Black Magic: The best Aboriginal 18 of all time:

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

djrasta213

Debutant
May 13, 2018
62
99
AFL Club
West Coast
B David Wirrpanda Michael Johnson Gavin Wanganeen.
HB Andrew McLeod Adam Goodes Byron Pickett
C P. Matera M. Rioli M. Long
HF Nicky Winmar Stephen Michael Michael O'Loughlin
F Cyril Rioli Lance Franklin Jim Krakouer
R: Ggaham Farmer Shaun Burgoyne Barry Cable

Int: Eddie Betts, Chris Lewis, Phil Krakouer, Chris Johnson
Captain/Coach: Barry Cable.
 

Procrastinator35

Hall of Famer
Feb 24, 2013
45,366
37,710
The GoldenBrown Heart of Victoria
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Other Teams
Man Utd Green Bay Melb Storm
B David Wirrpanda Michael Johnson Gavin Wanganeen.
HB Andrew McLeod Adam Goodes Byron Pickett
C Peter Matera Maurice Rioli Michael Long
HF Nicky Winmar Stephen Michael Michael O'Loughlin
F Cyril Rioli Lance Franklin Jim Krakouer
R: Graham Farmer Shaun Burgoyne Barry Cable

Int: Eddie Betts, Chris Lewis, Phil Krakouer, Chris Johnson
Captain/Coach: Barry Cable.

Good side....Is there a reason why you left off the Christian names from the Centre-line?
 

Flags_In_The_Bag

Norm Smith Medallist
Aug 17, 2014
5,928
3,852
Melbourne
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Other Teams
Not a fan of overseas teams.....
If this was done to say the best Caucasian players ever, can you imagine the abuse. shows how some things are different. :think:
 

Derby103

Team Captain
Apr 20, 2006
328
225
Macclesfield
AFL Club
North Melbourne
If this was done to say the best Caucasian players ever, can you imagine the abuse. shows how some things are different. :think:

It would be a great side though. It could be called the 'White Power'. Black Magic v White Power could become a feature on the AFL calendar. I for one would love to be at a packed MCG as the chant 'White Power, White Power' echoed around the ground.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

El Gringo

Perro Jefe
Oct 29, 2009
477
522
AFL Club
Melbourne
C. Johnson, S. May, N. Jetta
A. McLeod, M. Johnson, B. Pickett
A. Davey, A. Goodes, S. Burgoyne
N. Winmar, L. Franklin, M. Walters
J. Farmer, L. Jurrah, C. Rioli
P. Ryder, P. Burgoyne, G. Wanganeen

M. O’Loughlin, M. Long, H. Bennell, P. Matera
 

masai tu

Team Captain
Oct 17, 2021
521
760
AFL Club
Fremantle
C. Johnson, S. May, N. Jetta
A. McLeod, M. Johnson, B. Pickett
A. Davey, A. Goodes, S. Burgoyne
N. Winmar, L. Franklin, M. Walters
J. Farmer, L. Jurrah, C. Rioli
P. Ryder, P. Burgoyne, G. Wanganeen

M. O’Loughlin, M. Long, H. Bennell, P. Matera

Ryder not in the same changerooms as Polly & TI.

Wanganeen v Cable, Wangers is in the toilet.

Cyril is good but is busy trying to tie Uncle Maurice laces.
 

BigPond101

Team Captain
Mar 18, 2020
467
849
AFL Club
Fremantle
Wirrapunda over C Johnson imo. I know Johnson held his own in the great brissie team but I don't remember him ever being a star or one of the best players like Wirrapunda was at times

Also agree with the poster above Cyril was very flattered by playing in that Hawks team and nowhere near as good as we are supposed to believe. I would have him a long way down the list behind Jeff Farmer, Walters and others
 

BringFevBack2021

Club Legend
May 9, 2021
2,021
5,228
AFL Club
Carlton
It would be a great side though. It could be called the 'White Power'. Black Magic v White Power could become a feature on the AFL calendar. I for one would love to be at a packed MCG as the chant 'White Power, White Power' echoed around the ground.
Holy duck hahahahahahaha

Great thread though, would be cool if the AFL did acknowledge an Indigenous TOTC or Indigenous all-time greats side.

First they need to mend relationships with one of the best indigenous players ever in Goodesy though.

Need more acknowledgement of the indigenous people of Australia in sport.
 

masai tu

Team Captain
Oct 17, 2021
521
760
AFL Club
Fremantle
Holy fu** hahahahahahaha

Great thread though, would be cool if the AFL did acknowledge an Indigenous TOTC or Indigenous all-time greats side.

First they need to mend relationships with one of the best indigenous players ever in Goodesy though.

Need more acknowledgement of the indigenous people of Australia in sport.

In relation to recognising footballer’s, the WAFL & SAFL are so far ahead of the AFL in this respect, it ain’t funny.

It’s all to do with history, indigenous players have been dominating at WAFL & SAFL, since the day dot. To the AFL ( Vic..... ), they are still taking steps to recognise them.
 

pz5151

Debutant
Aug 15, 2021
106
110
AFL Club
Collingwood
Are we accepting Wayne Carey's claim to be of Indigenous ancestry? If so, you'd probably need to move Goodes onto the flank or even play him as a wingman.
 

BringFevBack2021

Club Legend
May 9, 2021
2,021
5,228
AFL Club
Carlton
Are we acknowledging Wayne Carey as Aboriginal?

Are we accepting Wayne Carey's claim to be of Indigenous ancestry? If so, you'd probably need to move Goodes onto the flank or even play him as a wingman.
If he's claiming it, then yeah - sure. My indigenous friends get pretty upset when they are queried about their heritage and asked to 'prove' it and I don't blame them.

Goodes could be played as a third tall or anywhere in the midfield. Probably the most diverse player on the list. Maybe just move Wayne Carey to CHF, Lance to FF and Jurrah out (I'd take Matera over Jurrah all day)
 

Choc Milk

Team Captain
Aug 18, 2021
305
666
AFL Club
Carlton
It would be a great side though. It could be called the 'White Power'. Black Magic v White Power could become a feature on the AFL calendar. I for one would love to be at a packed MCG as the chant 'White Power, White Power' echoed around the ground.

10/10
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad