Bret Thornton vs Scott Thornton

[chickens_law]

Who is better?

Bret, Carlton
108 games, 1 goal
avg: 11.8 poss/match
3.8 marks/match

Scott, Freo
52 games, 5 goals
avg: 12.04 poss./match
4.2 marks/match

 

[Wizard]

Scotty would be if he could get his health right and bulk up a bit. Very similar players as defenders that clean up. Bret better in the contested situation. Scott cleaner skills and quicker.
Very even, if Scott cant put a season together finally i would probably rank him higher.

 

[walkers a legend]

Thornton has had a very solid two weeks playing on people that don't completely outsize him

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Brett has the ability to play on both small and tall forwards. Usually has clean disposal.