What lack of knowledge in regard to a Carlton poster calling people sooks because they dare question Carlton superiorority. Carton are no good,there is plenty of evidence,even a heavily suspended Essendon defeated the Blues and still you all think your on the right track just because of Silvini.
If Gibbs was perfectly fine staying at Carlton he wouldn't have asked to leave. I'd take the fact he asked to leave when he had the chance as better evidence than a post event interview. What else was he going to say at this point.
It's the Blues supporters with no idea about their list. First you all think Murphy and Gibbs are still going to be around when your finally competitive enough to push for a flag,like it's just around the corner and you all keep constantly mentioning ten game players and in many cases zero game players as ready made stars who will make it 100%. No wait and see,no patience just its definite and if you have an opposing view your a hater or a sook. Unbelievable,and the typical Carlton arrogance that has led the club up this path and why it has struggled to get back.
1. A round 23 defeat in a dead rubber doesn't sum up our season and our progress during the year.
2. Gibbs never had a problem with anybody at Carlton. His and his partner's families live in Adelaide and they have a little one. You don't actually have to have a problem with your club to want to be closer to family. Your logic is flawed.
3. I don't think Murphy and Gibbs are going to be there for our next successes, or at least I don't include them in my analysis. Our next wave starts at Docherty and down in terms of age.
4. We also don't assume they are all going to make it but we are happy that we have got in players rated as juniors in a variety of positions. Us liking what we saw from Curnow or Silvagni and identifying early talent does not equate to impatience or arrogance.
And yes, you lack knowledge and the ability to understand how we are going about building the list. Your constant reference to Silvagni's arrogance for recruiting GWS 'rejects' shows zero understanding of why we did it, what we hope to gain out of it and what the alternatives were.
Any time you want to engage in a real debate about our list management instead of your fly by stock standard responses, I will be happy to accommodate you.