Rumour Bluemour Discussion thread - The sequel - I know what SOS did last Sumner

[Azul]

What would people think about 35 and George Horlin-Smith for Tuohy?

It has been bumped back to 36 now.

Chuck in Gregson? We don't have enough players with busted feet.

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

What would people think about 35 and George Horlin-Smith for Tuohy?

What happened to his 2016 season? 1 game
What happened to his 2015 season? 7 games

After playing 21 in 2014. Has he ben injured?

 

[My name geoff]

If we settle for Gibbs & 24 for Lyons & 13 could this mean that we are any chance to get the GWS group for pick 13 alone ??

So you would settle to trade in an older nick Graham and upgrade our pick 24 by 11 places for our second best player?

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

I know a lot of people aren't fans but I would be really happy for Motlop for Touhy. For and inconsistent year he kicked 38 goals.

Gees, the guy has a fatter gut than I do and I'm not a professional AFL footballer. No thanks.

 

[luke livingston seagull]

What would people think about 35 and George Horlin-Smith for Tuohy?

I'd consider it but Dangerfield seems pretty content in Moggs Creek

 

[The Flying Doormat]

Out of crisis comes opportunity. The nervous nellies amongst us have the attention span of a goldfish. Have you forgotten what SOS did last trade period? Dunno about the rest of you but I'm anticipating another bumper crop of trades and recruits.

 

[Mr_Plow]

If we settle for Gibbs & 24 for Lyons & 13 could this mean that we are any chance to get the GWS group for pick 13 alone ??

We aren't settling for it. There will be no settling. Just ask SOS. We will not settle.



In all seriousness, I hope we don't have to part with pick 5. This is the beginning of a lengthy rebuild. Take anything but pick 5.

 

[teknodeejay]

I reckon Tuohy had an ordinary 2015 and a much better 2016. If someone is really rating him that highly enough to trade something worth a lot to our club in our position, you do the deal. Tuohy is the kind of player who can be very good and have quite ordinary spells. Certainly replaceable in my view.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

So you would settle to trade in an older nick Graham and upgrade our pick 24 by 11 places for our second best player?

Only if we can get overs in the other deal, need to look at the whole equation or nett profit in this scenario.

In- GWS 5 (Marchbank, Stewart, Corr, Pickett, Kennedy) & Lyons

Out- Gibbs & pick 13

*Importantly keep pick 5 for a future Gibbs midfield type replacement.

 

[Prem17]

Cats tend to get what they want

They won't have enough cattle on board to get all these picks the way they are going.
Maybe they will end up sending off someone like Cockatoo? Not to us but for a pick?

 

[passmark]

I reckon Tuohy had an ordinary 2015 and a much better 2016. If someone is really rating him that highly enough to trade something worth a lot to our club in our position, you do the deal. Tuohy is the kind of player who can be very good and have quite ordinary spells. Certainly replaceable in my view.

You sure about Zacs 2015.?

 

[I AM CARLTON]

The more I look at this GWS 5 the more I don't like it. Incidently Corr's management say he is going nowhere. Would take Ahern in fact would DEMAND Ahern be part of any deal.

 

[Stiffler's Dad]

No one calls me quitter.

I knew it.
Only took you five or ten minutes.
Just call me Mr Nostradamus.

 

[agro]

Only if we can get overs in the other deal, need to look at the whole equation or nett profit in this scenario.

In- GWS 5 (Marchbank, Stewart, Corr, Pickett, Kennedy) & Lyons

Out- Gibbs & pick 13

*Importantly keep pick 5 for a future Gibbs midfield type replacement.

13 and Lyons is a terrible deal for Gibbs and we've been conditioned to accept it like Pavlov's Dogs.

Lyons is just bog standard average.


Gibbs will be an absolute gun in Adelaides midfield - don't forget how Gibbs smashed Geelong earlier this year (Selwood and Dangerfield).

Adelaide know exactly what they are getting - the bare minimum in this deal is 13 and Lever.


And if we so much as think about giving 13 to GWS for Marchbank I'll spew up.

 

[Jeremias]

Incidently Corr's management say he is going nowhere.

So did Gibbs' management.

 

[dumb]

Zach got caught with ball in hand quite a bit earlier this year. Finished up being a very solid year though. No to motlop, we're good for inconsistent half forwards right now.

 

[Blue_Fusion]

So, where are all the people saying Gibbs will never leave and we should stop even mentioning it?

Walking out half way through a contract. Good thing we hold all the cards.

Cannot give up Gibbs + #24 for Lyons + #13. I think we've developed a reputation over the last decade of being idiots and now everyone thinks they can low ball us and get away with it.

Has to be a top 10 pick. If they don't have one, then #13 + a better player than Lyons while we keep #24.

If we trade pick #5 as well our midfield is going to be ****ed for years, but I've already said that quite a few times yesterday.

We'll be getting top 5 picks for the next 3-4 years.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

13 and Lyons is a terrible deal for Gibbs and we've been conditioned to accept it like Pavlov's Dogs.

Lyons is just bog standard average.


Gibbs will be an absolute gun in Adelaides midfield - don't forget how Gibbs smashed Geelong earlier this year (Selwood and Dangerfield).

Adelaide know exactly what they are getting - the bare minimum in this deal is 13 and Lever.


And if we so much as think about giving 13 to GWS for Marchbank I'll spew up.

I dont particulary think it has to be Lyons either, can be someone else.

I just want to keep pick 5 if we can.

 

[Prem17]

Out of crisis comes opportunity. The nervous nellies amongst us have the attention span of a goldfish. Have you forgotten what SOS did last trade period? Dunno about the rest of you but I'm anticipating another bumper crop of trades and recruits.

Last year though it was getting rid of the 3 sooks that brought us good picks. This year we are parting with 2 of our better players, so we need to make sure that the ones coming in are all 150+ game players for Carlton.

 

[jezzajay]

Tuohy for Pick 30 and Josh Walker is what I'm hearing.

Wait.. hold up

not sure if youre being serious...but didnt josh walker go to brisbane this year?

 

[Just Kreuzing]

Zach got caught with ball in hand quite a bit earlier this year. Finished up being a very solid year though. No to motlop, we're good for inconsistent half forwards right now.

I cringed many times when Zac had the ball this year, has a good penetrating kick on him but not sold on his game awareness or footy IQ.

 

[The Toad]

Two opposition clubs plonk huge contract offers in front of him weeks ago that we just cannot match and you are surprised he wants to jump ship ??

Sorry, that is completely baffling.

I'm terribly sorry, didn't know about the other contracts.
My most humble apologies.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Warsaw]

Far more comfortable in losing 13 for Marchbank and co, than I ever will be with 5.

 

[Aphrodite]

I'm terribly sorry, didn't know about the other contracts.
My most humble apologies.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

In all fairness to you Toady, you haven't been around these parts for a while.

 

[agro]

I dont particulary think it has to be Lyons either, can be someone else.

I just want to keep pick 5 if we can.

I want to keep pick 13 as well - and I don't want 13 used in the Marchbank scenario.

We need to use picks 5 and 13 for the best mid fielders available in this draft.

Lyons is not enough - pick 13 and Lever at a bare minimum