whatboutbob
Serial Avatar Troll
- Joined
- Mar 10, 2007
- Posts
- 12,663
- Reaction score
- 9,093
- Location
- Under a bridge
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions

Saints had pick 18 and 19, yet for former pick 8, Longer, refused to hand over anything better than 25. Longer had nominated them so the implied PSD threat was there.Don't know if points 2 and 3 would do much. Luke Ball had to happen because the Saints were unreasonable IMO. And looking at what other clubs gave up for Brisbane's players who left last year the offers seemed reasonable. No club really stood over Brisbane with the threat of the players leaving. Adelaide's lack of first round draft pick made life hard for the Polec trade, if they had one then there could've been more anger about Polec choosing a club. I think the reality was though that the trades were reasonable given the players were largely unproven. Where it's unfair isn't the trades but just the reality that there's nothing given in return for the development Brisbane has put in or for the big factor which was that they were all leaving at once.
More flexible rules with the ability to trade future picks could help in that situation. Firstly it would've allowed Brisbane to at least drag their haul of second round picks over a few years to spread out the picks and in turn make them more valuable at least in theory. Or to trade a couple of second rounders for a future first etc. Plus the SA and WA teams would've had more to offer so at least Brisbane could've had a fairer shot of driving up the price of Yeo or Polec.
Carlton wouldn't even give up pick 32 instead of pick 33 for former pick 12 Docherty. Again, he'd nominated Carlton so the implied PSD threat was there.
Off the top of my head West Coast were also prepared to take Yeo in the PSD if the Lions didn't accept their third round pick, before the Lions got Freo to help them out. Even then they got pathetic compensation for a young, regular first-22 player.
Rob Kerr's also on record saying that Polec nominating the club made it harder for the Lions to get fair compensation. He griped about the trade period going too long, thus making Polec's agent chicken out and nominate Port.
If you don't think the Lions weren't bent over, you weren't paying close attention.





Seriously though, draft Lachie Weller you muppets. Get some Queensland blood in there and give the locals something to get excited about. Scour the league for all the Queenslanders you can find to curb the go home factor and fire up the locals.
