Brent Moloney vs Corey Enright

[demondude]

i think enright would struggle to fit in our midfield to be honest

bruce,green,mclean,mcdonald,jonhstone imo are all better than enright...im sorry cats fans but enright is seriously OVERATED! just lyk many of the players in ur team...shame on the cats fan who said our midfield was crap, shame shame it is actually one of the best in the comp

 

[chapmanmagic35]

If you use that excuse Enright sounds like a frontrunner.
Beamer played well in our losing streak last year and was one of the few who could hold his head high during that period.
Proved enough? What has Enright ever proved? He is 25 and I don't see him getting any better, and he has a 5th in the B&F in 2004 to show for all that.

Been ravaged by injuries...

Instead of making an ill-informed judgement, please watch him play.

 

[chapmanmagic35]

i think enright would struggle to fit in our midfield to be honest

bruce,green,mclean,mcdonald,jonhstone imo are all better than enright...im sorry cats fans but enright is seriously OVERATED! just lyk many of the players in ur team...shame on the cats fan who said our midfield was crap, shame shame it is actually one of the best in the comp

You seriously have no idea...some of your views on AFL football are questionable to say the least.

 

[goDees22]

You seriously have no idea...some of your views on AFL football are questionable to say the least.

agreed, although this poll is also pretty dumb, Enright is in a slump atm, and over the course of their careers has been better, but he is older, and in time i reckon Moloney will overtake him. I hope.

 

[davey_magik]

Been ravaged by injuries...

Instead of making an ill-informed judgement, please watch him play.

I have. And he's been crap this year excluding perhaps the first two weeks, but the whole Geelong side was playing well then.

 

[chapmanmagic35]

I have. And he's been crap this year excluding perhaps the first two weeks, but the whole Geelong side was playing well then.

You obviously haven't...

 

[cats2rise]

I have. And he's been crap this year excluding perhaps the first two weeks, but the whole Geelong side was playing well then.

And Moloney sure has been setting the world on fire.....
Moloney is probably having the better year, but only just. But he isnt a better player. Yet.

 

[cats2rise]

i think enright would struggle to fit in our midfield to be honest

bruce,green,mclean,mcdonald,jonhstone imo are all better than enright...im sorry cats fans but enright is seriously OVERATED! just lyk many of the players in ur team...shame on the cats fan who said our midfield was crap, shame shame it is actually one of the best in the comp

Moloney would be having more trouble trying to fit into Geelong. WEll not at the moment as we are a rabble, but with a semi good geelong team, i think he would have been pushed to the way side. He would be getting games, but in no way would be a regular IMO.

 

[Jarka]

Moloney would be having more trouble trying to fit into Geelong. WEll not at the moment as we are a rabble, but with a semi good geelong team, i think he would have been pushed to the way side. He would be getting games, but in no way would be a regular IMO.

That's pretty funny actually, considering Moloney's current form and that of Geelong's, he'd easily be top ten in your B&F so far this season if he still played for Geelong.

In reality Enright is a better player than Moloney (although this season Moloney has been better due to injury to Enright) but the suggestion that Moloney wouldn't make Geelong's team is laughable.