
Fraser McInnes 0.05

Comments -
  • Shuey jumps from 7 to 5 due mainly to his GF performance
  • McGovern jumps from 10 to 8 due to his two good games in the season coming against Collingwood and Richmond.
  • Hutchings jumps from 20th to 15th
  • Dom Sheed from 16th to 11th
  • Redden closed the gap significantly to Yeo, but not enough to catch him. He's now clearly 2nd in the voting (compared to just in front of 3rd in the normal vote count).

I actually think this is a better representation of who played well this season.
 

omgfridge

Don't you know? Pump it up
Apr 10, 2011
1,064
2,307
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Tottenham Hotspur, Houston Rockets
OMGFridge

Elliot Yeo 38
Shannon Hurn 37
Andrew Gaff 33
Brad Sheppard 32
Jack Redden 31
Jack Darling 24
Luke Shuey 22
Chris Masten 20
Jamie Cripps 19
Nic Naitanui 19
Jeremy McGovern 14
Scott Lycett 11
Lewis Jetta 11
Tom Cole 10
Willie Rioli 10
Josh Kennedy 9
Mark LeCras 7
Liam Ryan 6
Dom Sheed 6
Tom Barrass 5
Mark Hutchings 3
Will Schofield 3
Jake Waterman 3
Nathan Vardy 1
Brendon Ah Chee 1

Players you love - Sheppard (8.5 votes more than average), Masten (11 votes), Nic Nat (4 votes), Lycett (4 votes) & Jetta (5 votes)
Players you hate - Yeo (10 votes less than average), Redden ( 7 votes), Barrass (5 votes) & Hutching (3 votes)
I hate Yeo but he still won my B&F haha.

I didn't give a single vote to Duggan yet 1 to Ah Chee...

Masten/Jetta/Shep <3

Also thanks for the breakdown Fidstar.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

omgfridge

Don't you know? Pump it up
Apr 10, 2011
1,064
2,307
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Tottenham Hotspur, Houston Rockets
I remembering commenting I thought he played his best game of the year in one votes thread.

0 votes haha. I do rate Dugs in the team though!
 

fidstar

Brownlow Medallist
May 9, 2013
12,944
8,900
AFL Club
West Coast
ArdentEagle

Elliot Yeo 45
Andrew Gaff 38
Shannon Hurn 32
Jamie Cripps 32
Jack Darling 28
Jack Redden 26
Brad Sheppard 21
Mark Hutchings 17
Nic Naitanui 16
Luke Shuey 15
Chris Masten 11
Tom Barrass 11
Liam Ryan 11
Jeremy McGovern 10
Josh Kennedy 10
Willie Rioli 9
Scott Lycett 8
Mark LeCras 7
Tom Cole 7
Dom Sheed 6
Will Schofield 5
Daniel Venables 5
Lewis Jetta 3
Nathan Vardy 2

Players you love - Gaff (5 votes more than average), Cripps (15 votes), Hutching (11 votes) & Ryan (4 votes)
Players you hate - Redden (12 votes less than average), Shuey (8 votes), McGovern (5 votes), Sheed (3 votes), Jetta (3 votes), Duggan (4 votes - You didn't give him a vote).
 

fidstar

Brownlow Medallist
May 9, 2013
12,944
8,900
AFL Club
West Coast
Here2tellyouwhy

Elliot Yeo 53
Shannon Hurn 53
Jack Redden 35
Andrew Gaff 31
Brad Sheppard 29
Luke Shuey 24
Jack Darling 20
Jamie Cripps 18
Nic Naitanui 14
Tom Barrass 13
Josh Kennedy 11
Jeremy McGovern 11
Will Schofield 8
Willie Rioli 7
Scott Lycett 7
Chris Masten 7
Liam Ryan 7
Tom Cole 6
Dom Sheed 5
Mark Hutchings 4
Mark LeCras 4
Lewis Jetta 3
Liam Duggan 3
Nathan Vardy 2

Players you love - Yeo (5 votes more than average), Hurn (18 votes), Sheppard (5.5 votes) & Schofield (4 votes)
Players you hate - Darling (6 votes), McGovern (4 votes), Rioli (3 votes), Sheed (3.5 votes) & Jetta (3 votes)
 

fidstar

Brownlow Medallist
May 9, 2013
12,944
8,900
AFL Club
West Coast
squashface

Jack Redden 50
Elliot Yeo 50
Shannon Hurn 31
Andrew Gaff 26
Brad Sheppard 25
Jack Darling 25
Luke Shuey 19
Jamie Cripps 16
Lewis Jetta 16
Tom Cole 15
Willie Rioli 15
Nic Naitanui 12
Chris Masten 12
Josh Kennedy 12
Liam Ryan 9
Jeremy McGovern 8
Tom Barrass 8
Will Schofield 6
Dom Sheed 6
Mark LeCras 5
Liam Duggan 4
Scott Lycett 3
Daniel Venables 1
Jake Waterman 1

Players you love - Redden (12 votes more than average), Jetta (10 votes), Cole (6.5 votes) & Rioli (5 votes)
Players you hate - Gaff (7 votes less than average), Shuey (4 votes), McGovern (7 votes), Lycett (4 votes) & Hutchings (6 votes - You didn't give him a vote).
 

fidstar

Brownlow Medallist
May 9, 2013
12,944
8,900
AFL Club
West Coast
Sw3Et

Elliot Yeo 43
Jack Redden 34
Jack Darling 33
Shannon Hurn 30
Andrew Gaff 28
Brad Sheppard 25
Luke Shuey 25
Nic Naitanui 15
Jamie Cripps 15
Chris Masten 14
Willie Rioli 13
Josh Kennedy 13
Tom Barrass 13
Lewis Jetta 12
Jeremy McGovern 12
Dom Sheed 10
Mark Hutchings 9
Tom Cole 8
Liam Ryan 7
Mark LeCras 7
Scott Lycett 4
Daniel Venables 2
Jackson Nelson 1
Will Schofield 1
Liam Duggan 1

Players you love - Darling (7 votes more than average), Masten (5 votes) & Jetta (6 votes)
Players you hate - Yeo (5 votes less than average), Hurn (5 votes), Gaff (5 votes), Lycett (3 votes) & Schofield (3 votes)
 

Here2tellyouwhy

SA GREAT
Sep 3, 2005
29,423
77,413
Adelaide
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
West Coast Eagles
Here2tellyouwhy

Elliot Yeo 53
Shannon Hurn 53
Jack Redden 35
Andrew Gaff 31
Brad Sheppard 29
Luke Shuey 24
Jack Darling 20
Jamie Cripps 18
Nic Naitanui 14
Tom Barrass 13
Josh Kennedy 11
Jeremy McGovern 11
Will Schofield 8
Willie Rioli 7
Scott Lycett 7
Chris Masten 7
Liam Ryan 7
Tom Cole 6
Dom Sheed 5
Mark Hutchings 4
Mark LeCras 4
Lewis Jetta 3
Liam Duggan 3
Nathan Vardy 2

Players you love - Yeo (5 votes more than average), Hurn (18 votes), Sheppard (5.5 votes) & Schofield (4 votes)
Players you hate - Darling (6 votes), McGovern (4 votes), Rioli (3 votes), Sheed (3.5 votes) & Jetta (3 votes)
Much appreciated fidstar

Looks good to me. Happy to see I rate our most underrated in Shep and Schoey, and our best two players Yeo and Hurn with Redden right up there too.

Up the bloody Coasters
 

Magnum27

Norm Smith Medallist
Sep 27, 2005
6,039
3,014
Victoria
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
WILDCATS/STH.FREO/CELTICS
fidstar you are a dead set legend and the player of the year votes on here, should be renamed as the fidstar medal in my opinion.

Cheers for doing this for the last few years. I know i didn't post every game, i forgot to do the finals, my guess is my best votes were for a backman.
 

ArdentEagle

Old enough to know better, too drunk to try.
Feb 12, 2008
4,905
8,029
A Quantum Universe
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Bombers - My true home
ArdentEagle

Elliot Yeo 45
Andrew Gaff 38
Shannon Hurn 32
Jamie Cripps 32
Jack Darling 28
Jack Redden 26
Brad Sheppard 21
Mark Hutchings 17
Nic Naitanui 16
Luke Shuey 15
Chris Masten 11
Tom Barrass 11
Liam Ryan 11
Jeremy McGovern 10
Josh Kennedy 10
Willie Rioli 9
Scott Lycett 8
Mark LeCras 7
Tom Cole 7
Dom Sheed 6
Will Schofield 5
Daniel Venables 5
Lewis Jetta 3
Nathan Vardy 2

Players you love - Gaff (5 votes more than average), Cripps (15 votes), Hutching (11 votes) & Ryan (4 votes)
Players you hate - Redden (12 votes less than average), Shuey (8 votes), McGovern (5 votes), Sheed (3 votes), Jetta (3 votes), Duggan (4 votes - You didn't give him a vote).
Thanks fidstar
I really rated Cripps this season and it shows. He hasn't been given enough love by some for mine. Ditto Hutchings.
Supposed I was a tad harsh on Redog ;)
 

Top Bottom