Brad Green?

[hotpie]

Not the worst player around, he could be useful at Collingwood. What would he be worth in a trade that Melbourne might like? I'm thinking Cole or Lonie, failing that offer pick 21. He's a bit dsoft so we dont want to be selling the farm to get him.

 

[Funkalicous]

You guys won't sell the farm for anyone......

 

[Jabso]

I would like him on our list, but isn't an absoloute must-get, on top of that Melbourne would ask way too much.

 

[FIGJAM]

You guys won't sell the farm for anyone......

Because we don't have a history of it? See McKee!

 

[MarkT]

I think he' be a good get. He addresses 1 of our fundamental problems which is footskills but he isn't particularly quick or hard. We also don't need his forward work as much as we need pace and skill in the midfield. If he comes relatively cheap then snap him up but don’t sacrifice a more suitable (for our list) player in the process.

 

[CarnthePies]

I miss Steve Mckee

We needed him this year with the lack of rucks

 

[Funkalicous]

Because we don't have a history of it? See McKee!

Was thinking of more recent examples: Nick Stevens, Nathan Brown, ect...

 

[hotpie]

Was thinking of more recent examples: Nick Stevens, Nathan Brown, ect...

Nick Stevens went on to fame and glory leading Carlton to a wooden spoon. Overrated hack. Browns a good player - 14 clubs failed to get him, including Carlton, who wasted all their salary cap on Kouta Lappin and Camporeale

 

[demondavey]

Green for lonie or cole??????????? are you insane!!!!!!!!!!! Cole and lonie could both be delisted!!!!!!! Green is a freak! I would not even take tarrant for brad green! I would take clement though! haha

 

[Funkalicous]

Nick Stevens went on to fame and glory leading Carlton to a wooden spoon. Overrated hack. Browns a good player - 14 clubs failed to get him, including Carlton, who wasted all their salary cap on Kouta Lappin and Camporeale

No need to get feral. I was just making an observation....

 

[Jimbeam]

they might like cole and our latest 1st rounder 23? Ds need somone that can go hard, not prounce around like a fairy.. i dont want him though, we dont need him.. where would he play?

 

[Slander]

Green may not be much chop but a lot of you are waaaaaay overrating Richie Cole.

 

[Jimbeam]

yeh but i think he came 6th BF in 04.. so he might be worth a look..

 

[rychenroller]

Green for lonie or cole??????????? are you insane!!!!!!!!!!! Cole and lonie could both be delisted!!!!!!! Green is a freak! I would not even take tarrant for brad green! I would take clement though! haha

Green is soft as the day is long who gets found out if under pressure or a semi decent tag. Only reason Collingwood could possibly want him is his finishing skills. Dont overrate him

 

[Murray]

I miss Steve Mckee

We needed him this year with the lack of rucks

Same result with or without him

 

[Murray]

Green for lonie or cole??????????? are you insane!!!!!!!!!!! Cole and lonie could both be delisted!!!!!!! Green is a freak! I would not even take tarrant for brad green! I would take clement though! haha

Well stop hawking him around then

 

[PiesMan]

Richard Cole is a disgrace,

he resembled Dean "rissole" Rioli at the moment. Hes fat, slow and soft. there is absolutely no way Melbourne would even flirt with the idea of trading him for Brad Green. You are all dreaming, Cole will either get offered a contract with the pies (which angers me) or get delisted.

 

[Robyn_323]

You guys over rate your players so much. Lonie and Cole are no where near as good as Green is. Melbourne will not trade Green or anyone for that matter so quit dreaming have a go at a quick midfielder that is what you need perhaps Kerr.

 

[Jimbeam]

no to be honest i dont rate cole or lonie that high, but i dont rate green that much either.. i'd be happy to c cole de listed or offered a crack at another club, lonie has had a rough year off field..

 

[shuveradda_41]

No thanks!

Good skills not overly good in any other department. And also melbourne would ask for us to break the bank for him. No way.

 

[hotpie]

lonie has had a rough year off field..

two years in a row??? Does he have a rough year every year, or is he just soft??

 

[Coin_Toss]

two years in a row??? Does he have a rough year every year, or is he just soft??

Don't you remember? Lonie's dad died.

 

[hotpie]

Don't you remember? Lonie's dad died.

last year.

 

[goalpie]

Why would Melbourne give Green to Collingwood for a few dopes.

I dont think they would be that stupid.

 

[dee_molisher]

Honestly, I couldn't see any player on Collingwoods list that Melbourne would be remotely interested in... except Buckley or Frazer