Blues v Port review

Remove this Banner Ad

from ODN.net

Carlton came into the match against Port Adelaide at Football Park today hoping to square the ledger, to 2-2 this season and the overall head to head record to 4-4. It was not to be .... :(

Carlton had a late change when Luke Livingston finally got his first taste of senior football coming into the side for Ian Prendergast. In what was an unusual match Port jumped the Blues early and looked like they were running training drills until imposing skipper Matthew Primus pulled up with what may be a knee or hamstring injury. From there the momentum changed and the Blues man to man game plan saw them start taking control of general play and the pressure they are known for surfaced to allow them to chip away at the Port lead. Much of Port's scoring was coming from the ball being swept down the ground in numbers. The Port forwards were struggling with Beaumont dominating running outside the defensive 50 and Lance Whitnall accounting for Tredrea with superior football smarts and great backup from the defensive runners in Gallagher and especially Andy McKay.

The half time break was the Blues worst enemy today as the two teams went in with scores level. One count help but think that Carlton were pleased with their efforts thus far while Port were very disappointed. The third quarter was a lesson in what a lapse in concentration can do as the Port Power dominated the centre clearances and had free players forward and behind the centre square. How this is possible is beyond me and can only be put down to the Power's willingness to run all day or a lack of accountability by the Blues runners. Whatever the reason Port 'powered' on 7 goals in half a quarter to blow the game apart. The Blues steadied late and goals to Gallagher and Merrington who was a rare shining light up forward stemmed the flow before Che Cockatoo-Collins waltzed around the defence to regain the momentum for Port going into the three quarter break 6 goals up.

Carlton seemed to copy Port's blueprint early in the final stanza when they gained first use of the ball from the centre bounce with quick goals to Hickmott, Murphy and Houlihan narrowing the margin to 18 points. Another foray forward saw an opportunity wasted for the Blues and when Cockatoo-Collins fortuitously marked a kicked that dropped short and goaled, the Blues challenge had ended in a big way. Injuries and illness to Bradley, Hickmott, Hulme and Sporn had depleted the Blues use of the bench and once the momentum had been halted the Carlton players ran out of legs. An 8 goal quarter by Port to match their 8 third quarter goals will probably have the Blues defence knockers come out of the woodwork yet again. Dermott Brereton also made the comment during the last quarter that the Blues had had some scores kicked against them this year. Well an average of 13 goals against in the first 3 rounds and a high score of 111 make a lie of this claim. More to the point, this game began a shootout in the second half as the Blues strayed from their game plan. Port were always going to be favoured by this style of play and unfortunately 6 goals by Tredrea unfairly leave the impression that Whitnall had his colours lowered. I disagree.

Port's momentum came from fantastic running, some loose checking, riding their luck with the umpires and the bounce of the ball. No excuses there, just frustration that the Blues momentum lost its way when it mattered most. More teams will find out this year that when Port gets things going their way, they are irrepressible.

Positives to come from the match apart from the good form of stalwarts Andy McKay, Simon Beaumont, Lance Whitnall and Darren Hulme were the contributions from Andrew Merrington, Simon Wiggins, Luke Livingston and Trent Sporn who was an important part of the Blues first half success. Coincidentally (or perhaps not), the Blues lost a bit of fluidity in defence once Sporn went off the ground.

It may seem like a stupid statement I am about to make but if had to have lost this game then it might be beneficial to us to have it blown out in the end so we will be spared from the players thinking "gee, we had a real dip today." As it stands they will be embarrassed by their fade out and we can expect another backs to the wall effort next week against the Roos, another team that will have a lot to play for after two consecutive losses.
 
Can't say I disagree with much from a Port viewpoint.

Whitnall definately had the better of the 1st half on Tredrea, and moved forward in the last quarter anyway.

Merrington seems to be good on the lead, and is a good kick for goal, rarely looked like missing a set shot.

I'm not sure the scoreboard accurately reflects the game, I was scared of being done halfway through the last, only a late flurry of goals after the challenge was stopped made it look bad.

Good to see the new crop of blues still willing to have a dip thuogh after the early 3rd quarter blitz, there are far more experienced sides that would have just dropped the bundle then and there (hell i dont even know if we would get back from that as well).

Good luck for the rest of the year (at least until rd 4+15 is 19 i guess).
 
Excellent synopsis of the game - good to see the young players finnaly getting a go Lets hope the club continues to keep them in the side - the major disappointments were McKernan (what is wrong with him), Mansfield? and even the coach was obviously unhappy with Bradley (his lack of accountability was shown out on a number of occasions - if he was that crook why did he come back on in the 3rd q and then when the tide turned late in the q he got crook again??)
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I thought the Carlton coaching staff erred with Whitnall.

He played well on Tredrea....although Tredders still ended up with 6 so really he was ineffectual in the end analysis. What Carlton lacked through was a marking forward. McKernen was hopeless and looked completely lost. I would have played Whitnall down back in the 1st and 3rd quarters and up forward in the 2nd and 4th. The decision to leave him down back in the second quarter was a mistake IMHO.

I was also not impressed with Carlton's receivers. Ratten did OK and got in and under....but I felt Camporeale (sp ?) and even Bradley when he was on the ground were not particularly damaging....much less than Schoflied and Stevens for example.

A disappointing game in the end I thought. Really only 15 minutes by Port won the game and the rest was fairly scrappy.

Satay Mat
 
Pretty good account of events. For your guys Merrington impressed me, especially his kicking for goal - perhaps tredders started to take notes as he kicked his last 5 staright - thanks Merro.
BTW what was wrong with Bradley, he looked ****house we he came off in the third looked really ill, was it the flu?
Agree that Whitnall had the better of Tredrea til half time (although tredders could of kicked 3 in the first quarter IMO). However, the Blues never looked the same without him up forward. Just need a couple of talls back, Manton will help and surely Campo & Braddles will play better again in the near future. Will be a tough one this week for you blokes v North.
 
i agree with most of you people , i thought that we lost the game at the start of the 3rd quarter, i beleive our centre players did not pressure the port mid feild enough ,instead of kicking the ball from the centre we chose to hand ball,kicking long in the forward line might have being a better option although mcernan,and lappin did not play too good,i also felt that we gave away way too many free kicks,to them which ended up in goals for them.
humes mark and miss 30 metres from goal should have being a ddefinite,although a 50 metres penalty should have being paid to him,wangadine went for the man not the ball, and cokcddoo collins should not have being paid that mark i thought our players lost the momentum,and let port run with easy goals,another point
we need more from houlahan he should have kicked that goal he missed he needs too improve dramaticly, at the same time i was impressesd with wittnals game and merringtons.some how i feeel that we can improve and learn from this defeat,hume is one of our better guttsy players i hope the rest learn from him.our star players need too lift and get out of this slump!! sorry for the spelling mistakes.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top