Brownlow Medal

[LukeHodge15]

who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

reckon goody had a stellar year this year. but is he a recognised vote getter like roo?

if u had to name ur top 3 brownlow medal fancies from the crows , who would they be ?

cheers

 

[Stiffy_18]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Goody has had a super year but he traditionally is not a vote getter.

I still think Roo will poll most votes even though he is ineligable. I reckon McLeod could poll well. He had that purple patch in the middle of the year.

 

[Bockchoy67]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Good topic.

Irrespective of Roo being suspended, I believe he has very little chance of getting in the Top 3-5. His form this season was up and down (though gladly we're getting a lot of up ATM) with both brilliance and quiet games. Much like our friend Scott Thompson.

IMO Goody should finish VERY high. His form has been extremely consistent. But you do make a good point in saying that he isn't as widely recognised by the umps as our captain.

IMO:
1. Goodwin - 18-22 votes
2. Riccuito - 15-20 votes
3. Tough one. Both Thommo and Edwards should get a few here.

BTW Don't be suprised to see Mattner and Skippy racking up some votes early on.

 

[Bockchoy67]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Goody has had a super year but he traditionally is not a vote getter.

I still think Roo will poll most votes even though he is ineligable. I reckon McLeod could poll well. He had that purple patch in the middle of the year.

IMO this has been Goody's best season to date.

I'd be suprised if he doesn't finish high despite his traditional shortfall after the red carpet.

 

[jc67]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

I think that quite a few AFC players will poll, but like our season they will spread it pretty evenly.
Goody
Hudson
Roo
Mattner
Edwards
For my top 5 vote getters (not the best 5 IMHO but vote winners)

 

[LukeHodge15]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

cheers 4 ur help guys.

had goody in my dream team from day 1. so kept a really close eye on him all year. would have 2 go close 2 taking it out, just a worry that he doesnt poll all that well.

running a brownlow medal competition at work where we name 3 players from each team. the top player u name get his votes multiplied by 3, the 2nd place guy u nominate get multiplied by 2 and the third gets single votes.

 

[adelaide_girl]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

reckon goody had a stellar year this year. but is he a recognised vote getter like roo?

if u had to name ur top 3 brownlow medal fancies from the crows , who would they be ?

cheers

Hi there Lukey

ROOO would still lead our vote getters i think, Goodwin would have to poll well, and for third either Mcleod, Thompson or Edwards.

 

[Crowz Gal]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

What about our AA FB??????

 

[Glenno23]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Backline players rarely get votes.......

can anyone remember the last player who played a whole season in the backline and won the Brownlow?

i read in the west australian that someone put $100 on Truck to win the brownlow at the odds of 1000-1!!!! thats a $100,000 pay out if he wins!

 

[dogs105]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Backline players rarely get votes.......

can anyone remember the last player who played a whole season in the backline and won the Brownlow?

i read in the west australian that someone put $100 on Truck to win the brownlow at the odds of 1000-1!!!! thats a $100,000 pay out if he wins!

Wanganeen?

 

[noddy]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Though Goody has had a slightly better year than his captain i think Roo will go close to winning the medal.

That is if he could win it but as we all know he can't so he'll have to make do with the MVP award.

Macca will poll well & like Bockchoy67 has already stated so will Skippy.

 

[LukeHodge15]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Hi there Lukey

ROOO would still lead our vote getters i think, Goodwin would have to poll well, and for third either Mcleod, Thompson or Edwards.

hi adelgirl......or maybe perthgirl

settling on

roo
goody
macca

unlucky

thomo because i reck he will get at least 10 votes

 

[Crowked]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

I dont think he was our best player for the season but going on other years, Macca will attract votes for just pretty good games. Dont be suprised if he polls the most for us. I cant see any Crow being at the top end of the vote tally though.

Personally I think Goody has been easily our best this season and will win the club B&F.

 

[LukeHodge15]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

I dont think he was our best player for the season but going on other years, Macca will attract votes for just pretty good games. Dont be suprised if he polls the most for us. I cant see any Crow being at the top end of the vote tally though.

Personally I think Goody has been easily our best this season and will win the club B&F.

couldnt agree more ,......goody been exceptional (just goes 2 show how important he is 2 u, bad injurys last couple of years).... but im wondering how those little white maggots see it.

i would have it

goody
roo
thomo

if i was picking

but seeing as though im picking brownlow votes.

ill go

roo
goody
macca

brownlow votes arent as way out as they used to be. the umpires have the stats at the end of the game to look over.

 

[mymansyd]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Roo, Goody and Tyson Edwards should all reach double figures.

Thompson, Macca and Mattner (especially early on) should also poll well.

My top 10 prediction-

Cousins, Hayes, West, Pavlich, Ricciuto, B.Harvey, Tredrea, Hall, Judd, Hodge.

 

[Glenno23]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Wanganeen?

i thought Wanganeen played in the midfield that year?

 

[jc67]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

bump

 

[Adam BK]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Has Mattner got 6 votes allready?

 

[NewCrowsFan]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Has Mattner got 6 votes allready?

Yes, as at the end of Round 4, he was on 6 votes.

 

[Stiffy_18]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Marty is actually polling well.

Had he not dropped off after a good start he would have been some sort of silly chance to finish near the top.

 

[Adam BK]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Make that 7 now...no sign of goodwin

 

[Stiffy_18]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Make that 7 now...no sign of goodwin

Goodwin never was a good vote getter. IMHO, he won't even come close to top 5.

 

[Adam BK]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

At the moment I am very suprised by the leaders.

 

[Adam BK]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Finally Goodwin gets 3 votes for the Essendon match.

 

[Adam BK]

Re: who will poll the most votes 4 the crows

Adelaide Crows Leader Board after 12 rounds


Martin Mattner
7

Tyson Edwards
7


Mark Ricciuto *
6

Andrew McLeod
5


Scott Thompson
4


Nathan Bassett
3


Hayden Skipworth
3


Simon Goodwin
3


Ken McGregor
1


Brent Reilly
1


Graham Johncock
1


Ben Hart
1

-----
Here comes 10 wins in a row so should see more votes.