I doubt you would be harangued. Also doubt we would be waiting 4 years to know.
But patience is cheap.
Do we condemn Eg Grundy (randomly selected ofcourse

) for his first few years before he emerged this year.
Ruckmen take time.
Sier may or may not make it, but if he's identified as a great potential mid,by all means draft him.
It's a crap shoot anyway.
The real strike rates of any clubs drafting you may find is not particularly high.
I think people that get snarky at Derek Hine are being a bit impolite. He does a fine job, not sure why we'd bag one of our better assets. Doesn't make sense to me.
Makes me wonder who drafted Grundy.... now who could that be....?
Siers draft year also netted us Phillips, Crocker, Wills, (Smith as a rookie) so looks like we went ok, this far.
(Ps the in Hine we trust thing, is just a bit of fun, don't think he prints his stationery with it, it's just a big footy silliness, but harmless.)