Guys we don't need Scott Selwood, tell me in what way is he any different to (or better than?) Miles, Dusty, the emerging Corey Ellis? Once again it would be a case of us taking another "samey" type player. If we want an inside player like him we have Miles who right now is miles (pun not intended) ahead of him. Selwood can't even get on the park either... If we want an inside player, what we need is a bigger specimen of the Jobe Watson, Andrew Swallow, Jack Ziebell ilk. I would take Joel in a heartbeat, but Scott ain't the same player.
Shiel is the player we need. A two-way running highly skilled midfielder who can win his own ball, get it plenty on the outside, tackle, and kick goals.
If we can somehow add another contested inside beast too, we will be well on track.
But look if we get Selwood for nothing he may well improve the 22 a little, but with Shiel too would there even be a place for Selwood in the best 22?