Post BF Upgrade Feedback - Click Here

Remove this Banner Ad

Boncers Basic Bitch (WW)

  • Thread starter Thread starter boncer34
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

GREENESHOOTS said:
I wasn't sure if damicky or MisterM was lying about their role.
Click to expand...
Makes sense. But ****, this is not helping at all right now haha. boncer34 would be pretty happy with how this game has turned out I reckon.

I don't think I want to vote for one of the three seers. It's clear one is lying and I don't know who to believe. I also think that the one lying is not head evil but an accomplice to a hidden head so I'm not sure it's worth trying to lynch someone who is likely to die to either the SK or the other evil faction tonight. Better to keep all three alive and take the chance that the evil seer is killed and we get another night of at least 1 but hopefully 2 seer results.

I'm laying my vote on someone quiet because it's Day 3 now and they've been low key the entire time which suggests to me head evil laying low for as long as possible. RU_.
 
ClarkeM said:
Makes sense. But fu**, this is not helping at all right now haha. boncer34 would be pretty happy with how this game has turned out I reckon.

I don't think I want to vote for one of the three seers. It's clear one is lying and I don't know who to believe. I also think that the one lying is not head evil but an accomplice to a hidden head so I'm not sure it's worth trying to lynch someone who is likely to die to either the SK or the other evil faction tonight. Better to keep all three alive and take the chance that the evil seer is killed and we get another night of at least 1 but hopefully 2 seer results.

I'm laying my vote on someone quiet because it's Day 3 now and they've been low key the entire time which suggests to me head evil laying low for as long as possible. RU_.
Click to expand...

I am even happy to take your recommendation on who to Seer tonight (if I’m still here)
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Mister M said:
The Seer/Fake Seer will NOT be told which one they are. Which is safe to assume that boncer34 wouldn't tell you the result of the exact result of the other seer, just that they are the other Seer/Fake Seer.
Click to expand...
I actually disagree, I think seering the seer would/should give which seer they are - obviously on the proviso that the seer is the real seer.

The Seer themselves are not told whether they themselves are the real one or not however seers of that seer should give that information.

If the seer seered the fake seer, then the seer result shouldn't show "real/fake seer" as that's both true and false and they are only told correct information.
If the fake seer seered the seer, then the seer result shouldn't show "real/fake seer" as that's both true and false and they are only told incorrect information.

The seer learns the player's role of whom they seer. Nowhere in the roles does it say what they "seer as" which too leads me to believe that

At least one of you three is lying and while it'd be nice to know which, with three night-immune roles still in the game, I don't think the priority should be on the likely 1/3 of you being an evil seer. It should be on looking for night-immune evil.

#Seer #Seer #Seer
 
ClarkeM said:
I actually disagree, I think seering the seer would/should give which seer they are - obviously on the proviso that the seer is the real seer.

The Seer themselves are not told whether they themselves are the real one or not however seers of that seer should give that information.

If the seer seered the fake seer, then the seer result shouldn't show "real/fake seer" as that's both true and false and they are only told correct information.
If the fake seer seered the seer, then the seer result shouldn't show "real/fake seer" as that's both true and false and they are only told incorrect information.

The seer learns the player's role of whom they seer. Nowhere in the roles does it say what they "seer as" which too leads me to believe that

At least one of you three is lying and while it'd be nice to know which, with three night-immune roles still in the game, I don't think the priority should be on the likely 1/3 of you being an evil seer. It should be on looking for night-immune evil.

#Seer #Seer #Seer
Click to expand...
25 "seer"s.

Seeriously...
 
ClarkeM said:
I actually disagree, I think seering the seer would/should give which seer they are - obviously on the proviso that the seer is the real seer.

The Seer themselves are not told whether they themselves are the real one or not however seers of that seer should give that information.

If the seer seered the fake seer, then the seer result shouldn't show "real/fake seer" as that's both true and false and they are only told correct information.
If the fake seer seered the seer, then the seer result shouldn't show "real/fake seer" as that's both true and false and they are only told incorrect information.

The seer learns the player's role of whom they seer. Nowhere in the roles does it say what they "seer as" which too leads me to believe that

At least one of you three is lying and while it'd be nice to know which, with three night-immune roles still in the game, I don't think the priority should be on the likely 1/3 of you being an evil seer. It should be on looking for night-immune evil.

#Seer #Seer #Seer
Click to expand...

Now I am even more confused
 
The more I read back, the more I think that we're only worse off if we try and lynch one of you three today.

There's 10 of us left I think right? Which means 9 going into tonight with three kills up their sleeves. If all three kills hit overnight, we're down to 6 left including the SK which means as long as they avoid lynch tomorrow, they win.

We need to hit night immune but ideally, we need to hit the SK today. Chances are, a 1/3 shot at which is the evil seer is not worth a lynch today and even id we got it right, the chances that that seer was in fact the head of either evil faction is incredible slim. This will also mean that with only 2 kills tonight, we have both more numbers and ultimately more time to find head evil.

It's been a while since I've played but far out, I think the SK is in a great position right now and the "seer" fight is futile. Surely?
 
ClarkeM said:
The more I read back, the more I think that we're only worse off if we try and lynch one of you three today.

There's 10 of us left I think right? Which means 9 going into tonight with three kills up their sleeves. If all three kills hit overnight, we're down to 6 left including the SK which means as long as they avoid lynch tomorrow, they win.

We need to hit night immune but ideally, we need to hit the SK today. Chances are, a 1/3 shot at which is the evil seer is not worth a lynch today and even id we got it right, the chances that that seer was in fact the head of either evil faction is incredible slim. This will also mean that with only 2 kills tonight, we have both more numbers and ultimately more time to find head evil.

It's been a while since I've played but far out, I think the SK is in a great position right now and the "seer" fight is futile. Surely?
Click to expand...
If we don't think damicky is in a faction then he is most likely the SK
 

Remove this Banner Ad

omgfridge said:
not too fussed either way but one of those 3 is talking sh*t

greeneshoots

boncer34
Click to expand...
Anyone falling for this?^ 3 minutes before deadline. Dies as a wolf. Knows one of the three are talking shit and votes Greeneshoots for the reverse Monty Hall...?

Greeneshoots is a wolf, unlikely to be head wolf though and frankly is the least of my concerns right now.

I'm backing you in damicky. You can't be evil and I'm not believing you are the SK as that would make no sense why you'd open up to having the amulet N1/D1 and admitting that you forgot to pass it on. Also, Greeneshoots with the early seer of you seems to be a feeble attempt to sway the village early and yep, I'll admit, it's stumped me for a while here

We need to find the SK and we need to find them today.

We will also lose dogs105 to a modkill if he doesn't vote today too which only brings the SK's chances of winning closer.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I think Clarkey is on the right track regarding not lynching the seers and the SK being close to winning.

MC Bad Genius please boncer34
 
ClarkeM said:
Anyone falling for this?^ 3 minutes before deadline. Dies as a wolf. Knows one of the three are talking sh*t and votes Greeneshoots for the reverse Monty Hall...?

Greeneshoots is a wolf, unlikely to be head wolf though and frankly is the least of my concerns right now.

I'm backing you in damicky. You can't be evil and I'm not believing you are the SK as that would make no sense why you'd open up to having the amulet N1/D1 and admitting that you forgot to pass it on. Also, Greeneshoots with the early seer of you seems to be a feeble attempt to sway the village early and yep, I'll admit, it's stumped me for a while here

We need to find the SK and we need to find them today.

We will also lose dogs105 to a modkill if he doesn't vote today too which only brings the SK's chances of winning closer.
Click to expand...
Yup, agree. The likelihood of one of the "seers" being the Serial Killer seems pretty small. I still think Greeneshoots is Mafia though. But I'm well aware that I struggle to change my mind once I've used my gut instinct to peg someone as evil, so I need to be open to potentially Mister M being evil. I'm really certain that damicky is good though.
 
damicky is far too much of a noob to be bullshitting here imo. One of GS or MM has lied. Would damicky's seer night 3 have been unsuccessful if GS had been protected? I get the logic of trying to hit night immune, not sure of the targets so far.

I'll vote Greeneshoots again and swap if a good option presents. boncer34
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

JHF1870
    • Love
    • Like
WW - The Purge (Directed by JHF1870) Friday 23 January
2 3
Replies
59
Views
667
BEaston
BEaston

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom