I would not be giving up pick #5 for any trade involving Marchbank/GWS unless pick #8 was coming back, and we got se better scraps.
A deal of
OUT: #5, #2017 2nd (Worth more than our 2016 2nd to them)
IN: #8, Marchbank, Pickett/Ahern/Corr and McKenna
Or
OUT: #5, 2017 2nd, 2017 3rd (both worth more to them than our 2016 2nd and 3rd's)
IN: #8, Marchbank, Steele
But i really want to keep pick #5, honestly. 2017 2nd for Marchbank.
Or if they need a higher first to get pick #1 off Ess, trade our 2017 1st. 2017 1st for Pick #8 and Marchbank, or 2017 1st for 2016 GWS 1st (#16ish) and 2017 Geel 1st (#18ish) and Marchbank.
Option
A: #8, Marchbank, (injured talent), McKenna, #23, #40, 2016 WBD 3rd, Carl 2017 1st, Carl 2017 3rd.
B: #8, Marchank, Steele, #23, #40, WBD 2016 3rd, Carl 2017 1st
C: #5, #23, #40, WBD 2016 3rd, Carl 2017 1st & 3rd, Marchbank
D: #5, #8, #23, #40, Marchbank, WBD 2016 3rd, Carl 2017 2nd & 3rd
E: #5, #16, #18, #23, #40, WBD 3rd, Marchbank, Carl 2017 2nd & 3rd.
Which option is best?
Personal preference would be; D, E, C, B, A
We might snag a player like McKenna in every scenario as well
Sent from my SM-N910G using Tapatalk