I think the supporters (and I accept there is plenty of reasons to be in favour of him) of Scott are missing the reason why the rest of us are not a fan.
It's not that we aren't playing 4 quarters v shit sides.
It's that we've had this problem for a long time, this poor concentration, inability to be switched on when needed etc. And it has cost us time and time again. It cost us from playing finals in 2013. It meant we were no hope of winning the prelim final in 2014. It could well be the difference in finishing top 4 this year depending on how we end the year (if we had managed to show more discipline and resolve v Collingwood we would be 4th right now)...
These same problems, rearing their ugly heads over and over again. And all I hear is "well it's not bad because we won 6 games in a row" (will we meet any of these teams in the big finals? no) and "well we beat Essendon in the elimination final despite only playing a half" (yeah, was great at the time).