Buckley v Riccuito

[fryingpan]

Bigfooty are full of idiots like you. Amen.

Amen? You stupid filthy Magpie Fan.

 

[Coin_Toss]

How can you even compare Riccuito with Buckley?

Bucks has won every individual AFL award, except for winning a Premiership medallion up to date. Also, Bucks has been a real champion for Collingwood through the good and the bad times.

It is really laughable how only Adelaide Supporters (Riccuito plays for the club) and Carlton Supporters (They never give respect for our players anyway) have voted for Riccuito, while most supporters from other clubs have voted for Buckley.

Buckley > Riccuito. The real truth does hurt Adelaide supporters.

 

[Gets!]

how can u tell which clubs supporters have voted for which player?

Just because they didnt post in here doesnt mean they voted for one or the other dumbass.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Buckley has been much better over their career.

Agree.... Bucks for me aswell.

 

[lachystar]

When I posted this originally, I thought it would be academic that Bucks would be a mile in front. We are talking about a bloke who has been tagged more heavily then any other player over the last 12 years. When comparing stats, Bucks is a mile ahead and has played 30 less games. His skill level is also much better then the Roo. I think if Bucks had Macleod, Edwards, Goodwin and Johnson playing with him he would have been even better. I can only put this down to an anti Collingwood sentiment or lack of care factor from non Pie/Crow supporters. In all reality, Bucks is a whole echelon above the Roo.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

When I posted this originally, I thought it would be academic that Bucks would be a mile in front. We are talking about a bloke who has been tagged more heavily then any other player over the last 12 years. When comparing stats, Bucks is a mile ahead and has played 30 less games. His skill level is also much better then the Roo. I think if Bucks had Macleod, Edwards, Goodwin and Johnson playing with him he would have been even better. I can only put this down to an anti Collingwood sentiment or lack of care factor from non Pie/Crow supporters. In all reality, Bucks is a whole echelon above the Roo.

Correct but there are some people who just cant bring themselves to vote Buckley. Sad really.

 

[tribey]

Mark Ricciuto

281 Games
228 Goals
Career average of 21.73 disposals per game
7 times All-Australian (captain 2004)
3 times AFC Club Champion
Brownlow Medallist 2003
AFL Premiership Player 1998

Nathan Buckley

251 Games
249 Goals
Career average of 24.96 disposals per game
7 times All-Australian (vice-captain 1999, 2000, 2003)
6 times Collingwood Club Champion
Brownlow Medallist 2003
Norm Smith Medallist 2002
Alex Jesaulenko Medallist 1997 (best afield for the Allies in SOO)
AFL Rising Star 1993
Magarey Medallist 1992
Jack Oatey Medallist 1992 (best afield in an SANFL Grand Final)
_______________

On weight of honours and the limited statistical evidence I've provided Buckley shades Ricciuto all up.

But both are all-time greats, no question.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

On weight of honours and the limited statistical evidence I've provided Buckley shades Ricciuto all up.

But both are all-time greats, no question.

Well done. I bet your fellow adelaide supporters wont be happy

 

[Jars458]

Well done. I bet your fellow adelaide supporters wont be happy

pfft

Both champions. Both icons of their Clubs.

Why bother comparing the incomparable.

This my ******** is bigger than yours stuff is so boring.

 

[Malibu#27]

Both great players ... but different styled players.


For mine though I wouldnt have hesitated to take Buckley in his prime. I just think he had that little more polish (ie kicking skills - Buckley drills them and is precise, Roo always seemed a bit up and under).... and the fact that statistically he would slightly surpass Roo.

 

[fryingpan]

How can you even compare Riccuito with Buckley?

Bucks has won every individual AFL award, except for winning a Premiership medallion up to date. Also, Bucks has been a real champion for Collingwood through the good and the bad times.

It is really laughable how only Adelaide Supporters (Riccuito plays for the club) and Carlton Supporters (They never give respect for our players anyway) have voted for Riccuito, while most supporters from other clubs have voted for Buckley.

Buckley > Riccuito. The real truth does hurt Adelaide supporters.

If you think Adelaide Fans and Carlton Fans are the only two clubs that have voted for Riccuito, then you are living a world of fantasy. NEWSFLASH! Collingwood are the most feral and hated team in the AFL.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Collingwood are the most feral and hated team in the AFL.

So your admitting that this poll is a farce because people vote on players they like. Thanks fryingpan

 

[MickZu]

Not even close, Riccuito easily!!

 

[fryingpan]

So your admitting that this poll is a farce because people vote on players they like. Thanks fryingpan

So your admitting that your team is the most hated team in the AFL and the most feral? Thanks brilliant pies

 

[rayven]

Mark Ricciuto

281 Games
228 Goals
Career average of 21.73 disposals per game
7 times All-Australian (captain 2004)
3 times AFC Club Champion
Brownlow Medallist 2003
AFL Premiership Player 1998

Nathan Buckley

251 Games
249 Goals
Career average of 24.96 disposals per game
7 times All-Australian (vice-captain 1999, 2000, 2003)
6 times Collingwood Club Champion
Brownlow Medallist 2003
Norm Smith Medallist 2002
Alex Jesaulenko Medallist 1997 (best afield for the Allies in SOO)
AFL Rising Star 1993
Magarey Medallist 1992
Jack Oatey Medallist 1992 (best afield in an SANFL Grand Final)
_______________

On weight of honours and the limited statistical evidence I've provided Buckley shades Ricciuto all up.

But both are all-time greats, no question.

Could someone find the statistics for when both have played midfeld because Buckley started his career on a wing and Ricciuto started in the back pockett
Under robert Shaw Ricciuto's role was as a enforcer not a ball winner so that would effect the stats too, it wasnt until Blight came along that Ricciuto was unleashed as a ball winner.

 

[Paddywhackers]

Look at the Poll.

While you're at it, look at the ladder.

Oh and the premiership trophies you have won over the last 10 years.

Show some respect, we are the Collingwood football club and have been around a lot longer than you. As an Adelaide supporter, you should be full of admiration respect for our great club and one of our greatest players. Don't let me see this rubbish writtten by you again.

 

[Paddywhackers]

Could someone find the statistics for when both have played midfeld because Buckley started his career on a wing and Ricciuto started in the back pockett
Under robert Shaw Ricciuto's role was as a enforcer not a ball winner so that would effect the stats too, it wasnt until Blight came along that Ricciuto was unleashed as a ball winner.

Moron, Buckley played half his career on the half back flank, under Tony Shaw whats your point? This is rediculous, I can't believe even the most biased of the feral Adelaide supporters could possibly believe that Riccuito has been the better player than Buckley over their careers. You all must be living in fairyland.

 

[fryingpan]

Moron, Buckley played half his career on the half back flank, under Tony Shaw whats your point? This is rediculous, I can't believe even the most biased of the feral Adelaide supporters could possibly believe that Riccuito has been the better player than Buckley over their careers. You all must be living in fairyland.

Now come on. You know it has been proven over the years that Collingwood is and always will be the biggest ferals in the competition.

 

[fryingpan]

Show some respect, we are the Collingwood football club and have been around a lot longer than you. As an Adelaide supporter, you should be full of admiration respect for our great club and one of our greatest players. Don't let me see this rubbish writtten by you again.

Why the ******** should we be full of admiration for your filthy club? What do you base this comment on you idiot.

 

[Paddywhackers]

Why the ******** should we be full of admiration for your filthy club? What do you base this comment on you idiot.

We have a rich history, you don't.

 

[Paddywhackers]

Now come on. You know it has been proven over the years that Collingwood is and always will be the biggest ferals in the competition.

... Excluding all the inbreds from Adelaide

 

[fryingpan]

We have a rich history, you don't.

And because of that we must be full of admiration for Collingwood? Haha. Good luck with that one. Hahahaha.

 

[Paddywhackers]

And because of that we must be full of admiration for Collingwood? Haha. Good luck with that one. Hahahaha.

Absolutely, your last post was childish and immature, much like your football club.

 

[fryingpan]

... Excluding all the inbreds from Adelaide

Collingwood = Ferals. Thought you would have been used to it by now? Nothing you can say or do will ever change Collingwood's status.

 

[fryingpan]

Absolutely, your last post was childish and immature, much like your football club.

Hahaha. Yes the Adelaide Football Club is very childish and immature Make you feel better?? Nice to see you have some kind of useful information to back that disgraceful comment up.