Post BF Upgrade Feedback - Click Here

Remove this Banner Ad

Phantom Draft Bishop's 2017 Draft Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bishop
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

With Brett Anderson saying that Collingwood are considering Richards at 6, would you say that it would be a big reach or would he be worthy of a selection at 6?
 
Moeydw said:
With Brett Anderson saying that Collingwood are considering Richards at 6, would you say that it would be a big reach or would he be worthy of a selection at 6?
Click to expand...

Reeeeaaaccchhhh
 
Last edited:
HedgeFund said:
Reeeeaaaccchhhh
Click to expand...
Thought so, could you see it happening on Friday? It would really sour my night if Hine ends up going with him.
 
Moeydw said:
With Brett Anderson saying that Collingwood are considering Richards at 6, would you say that it would be a big reach or would he be worthy of a selection at 6?
Click to expand...
Maybe the crazy decision to let Jake Kelly go has them too scared to let Ed slip.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

cooperg said:
Bishop I know you're a busy man, but who are the 5 names St.Kilda are interested in at 7&8? In order if you know. Also Billy Hartung at 45 could very well, hope we get Hartung. Do you think Billy can join the Saints?

I've been told Billy will be a Saint or a Lion.
Click to expand...
Saints would be bloody fools to draft Hartung at 45. I know this draft is shallow but Hartung is an incredibly soft player that would disappear in a final and either lacks skills like toughness or refuses to use weapons like speed. He's panicky and indecisive. He's a dud and I totally get why he was delisted by the hawks. Richmond don't need outside types bu even if they did, I'd be praying they didn't draft Hartung.

Try a kid, have a crack, you may find a role player, or even better a gun player. Saints need to back their recruiters.
 
cooperg said:
Thanks legend. Final one at 34&45, Do you think the Saints could get Kyron Hayden,Brayden Starceveich , Charlie Ballard or Jackson Ross? Also do you know if they have spoken to any of these guys? Any other names they have met or discussed with for 34&45?
Click to expand...

Think Ballard will be gone by then, Ross I believe hasn't spoken to Saints. No idea on the other two.

Moeydw said:
With Brett Anderson saying that Collingwood are considering Richards at 6, would you say that it would be a big reach or would he be worthy of a selection at 6?
Click to expand...

I think it'd be a reach, but you've gotta back your recruiters in - they've seen more than me (or anyone else) of Richards playing.

Think things get blown out by the fact that fans watch a 2 minute highlight video and fall in love with player X, I've never seen a bad highlights package...

If Carlton are considering Richards at 10, then it certainly isn't a reach to take him at Pick 6.
 
Bishop said:
Think Ballard will be gone by then, Ross I believe hasn't spoken to Saints. No idea on the other two.



I think it'd be a reach, but you've gotta back your recruiters in - they've seen more than me (or anyone else) of Richards playing.

Think things get blown out by the fact that fans watch a 2 minute highlight video and fall in love with player X, I've never seen a bad highlights package...

If Carlton are considering Richards at 10, then it certainly isn't a reach to take him at Pick 6.
Click to expand...
I hope we consider him at 9
 
Richo83 said:
Saints would be bloody fools to draft Hartung at 45. I know this draft is shallow but Hartung is an incredibly soft player that would disappear in a final and either lacks skills like toughness or refuses to use weapons like speed. He's panicky and indecisive. He's a dud and I totally get why he was delisted by the hawks. Richmond don't need outside types bu even if they did, I'd be praying they didn't draft Hartung.

Try a kid, have a crack, you may find a role player, or even better a gun player. Saints need to back their recruiters.
Click to expand...
+1000000
Please go and talk some sense to the Saints board. Sick of his name!
 
Bishop said:
Think things get blown out by the fact that fans watch a 2 minute highlight video and fall in love with player X, I've never seen a bad highlights.
Click to expand...

Too true, the highlight draft experts at this time of the year come out of the woodwork. didn't know what the prospects looked like til last week
 
Bishop, from what I can gather the two most likely at our pick 9 are Naughton and Murphy, is that what you're thinking? If they are both there, which do you think we'd take?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

HedgeFund said:
Reeeeaaaccchhhh
Click to expand...
Just can't see it happening .....Shifter Sheehan said today that Richards had worked into first round consideration .....that's a long way though from #6
 
Dannnnnnnnnn said:
Pls be right Collingwood board
Click to expand...
Can't understand the talk of you guys taking a tall ......you have enough already, surely you'll be taking a Mid?
 
CaptainMurphy said:
Bishop, from what I can gather the two most likely at our pick 9 are Naughton and Murphy, is that what you're thinking? If they are both there, which do you think we'd take?
Click to expand...

I think Naughton is almost a lock at 9 - Pick 16 bit unsure right now as it stands.
 
Bishop said:
Think Ballard will be gone by then, Ross I believe hasn't spoken to Saints. No idea on the other two.



I think it'd be a reach, but you've gotta back your recruiters in - they've seen more than me (or anyone else) of Richards playing.

Think things get blown out by the fact that fans watch a 2 minute highlight video and fall in love with player X, I've never seen a bad highlights package...

If Carlton are considering Richards at 10, then it certainly isn't a reach to take him at Pick 6.
Click to expand...
Jonty Scharenberg's highlight video, well one of them, was really bad. He kept kicking it on the ground if front of the player he was aiming for.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Bloody hell. What about 1? Brayshaw talk continues. Just a ruse?
 
The Bradshaw at 1 continues to firm... changes so much in the first round... Freo prefer LDU over Raymor and Carlton need mids so could still take Dow or Cerra instead of Rayner who might end up at North

1. Brayshaw
2. LDU
3. Dow
4. Raynor
5. Fogarty
6. Coffield
7. Clark
8. Higgens
9. Brander
10. Stephenson
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

Futbolista
State Focus West Australian Junior Talent: 2026 Draft
11 12 13 14 15
Replies
357
Views
38K
Futbolista
Futbolista

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom