curiosity got to me so i worked it out, and here it is
BROWNLOW AND PREMIERSHIP
-1926 I.Warne-Smith (Melbourne) - defeated Collingwood by 57pts
-1927 Syd Coventry (Collingwood) - defeated Richmond by by 12pts
-1929 Albert Collier (Collindwood) - defeated Richmond by 29pts
-1930 Harry Collier {tied} (Collingwood) - defeated Geelong by 30pts
-1947 B.Deacon (Carlton) - defeated Essendon by 1pt
-1951 B Smith (Geelong) - defeated Essendon by 11pts
-1966 Ian Stewart (St.Kilda) - defeated Collingwood by 1pt
-1986 R.DiPierdomenico (Hawthorn) - defeated Carlton by 42pts
-1993 Gavin Wanganeen (Essendon) - defeated Carlton by 44pts
BROWNLOW AND LOSING GRAND FINAL
-1939 Marcus Whelan (Collingwood) - lost to Melbourne by 53 points
-1946 Don Cordner (Melbourne) - lost to Essendon by 63 points
-1965 Ian Stewart (St.Kilda) - lost to Essendon by 35pts
-1974 Keith Greig (Nth Melb) - lost to Richmond by 41pts
-1978 Malcolm Blight (Nth Melb) - lost to Hawthorn by 18pts
-1979 Peter Moore (Collingwood) - lost to Carlton by 5pts
-1987 John Platten {tied} (Hawthorn) - lost to Carlton by 33pts
-1989 Paul Couch (Geelong) - lost to Hawthorn by 6 points
-1997 Robert Harvey (St.Kilda) - lost to Adelaide by 31pts
-2000 SHANE WOEWODIN (MELBOURNE) - ????????????????
So the records say its nine each way, but recent history from the 70's onwards when the pressure of winning a brownlow and its public expectations have shown its a great deal harder to win both.
After the seventies its 2 to win both and 6 the other way.
I personally dont reckon it will make a difference on the team, maybe only Shane himself, but well done to him, we'll see what happens.
worthy winner, am im glad kouta or buckley didnt win
BROWNLOW AND PREMIERSHIP
-1926 I.Warne-Smith (Melbourne) - defeated Collingwood by 57pts
-1927 Syd Coventry (Collingwood) - defeated Richmond by by 12pts
-1929 Albert Collier (Collindwood) - defeated Richmond by 29pts
-1930 Harry Collier {tied} (Collingwood) - defeated Geelong by 30pts
-1947 B.Deacon (Carlton) - defeated Essendon by 1pt
-1951 B Smith (Geelong) - defeated Essendon by 11pts
-1966 Ian Stewart (St.Kilda) - defeated Collingwood by 1pt
-1986 R.DiPierdomenico (Hawthorn) - defeated Carlton by 42pts
-1993 Gavin Wanganeen (Essendon) - defeated Carlton by 44pts
BROWNLOW AND LOSING GRAND FINAL
-1939 Marcus Whelan (Collingwood) - lost to Melbourne by 53 points
-1946 Don Cordner (Melbourne) - lost to Essendon by 63 points
-1965 Ian Stewart (St.Kilda) - lost to Essendon by 35pts
-1974 Keith Greig (Nth Melb) - lost to Richmond by 41pts
-1978 Malcolm Blight (Nth Melb) - lost to Hawthorn by 18pts
-1979 Peter Moore (Collingwood) - lost to Carlton by 5pts
-1987 John Platten {tied} (Hawthorn) - lost to Carlton by 33pts
-1989 Paul Couch (Geelong) - lost to Hawthorn by 6 points
-1997 Robert Harvey (St.Kilda) - lost to Adelaide by 31pts
-2000 SHANE WOEWODIN (MELBOURNE) - ????????????????
So the records say its nine each way, but recent history from the 70's onwards when the pressure of winning a brownlow and its public expectations have shown its a great deal harder to win both.
After the seventies its 2 to win both and 6 the other way.
I personally dont reckon it will make a difference on the team, maybe only Shane himself, but well done to him, we'll see what happens.
worthy winner, am im glad kouta or buckley didnt win
