Only one GWS player we targeted has been delisted and that was pre-rebuild with a different list manager.
We have 6 with Palmer likely to depart to make it 5. Kennedy and Smith will then make it 7. 5 or 6 will be regular best 22.
Again selective posting about GWS players only
How many of your players are recycled player on your list ?
Again you are presuming that 6 will be regulars there are no guarantee's they will be regular players in a "top" Team
You can have them be regular players if you dont have quality to replace them with if they are not upto the level required to make you a top 4 team then its useless.
Might be an idea to have a look through the lists of teams that have won the last 2 flags and see how its come about rather than automatically presume that every player Carlton take from GWS are going to be great players.
When Gws entered the comp and sos was given unlimited picks for the next few years and all the players he could take from other clubs and they started their build of this super club the bulldogs and Tigers were on their knee's but have both won flags whilst the list that SOS built is struggling to get there and turfing players that SOS recruited.
These players are not bad but carlton need to look at other avenue's apart from just players that the 3rd or 4th placed team are happy to let go and get draft picks for them to continue the churn.
None of the players that have been let go to Carlton are players that GWS were desperate to keep, Sure some perhaps they may have liked to keep but were not desperate like they way they were with Kelly,Treloar,Patton,Cameron,Shiel etc
What i mean by getting their off cuts is not to mean they are rubbish but will just be average to good but hardly enough to win a flag as these players will be the ones that GWS wont let go.
If you cant see an issue with being too gws focused then with recruiting then that in itself is an issue , Best you will be is competitive but not successful in getting to the top