BUST A CAP - EAST v WEST - HIP HOP WEREWOLF

(Log in to remove this ad.)

BRAB

Just Hip my Wood
Joined
Oct 20, 2014
Posts
25,398
Likes
38,461
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
I think there’s two possible reasons for not targetting BJD.

1. He’s not the good sort of wheat dealer, he plays for the Big Boys (Evil)

2. He’s actually off in this game (I hate to say it, from what I have seen, it’s off this time around) and why would evil want to kill someone that’s off? One of the groups had a legit excuse to go after someone else (so they knew
I'm very impressed by you. Glad we signed ya.
 
Joined
Jul 26, 2007
Posts
60,186
Likes
70,209
Location
The Throne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Arsenal, Gold City Royals
Moderator #1,955
Filthy producing 3 run on posts, playing the victim and shifting the blame.

Bloodhound is excited.
If I'd multi-quoted some arsebrain would accuse me of walls of text.

If you're basing your accusations off me berating Joe for him having a terrible game then guess what, he has had a terrible game. I was just trying to spare him further embarrassment.

Do you really think in this bumper game that the big 3 all got roles? What are the odds there?
 

Brown Bottle

Seasoned Campaigner
Joined
Jul 26, 2006
Posts
12,372
Likes
8,069
Location
Browntown
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
East Side Hawks
I think there’s two possible reasons for not targetting BJD.

1. He’s not the good sort of wheat dealer, he plays for the Big Boys (Evil)

2. He’s actually off in this game (I hate to say it, from what I have seen, it’s off this time around) and why would evil want to kill someone that’s off? One of the groups had a legit excuse to go after someone else (so they knew full well what they were doing yesterday.) But when that failed, they decided to just get it done before any more words were spoken.

That’s why I’m highly suspicious of Brown Bottle. His faction learnt this identity the night before, and tried to ‘play it natural’ for the attempted lynch, they had a legit reason too (RM backed DC, confirmed evil). Three situations:

1. If the lynch was successful, job done. Those that pushed him can legitimately claim they were mistaken because of that suss behaviour.

2. If they tried to get it running, but to no avil, then they’ll get it done in the night anyway.

3. If it looked bad for RM, he was going to out himself. If Blacky came out and revealed himself as the fake, it would seem like the Doctor could protect them… but what about alternate nights? No amulet? Free kill!

It feels like it favoured evil to casually make the play since well, the material is there, and just see how things go. Even in failure, the pieces would fall, but that had a low chance of happening. What happened right now was pretty much as planned for them.

That’s my theory on the matter, it was a well-planned high percentage ploy to rid of the seer (not even the Seer saw it coming).

I'd look at the guys that recommended RM for lynching.
Cool story bro. I note how all my teammates jumped on the Red Mist bandwagon. Not!

Did I actually vote for him? I really don't recall. Just knew I had a meaningless vote in play and no reason to switch to the bandwagon for EJW who seemed as lost as me.

P.s. I did exactly the same thing with Frankie a day prior. Had no reason to change my vote so stuck with him
 

BRAB

Just Hip my Wood
Joined
Oct 20, 2014
Posts
25,398
Likes
38,461
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
If I'd multi-quoted some arsebrain would accuse me of walls of text.

If you're basing your accusations off me berating Joe for him having a terrible game then guess what, he has had a terrible game. I was just trying to spare him further embarrassment.

Do you really think in this bumper game that the big 3 all got roles? What are the odds there?
Yeah I'll cop the multi-quote thing. That's fair enough.

You went too hard at Joe if you're a villager. If he's having a bad game he doesn't pose as much a threat as he does. I'm fairly sure you're evil and your mistake was being over zealous in your defence if that's the case. Your response to Joe was disproportionate.

Your last comment is interesting to me. Appealing to the odds like that is weird. It's just as possible for any 3 people to have a role as it is for the Big 3. (Frankly should be big 4, SM up there now)

You also seem to place a lot of faith in odds. Tell me the odds of someone as good as Joe being wrong about every accusation he's made in the game. Not likely.

They're all fairly flimsy defences, especially for you.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

BigJoeD_

Moderator
Joined
Sep 21, 2013
Posts
19,075
Likes
39,779
Location
The G-Funk Era
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Coney Island - The Benchmark™
Moderator #1,962
If I'd multi-quoted some arsebrain would accuse me of walls of text.

If you're basing your accusations off me berating Joe for him having a terrible game then guess what, he has had a terrible game. I was just trying to spare him further embarrassment.

Do you really think in this bumper game that the big 3 all got roles? What are the odds there?
Embarrassed? Me?

Hardly.

Besides, I'm bouncing back today with my vote for you
 
Joined
Jul 26, 2007
Posts
60,186
Likes
70,209
Location
The Throne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Arsenal, Gold City Royals
Moderator #1,964
Yeah I'll cop the multi-quote thing. That's fair enough.

You went too hard at Joe if you're a villager. If he's having a bad game he doesn't pose as much a threat as he does. I'm fairly sure you're evil and your mistake was being over zealous in your defence if that's the case. Your response to Joe was disproportionate.

Your last comment is interesting to me. Appealing to the odds like that is weird. It's just as possible for any 3 people to have a role as it is for the Big 3. (Frankly should be big 4, SM up there now)

You also seem to place a lot of faith in odds. Tell me the odds of someone as good as Joe being wrong about every accusation he's made in the game. Not likely.

They're all fairly flimsy defences, especially for you.
No, I went hard at him because we have been warring since you were just a glint in RU_s eye. A lot of things existed before you did. If he's smart he will understand I've never spoken to him that way and that if he wants to help the village he will be looking elsewhere.
 

BRAB

Just Hip my Wood
Joined
Oct 20, 2014
Posts
25,398
Likes
38,461
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
No, I went hard at him because we have been warring since you were just a glint in RU_s eye. A lot of things existed before you did. If he's smart he will understand I've never spoken to him that way and that if he wants to help the village he will be looking elsewhere.
Firstly are you saying RU_ is my father as I am not comfortable with that.

Secondly, still don't buy it.

Maybe I'm an idiot though. Can someone else read this situation for me please.
 
Joined
Jul 26, 2007
Posts
60,186
Likes
70,209
Location
The Throne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Arsenal, Gold City Royals
Moderator #1,973
Firstly are you saying RU_ is my father as I am not comfortable with that.

Secondly, still don't buy it.

Maybe I'm an idiot though. Can someone else read this situation for me please.
I'm simply saying that some people are bringing previous agendas into this game to the detriment of the village and those people know I don't generally post that way.

I voted Red mist yesterday, yes. I said at the time I wasn't sure but I tried to find patterns with Frankston Rover and dennis crumpet and that's what I came up with. A lot of you all voted for BigJoeD_. Some voted for Hatchy. Some voted for burningdwarf and Blacky. I briefly voted for the latter. There is a common denominator there no? So when I'm the one that found the logic to hang dennis and get FR shot it's a little unfair to target me because I got one wrong, no? That me and Joe have battled a thousand times and that dogs and I have been pretty hard at each other last two games doesn't come into it? That is merely what I am responding to.
 

JackNah_8

Hall of Famer
Joined
Jan 15, 2012
Posts
35,109
Likes
30,966
AFL Club
Richmond
so still no clear leads.

my votes are leaning towards Joe and Human Meatball. Hm's voting is odd, and he was targeting EJW from day 1 but we rarely hear from him.

If blacky is telling the truth and is killed and shows as seer it can only help the village really. Real seer would know where they stand.
atm i cant go through the old posts using my mobile and i can't remember what blacky said
 
Top Bottom