Remove this Banner Ad

Strategy Blair Hartley Project 2015 II

  • Thread starter Thread starter Equus
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
captain blood 17 said:
What makes me say it is Grigg in particular. Remind me again the reports on his efforts in games and how hard he worked off the field playing for Carlton? How is he playing now?

As for the rest of your post, it's speculative nonsense.


Sent from my iPad using righteous man power.
Click to expand...
Sorry mate, wasn't having a go at you but I don't share the Yarran love nor the "we can fix him" approach.

Have to admit I didn't know much about Grigg pre Richmond but I can't recall him ever giving up during games?

Good on you for having greater faith in our club in turning Yarran around but I don't share it sorry. Dan Connors, Relton "burger" Roberts are two recent disasters that immediately come to mind. You can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink.

Give me Motlop or Bennel any day over Yarran. We only have to keep these boys on the straight & narrow not get into their heads.
 
captain blood 17 said:
Jeff Garlett is gonna kick 40 goals plus for Melbourne this year. Think about that.


Sent from my iPad using righteous man power.
Click to expand...

Garlett is a proven goal kicker, Yarran is not. How much of that is to do with Yarran playing predominately backline since becoming truly established at AFL level is the question and is why I waiver as to whether I want him or not. One thing that is for certain as far as I'm concerned is I wouldn't want him anywhere near our backline, which isn't an opinion I shared earlier in the season but having seen how well we defend as a unit I think Yarran would only destroy that.
 
Tomnat Tigers said:
Garlett is a proven goal kicker, Yarran is not. How much of that is to do with Yarran playing predominately backline since becoming truly established at AFL level is the question and is why I waiver as to whether I want him or not. One thing that is for certain as far as I'm concerned is I wouldn't want him anywhere near our backline, which isn't an opinion I shared earlier in the season but having seen how well we defend as a unit I think Yarran would only destroy that.
Click to expand...
Lindsay Thomas. We can trade Robin Nahas for Lindsay Thomas.
 
Yarran is an Elite talent, He has the skill to be just as good as Cyril if not better

He is at a club where the place is a complete rabble and he is being played out of position in a team thats getting bombarded
Carlton have a very very weak team with no game plan and little talent - Its impossible to understand how yarran must feel being so talented yet not being able to play his natural game.

Dermott Brereton actually mentioned the same thing yesterday on sen, In the Hawks team yarran would be unstopable
If we can get him for a pick in the mid 20's thats a bargain that we must go after specially with motlop and Edwards - wow
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Gotta be the most overrated name thrown around here....more than that Dea bloke. Do not rate.

272327-megan-gale.jpg


Seriously......Jaws?? :drunk::drunk::drunk::thumbsdown::thumbsdown:

Not sure if even female!! o_O

Inb4 some serious hate!! lol
 
WATiger86 said:
Its funny, before he re-signed last year we were all shitting ourselves he'd leave. The relief when he resigned was massive on here. Next minute, trade bait!
Click to expand...
We have enough depth to dangle one of our key fwds. Unlucky griffo!
 
WATiger86 said:
Its funny, before he re-signed last year we were all shitting ourselves he'd leave. The relief when he resigned was massive on here. Next minute, trade bait!
Click to expand...
Short memories
Conca has already gone to WA for nothing
 
I would go Motlop over yarran on current form. I would also prefer the Gws boys over Motlop.
 
Mahlepi said:
sorry for the intrusion but you will not have 12 or 15, given there will be priority picks for leuenger and possibly selwood
your first pick could be 18 or 20, and that will not work
just like you will not accept collingwoods second round pick for vickery
Click to expand...
Both those players would have to get 600k to trigger band 1 compo, which I cant see. See Frawley.
 
Tomnat Tigers said:
Garlett is a proven goal kicker, Yarran is not. How much of that is to do with Yarran playing predominately backline since becoming truly established at AFL level is the question and is why I waiver as to whether I want him or not. One thing that is for certain as far as I'm concerned is I wouldn't want him anywhere near our backline, which isn't an opinion I shared earlier in the season but having seen how well we defend as a unit I think Yarran would only destroy that.
Click to expand...
I would play yarran on the wing and tell him to run all day.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Mahlepi said:
sorry for the intrusion but you will not have 12 or 15, given there will be priority picks for leuenger and possibly selwood
your first pick could be 18 or 20, and that will not work
just like you will not accept collingwoods second round pick for vickery
Click to expand...
Geelong aren't going to pay Selwood $600k to warrant a first round compo pick and WCE will like finish higher than us so even if your club is dumb enough to pay it, it won't affect us.
 
THE_GUN said:
Yarran is an Elite talent, He has the skill to be just as good as Cyril if not better

He is at a club where the place is a complete rabble and he is being played out of position in a team thats getting bombarded
Carlton have a very very weak team with no game plan and little talent - Its impossible to understand how yarran must feel being so talented yet not being able to play his natural game.

Dermott Brereton actually mentioned the same thing yesterday on sen, In the Hawks team yarran would be unstopable
If we can get him for a pick in the mid 20's thats a bargain that we must go after specially with motlop and Edwards - wow
Click to expand...

I can tell you this much from a hawf source. Hawthorn very much made a play for Yarren. They rate him highly. Yarren chose Carlton over the Hawks. Just an fyi.


Sent from my iPad using righteous man power.
 
captain blood 17 said:
I can tell you this much from a hawf source. Hawthorn very much made a play for Yarren. They rate him highly. Yarren chose Carlton over the Hawks. Just an fyi.


Sent from my iPad using righteous man power.
Click to expand...
Brereton said the other day the Hawks are sniffing around him.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

_EAD_ said:
Geelong aren't going to pay Selwood $600k to warrant a first round compo pick and WCE will like finish higher than us so even if your club is dumb enough to pay it, it won't affect us.
Click to expand...
No gtee as you might go deeper in finals
We might pay 600 for 2, then 400 for 3
 
The long term plan put into place years ago, not paying our players overs, having cash and cap space banked is going to be a master stroke. The side seems to have turned a corner, now to get some cream with the warchest brilliant work by the club.
 
Stylo said:
How would people feel about this:

Richmond:
Out - picks 14 + 32
In - Aish + Yarran
Brisbane:
Out - Aish + pick 20
In - picks 14 + 32
Carlton:
Out - Yarran
In - pick 20

?
Click to expand...
Prefer the following.
Richmond:
Out - picks 14 & 32
In - Motlop & Yarran

Carlton:
Out - Yarran & Henderson
In - picks 12 & 28

Geelong:
Out - Picks 12 ontraded 28 Motlop
In - Henderson & 14

Everyone wins IMO
 
Mahlepi said:
No gtee as you might go deeper in finals
We might pay 600 for 2, then 400 for 3
Click to expand...
Huh? Scott Selwood isn't worth $600k and if Geelong pays him that then I'd be extremely concerned as Geelong fans. I'd also be worried about the cap because if you're also getting Danger for $800k+ and Henderson on another $500-600k. That would be 3 players on more than Joel Selwood.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom