- Dec 18, 2005
- 17,223
- 23,281
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- GAVROI MOUNIA... GAMW TON PIRAEA
Here we go ...
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
??Here we go ...
Port have a great hand this year , What did they give up ?Pick swap done b/w Brisbane and Port.
Port now have #12, #16, #18
Port have a great hand this year , What did they give up ?
Thinking 2020 1st +
Smart move by Port imo , They are going all in this year combined with the 3 talented lads from last year they are fast tracking their development and talent+ 29 for #16 and change.
Port have a great hand this year , What did they give up ?
Thinking 2020 1st +
My take is that Port are bold when it comes to making moves to get the player(s) it wants. Worry about next year then but if they get the guy they want this year then that is what they do. People thought they gave up a lot to get pick 5 last year..but now they have Rozee who could easily end up being the most talented kid from that draft they way he is goingPort Adelaide gain - Pick 16, 52, 55 & 72
Brisbane gain- Port Adelaide 2020 First Round, Pick 29 & Pick 71.
Based off point value it values Port Adelaide's 2020 Pick as equivalent to Pick 21.
It could be a good deal if Port see themselves as finishing Top 4-6 next year; but a horrible trade by Port Adelaide if they finish outside the 8 IMO.
Personally i see it this wayPort Adelaide gain - Pick 16, 52, 55 & 72
Brisbane gain- Port Adelaide 2020 First Round, Pick 29 & Pick 71.
Based off point value it values Port Adelaide's 2020 Pick as equivalent to Pick 21.
It could be a good deal if Port see themselves as finishing Top 4-6 next year; but a horrible trade by Port Adelaide if they finish outside the 8 IMO.
Smart move by Port imo , They are going all in this year combined with the 3 talented lads from last year they are fast tracking their development and talent
Port Adelaide gain - Pick 16, 52, 55 & 72
Brisbane gain- Port Adelaide 2020 First Round, Pick 29 & Pick 71.
Based off point value it values Port Adelaide's 2020 Pick as equivalent to Pick 21.
It could be a good deal if Port see themselves as finishing Top 4-6 next year; but a horrible trade by Port Adelaide if they finish outside the 8 IMO.
Next Minute ............................... Geelong bid pick #15 for MeadDoesn’t take into account we would’ve had to use 29 on Mead so now get 16 and Mead along with next year’s draft being super compromised of a tonne of father sons and NGA picks, especially early on.
Shouldn't this trade have been prevented as being against the rules? Port have traded in more point bearing picks than they have list spots?
I like it but why would brisbane do this ?
Not necessarily, and I doubt either of those clubs will want to move back that far even if there is a bid.They are either dangling for GWS #6 or freo's #10
I think that it’s more that we can’t use those picks, we can trade as many in as we want. We either now lose our last 3 picks in the draft for nothing due to list spots, or try and package them up for something else like moving higher up the draft or future picks.
So I guess port have to be making more trades prior to the draft.
As far as Port are concerned this is effectively a straight swap of their 2020 first round pick for pick 16, given they'll use 52, 55, 66, 67, 68 and 72 to match for Mead.
Brisbane have done extremely well regardless of where Port finish. Win-win.
Port Adelaide gain - Pick 16, 52, 55 & 72
Brisbane gain- Port Adelaide 2020 First Round, Pick 29 & Pick 71.
Based off point value it values Port Adelaide's 2020 Pick as equivalent to Pick 21.
It could be a good deal if Port see themselves as finishing Top 4-6 next year; but a horrible trade by Port Adelaide if they finish outside the 8 IMO.
Not really, reported they can draft minimum 4 senior list spot. What about maximum?Shouldn't this trade have been prevented as being against the rules? Port have traded in more point bearing picks than they have list spots?
why not? - Rozee Butters and Duursma have now had a year at AFL level, they may have a low injury list and they should have a reasonable draw. They also have a number of other younger players where improvement can come from. I HOPE they don't from a crows perspective but it would not be the biggest shock to see them move into the top 8 and maybe do okThere is no way Port are top 6 next season.