Board discussion

[jono25]

yeah mate- it is not you but the rest of us that is insane
hbf closed the thread because you are a child and decide to slang personal abuse at people

no I asked somebody to justify what I consider to be a really stupid statement.

The non-aligned posters in the thread were actually pointing out the abuse was coming from posters other than myself. But you keep posting garbage and refuse to address the substance of your mate's comments.

 

[blue gunslinger]

again ignores the issue and attacks the man. Anyhow shall leave it to the mods to sort out.

lets see the respected hbf closes a thread and you question his judgement
your honour our case rests and we ask for an immediate hanging

 

[thylacine60]

no I asked somebody to justify what I consider to be a really stupid statement.

The non-aligned posters in the thread were actually pointing out the abuse was coming from posters other than myself. But you keep posting garbage and refuse to address the substance of your mate's comments.

Mate you're off the books, get yourself a latte and thumb an old law journal. You're the only one who gives a shit any more.

 

[blue gunslinger]

no I asked somebody to justify what I consider to be a really stupid statement.

The non-aligned posters in the thread were actually pointing out the abuse was coming from posters other than myself. But you keep posting garbage and refuse to address the substance of your mate's comments.

I am not alligned with anybody but when I see a poster post crap I will tell them it is crap
Fev is a good bloke, Stalin had mates as well you know

 

[bluepride]

I really want to see if a 'Board Discussion' thread can be locked. .

 

[LemmingMaster]

And why would a mod (HBF) close down the thread where that person is being asked to justify their comments?

The thread had to be closed for constant obvious personal attacks. The personal attacks have then moved to this thread, so as you can see the other thread was never going to get back on track.

I would guess that the mods will have words to certain posters from that thread.

 

[Jeremias]

FFS, you moronic imbecile, no-one actually gives a shit in the end. It's off season and exposing you for the overblown arrogant ponse you are is just a bit of sport. Let it go and get yourself down to the soup-kitchen with your pious face on.

Thy....have you ever met a non moronic imbecile?

 

[thylacine60]

I really want to see if a 'Board Discussion' thread can be locked. .

Everything can be locked - except it seems your internet access at the sanitarium.

 

[blue gunslinger]

sorry T-I retire

 

[jono25]

The thread had to be closed for constant obvious personal attacks. The personal attacks have then moved to this thread, so as you can see the other thread was never going to get back on track.

I would guess that the mods will have words to certain posters from that thread.

Yet the neutral posters in the thread were pointing out where the personal abuse was in fact coming from. But the Mod who closes the thread chooses to take the side (once again) of the posters who have been on the board the longest.

Honestly if this place is to be moderated based on a boys club why allow new posters to join?

 

[bluepride]

Everything can be locked - except it seems your internet access at the sanitarium.

I keep showing you love and affection and this is how you treat me.

I am shocked and appalled.

I didnt say anything bad to you .

 

[blue gunslinger]

Yet the neutral posters in the thread were pointing out where the personal abuse was in fact coming from. But the Mod who closes the thread chooses to take the side (once again) of the posters who have been on the board the longest.

Honestly if this place is to be moderated based on a boys club why allow new posters to join?

nice interpretation of events. It is clear your knowledge on the roles and responsabilities of a mod are so deep. How would you have dealt with a poster say describing another as a w***er?

 

[zeeCFC]

I keep showing you love and affection and this is how you treat me.

I am shocked and appalled.

I didnt say anything bad to you .

show some pride, bluepr...

...love the off-season

 

[Blue and Silver]

I keep showing you love and affection and this is how you treat me.

I am shocked and appalled.

I didnt say anything bad to you .

Pretty common rule, DON'T PET THE THYLACINE

 

[LemmingMaster]

Yet the neutral posters in the thread were pointing out where the personal abuse was in fact coming from. But the Mod who closes the thread chooses to take the side (once again) of the posters who have been on the board the longest.

Honestly if this place is to be moderated based on a boys club why allow new posters to join?

Unless I've missed something, I see no evidence of the mods taken the side of the "boys club", they simply closed down a thread that was beyond repair.

I am unsure, like yourself if they will or have sent a PM to advise certain posters that their attitude is not appreciated.

I think it is time you just forget about this topic, neither side is going to change their view point and I seriously doubt you will ever get the response you so desire from these boys club members.

 

[jono25]

nice interpretation of events. It is clear your knowledge on the roles and responsabilities of a mod are so deep. How would you have dealt with a poster say describing another as a w***er?

harshly.

but then somebody arguing to change the rules of evidence to convict an individual would be banned from posting because of suggesting something utterly inconsistent with social norms.

 

[bluepride]

But I love him, I really do.

Im just attracted to him.

On a serious note, I put forth a idea that before anyone is allowed to post on this board (each day) a positive comment must be said about another poster.
Sticky it on the board page.
PM me ODN on your thoughts?

 

[jono25]

Unless I've missed something, I see no evidence of the mods taken the side of the "boys club", they simply closed down a thread that was beyond repair.

I am unsure, like yourself if they will or have sent a PM to advise certain posters that their attitude is not appreciated.

I think it is time you just forget about this topic, neither side is going to change their view point and I seriously doubt you will ever get the response you so desire from these boys club members.

yeah its the contents of HBF's PM that angers me - not closing the thread. Demonstrates one of the many critcisms of this board by posters, that it is essentially a boys club. When that is supported by the mods - it spells problems and probably explains why Carlton posters on this board have such a bad reputation in other parts of the website.

But your advice is very sound - thank you. I shall go and enjoy the mixed doubles in the Hopman Cup. Definitely won't be renewing my annual subscription to this board unless the boys club mentality changes.

 

[blue gunslinger]

yeah its the contents of HBF's PM that angers me - not closing the thread. Demonstrates one of the many critcisms of this board by posters, that it is essentially a boys club. When that is supported by the mods - it spells problems and probably explains why Carlton posters on this board have such a bad reputation in other parts of the website.

But your advice is very sound - thank you. I shall go and enjoy the mixed doubles in the Hopman Cup. Definitely won't be renewing my annual subscription to this board unless the boys club mentality changes.

not going to happen so see ya

 

[jono25]

not going to happen so see ya

Oh I didn't realise this was your website. Silly me - sorry.

 

[blue gunslinger]

Oh I didn't realise this was your website. Silly me - sorry.

ah talk talk walk walk
credibility=zero

 

[Jeremias]

Do you honestly think we care whether or not you fork out money before sprouting some of the shit you have been?

 

[ESKIE]

yeah its the contents of HBF's PM that angers me - not closing the thread. Demonstrates one of the many critcisms of this board by posters, that it is essentially a boys club. When that is supported by the mods - it spells problems and probably explains why Carlton posters on this board have such a bad reputation in other parts of the website.

But your advice is very sound - thank you. I shall go and enjoy the mixed doubles in the Hopman Cup. Definitely won't be renewing my annual subscription to this board unless the boys club mentality changes.

Well not for us girls it isn;t

I find the carlton board and BF a great place to post/visit never had any real problems, enjoy the agreements and disagreements with everyone, it;s just the colour and movement of the whole thing...heaps of fun for me !

 

[thylacine60]

Well not for us girls it isn;t

I find the carlton board and BF a great place to post/visit never had any real problems, enjoy the agreements and disagreements with everyone, it;s just the colour and movement of the whole thing...heaps of fun for me !

Just the vibe of the thing?

 

[ESKIE]

Just the vibe of the thing?

Maybe some of you hairy galloots take it all too serious