Injury Blue Healers Medical Room - 2021

[Zlatan]

Does anyone know whether Williams “general soreness” is legitimately debilitating soreness throughout his body to the point he can’t move, or is it “I know what’s about to happen on Sunday and am bailing out early?”

 

[BlueTang]

Does anyone know whether Williams “general soreness” is legitimately debilitating soreness throughout his body to the point he can’t move, or is it “I know what’s about to happen on Sunday and am bailing out early?”

I was re watching some of the Bris game today, he got battered around quite a lot, I saw one marking contest where I think 3 bodies landed on him.
Why would you want to miss our third win of the year? Crazy talk

 

[BigFrizz36]

We cop it all week in the media about our rebuild.

Murphy singled out, but there are doubts we would omit our former captain.

Neck minnit, Murphy out with a vague, last minute injury at training (where no one was watching).

...coincidence much?

We've had all and sundry telling us that Murphy has been guaranteed to get to 300 asap. Surely if this was the case and he wasn't injured the club would just have made him the sub where he gets credited another game regardless of whether he gets on.
Call me an anti conspiracy theorist but I think that he is just injured.

 

[BigFrizz36]

Does anyone know whether Williams “general soreness” is legitimately debilitating soreness throughout his body to the point he can’t move, or is it “I know what’s about to happen on Sunday and am bailing out early?”

What's going to happen on sunday that can be so bad. We are playing a team that we should beat.
I read it that he has soreness that makes the match committee believe that he wouldn't be able to perform to the standard of his potential replacement.

 

[SkyhorseTamer]

What's going to happen on sunday that can be so bad. We are playing a team that we should beat.
I read it that he has soreness that makes the match committee believe that he wouldn't be able to perform to the standard of his potential replacement.

Still that's weird he's rested for general soreness when Casboult is asked to limp his way through a 7th game in a row with 0 mobility.

 

[BigFrizz36]

Still that's weird he's rested for general soreness when Casboult is asked to limp his way through a 7th game in a row with 0 mobility.

It's only weird if you have inside knowledge as to how sore each of them are/were. I don't and am pretty sure nobody else on here does either.

 

[SkyhorseTamer]

It's only weird if you have inside knowledge as to how sore each of them are/were. I don't and am pretty sure nobody else on here does either.

You don't think 6 games of evidence is enough to determine that Cas is playing so below his level is enough? Let alone that we've had inside word he's playing injured...

Different standards and requirements for different players, saads playing really sore too. 'Weird' is a fine word to describe something unexplainable. If you have inside knowledge it wouldn't be weird because you'd know the exact reasoning....

 

[Mr_Plow]

Disappointed for McGovern, thought he was quite good defensively from a pressure POV and building into some form. Sucks.

 

[teagueyubeauty]

Disappointed for McGovern, thought he was quite good defensively from a pressure POV and building into some form. Sucks.

Agree, will we ever get the first or second choice forward line together?

Jack probably would have been back this week and therefore only missing Curnow.

McGovern has the rest of this year and next to get it together, looked a bad hammy though so can’t see him back in the 1’s for 6-8 weeks


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Mr_Plow]

Agree, will we ever get the first or second choice forward line together?

Jack probably would have been back this week and therefore only missing Curnow.

McGovern has the rest of this year and next to get it together, looked a bad hammy though so can’t see him back in the 1’s for 6-8 weeks


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

I'm expecting it to be a regulation 4 weeker, hopefully. We (he) just can't change our injury fortunes. Forward line keeps taking hits.

 

[BigFrizz36]

Agree, will we ever get the first or second choice forward line together?

Jack probably would have been back this week and therefore only missing Curnow.

McGovern has the rest of this year and next to get it together, looked a bad hammy though so can’t see him back in the 1’s for 6-8 weeks


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Wouldn't jack Martin or Zac fisher be in our best forward line?

 

[Burgers45]

What's happened to our Tuesday night injury update. Running a bit late?

 

[Christou2Kouta]

No updates on the Carlton site yet but the AFL site has an updated injury list:
Dow and McGovern listed as TBC
Carroll, Murphy, Williams and Silvagni listed as Test
Martin 2 weeks
Kemp 2-3 weeks
Fisher 5-6 weeks
McDonald 10-12 weeks
Marchbank Season
Charlie indefinite

 

[The Bighouse]

No updates on the Carlton site yet but the AFL site has an updated injury list:
Dow and McGovern listed as TBC
Carroll, Murphy, Williams and Silvagni listed as Test
Martin 2 weeks
Kemp 2-3 weeks
Fisher 5-6 weeks
McDonald 10-12 weeks
Marchbank Season
Charlie indefinite

Kemp has slipped back, hasn’t he?
Maybe for the return post-VFL bye.
Martin a week schedule behind too, if still 2 weeks away.

 

[Christou2Kouta]

Kemp has slipped back, hasn’t he?
Maybe for the return post-VFL bye.
Martin a week schedule behind too, if still 2 weeks away.

Yeah, post bye makes sense for Kemp. He's clearly not back this week so it's two weeks minimum depending on how he responds to the increasing training loads. Can't wait to see him out there.

 

[The Fantom]

What's happened to our Tuesday night injury update. Running a bit late?

I could be wrong but I thought we get them on Wednesday’s if we play Sunday.

 

[skadoosh]

JSOS likely in.
McGovern 8-10 weeks...
Williams likely available.
Murphy test.
Wait and see for Dow. Test.

Injury news: Multiple set to return, McGovern set for sidelines

Jack Silvagni is set to return for the injured Mitch McGovern.

www.carltonfc.com.au

 

[RPCB]

That sucks about Gov.

 

[Kruezing]

No updates on the Carlton site yet but the AFL site has an updated injury list:
Dow and McGovern listed as TBC
Carroll, Murphy, Williams and Silvagni listed as Test
Martin 2 weeks
Kemp 2-3 weeks
Fisher 5-6 weeks
McDonald 10-12 weeks
Marchbank Season
Charlie indefinite

McGovern 8-10 weeks meaning season allowing for the factored add ons every Tuesday …

 

[The Bighouse]

That sucks about Gov.

Yep, wasn’t expecting that. Thought AR was about to say high grade, 3-4 weeks and then bang, 8-10.

Hopefully JSOS is fit over this time.

 

[Navy_Blueblood]

Real pity for Gov but perfect timing to get JSOS back, who is my preferred 3rd tall in any event

 

[FRUMPY]

Did look a bad hammy so not surprised

Sent from my CPH2005 using Tapatalk

 

[rp84]

I'm expecting it to be a regulation 4 weeker, hopefully. We (he) just can't change our injury fortunes. Forward line keeps taking hits.

Nah that looked terrible at the time

 

[BigFrizz36]

Nah that looked terrible at the time

8 - 10 weeks apparently.

 

[HBF]

Feel for Gov. That looked like a shocking hammy!