Opinion Calls you made that you got wrong

[Cleric]

I said Rory Atkins

32

Rory Atkins

Age

31

Ht

185cm

Wt

82kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

19.9

5star

K

12.1

4star

HB

7.9

5star

M

4.6

4star

T

1.9

4star

MG

367.4

5star

D

9.0

2star

K

5.0

2star

HB

4.0

3star

M

0.3

1star

T

2.7

4star

MG

147.7

3star

D

14.2

4star

K

8.8

4star

HB

5.4

4star

M

4.0

4star

T

1.2

3star

MG

217.8

4star

was a dud and wouldn't make it at AFL level. He then became a decent player in the Crows team. I then said I was wrong and he was a good player, then he went to Gold Coast and went back to being a dud. He got me twice.

 

[TheFourPillars]

Around 30 years ago (hopefully i have wised up by now) i made the call watching a young gangly looking Chris Langford line up on the wing and get flogged. He was never making it as a footballer as far as i was concerned. Then after playing him in the ruck they stuck him at full back and the rest is history.

 

[NetworkNerd]

Around 30 years ago (hopefully i have wised up by now) i made the call watching a young gangly looking Chris Langford line up on the wing and get flogged. He was never making it as a footballer as far as i was concerned. Then after playing him in the ruck they stuck him at full back and the rest is history.

Time flies... Langford retired 28 years ago

 

[TheFourPillars]

Time flies... Langford retired 28 years ago

hahaha yeah make that nearly 40 years ago then lol

 

[Mop]

I thought John Butcher

John Butcher

Age

34

Ht

197cm

Wt

94kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

8.7

2star

K

5.1

2star

HB

3.6

3star

M

3.3

3star

T

1.6

4star

G

1.3

5star

No current season stats available

D

7.8

2star

K

4.8

2star

HB

3.0

3star

M

4.0

4star

T

2.4

4star

G

2.6

5star

was going to be the next big thing at Port.

I have no idea what it was I thought I saw either.

 

[PhatBoy]

Came home from the New Year's Test in 1992 of the view that the new blond leggie probably wasn't much chop.

Yeah I said something similar about Steve Smith when a Sydney grade **** told me ‘don’t worry about his spin, wait until they start picking him as a batsman’ and I scoffed at him.

 

[Wallaby]

Came home from the New Year's Test in 1992 of the view that the new blond leggie probably wasn't much chop.

Yeah, you know that McGrath bloke from NSW - just play him in the one-dayers to clog up an end. That barely-medium pace won't cut it in tests.

 

[Ambrosia]

I thought Bobby Hill wasn’t any good and was happy when the trade didn’t go through for him to Essendon

 

[PowerfulPies2023]

I've never made a call that I got wrong.
But I never made a call that I got right.
Nil all draw.

 

[longdonkey]

When Hinkley took over from Primus, I said Hinkley wouldn't last 3 years at Port. I redeemed myself by saying he would never take us to a premiership.

 

[Cam Payne]

Back about 2003 I bet a Hawks mate $50 Freo would win a flag before the Hawks next. Glad I never doubled down.

 

[Cyclops]

In 2003 i saw us beat Brisbane in a final, wirh Port our likely opponent in the Prelim and Brisbane at risk of straight sets. At the pub after I said to my brothers "one hand on the cup boys".

 

[Blues177]

Ladder prediction thread for 2023: Tipping Richmond to finish 2nd.

 

[Lockyer24]

Rozee was overrated
But it’s really only the half back role that has changed my mind

 

[Saints4ever]

About 30 years ago I thought it would be fun to follow the St Kilda football club.

I was wrong.

 

[terrybull]

I said that in the TV era, Collingwood only won Premierships in years ending with 0.

 

[Andyy]

Thought Tex was finished years ago. He might be finished this year but he's played several years longer than I thought he would.

Thought Carlton would bounce back after a crap start to the season. Pleased to be incorrect hehe

 

[Andyy]

"All time greats..." .... "....of the last 20 years..."

Lets look at JUST the last 20 years. Forget "all time"...

Top 10 last 20 years

Franklin
Lloyd
Jack Riewoldt
Tom Hawkins
Josh Kennedy
Nick Riewoldt
Matthew Pavlich
Jeremy Cameron
Taylor Walker
Eddie Betts

Then after that

Brendan Fevola
Jonathan Brown
Jarryd Roughead

Sam McLure simply has to be the biggest dumb **** nepo baby of all time.

Richardson?

 

[Cyclops]

Thought Tex was finished years ago. He might be finished this year but he's played several years longer than I thought he would.

Thought Carlton would bounce back after a crap start to the season. Pleased to be incorrect hehe

Not Robinson Crusoe on either of those.

 

[Gibbke]

After 2006, I could see all the signs that Geelong needed urgent repairs and would go into a few years of decline while they sorted it out, and that Melbourne was the best placed Victorian team to wrest dominance from the interstaters...

 

[GhostofJimJess]

I called just before the 1991 grand final that Paul Dear was a spud and a liability to the Hawks team.

2.5 hours later he was a Norm Smith medalist.

 

[HairyO]

HairyO just made a call worthy of this thread.

Looking back on GAJ and seeing him be a terrible choice by the club?

Hr was brilliant at individual glory and shit at being a team mate.

Jordan Lewis talked about how they would sit off him anywhere outside of F50 and only prrssure him when he was in goal kicking range. They knew that after he disposed of the ball they would get it back.

He was the cream GCS simply didnt need. They needed leaders who would bring the kids up. GAJ had zero interest in that.

Also, pretty sure this thread is about future predictions gone awry.

What I do is look at what David King says and then think the opposite

 

[Guardian Hawk]

"All time greats..." .... "....of the last 20 years..."

Lets look at JUST the last 20 years. Forget "all time"...

Top 10 last 20 years

Franklin
Lloyd
Jack Riewoldt
Tom Hawkins
Josh Kennedy
Nick Riewoldt
Matthew Pavlich
Jeremy Cameron
Taylor Walker
Eddie Betts

Then after that

Brendan Fevola
Jonathan Brown
Jarryd Roughead

Sam McLure simply has to be the biggest dumb **** nepo baby of all time.

Is this just in order of goals kicked?

I personally wouldn't have Taylor Walker in "Category 1" if Roughead, Fevola and Brown are in "Category 2".

Walker has been amazing (and miles in front of McKay regardless) but I'd porobably take the other 2 ahead of him slightly (or at least in the same category as him). Fevola kicked a similar amount of goals in much less games with much better season tallies (99, 89, 84, etc whilst Walker kicked 60+ twice and never 80). Roughead was a multiple AA (Walker once), Coleman medallist (Walker not) and kicked only slightly less goals despite 2 years at CHB, 2 years as a 2nd ruck, time in the midfield, etc. All about the same level IMO.

Not sure about timelines but I reckon Barry Hall deserves to be in the convo and if it fits 20 years (some overlap, some not), Warren Tredrea and Matthew Richardson also.

Either way - McKay is not in the ball park - wouldn't even have him ahead of the next rung like Curnow, Daniher, etc.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Looking back on GAJ and seeing him be a terrible choice by the club?

Hr was brilliant at individual glory and shit at being a team mate.

Jordan Lewis talked about how they would sit off him anywhere outside of F50 and only prrssure him when he was in goal kicking range. They knew that after he disposed of the ball they would get it back.

He was the cream GCS simply didnt need. They needed leaders who would bring the kids up. GAJ had zero interest in that.

Also, pretty sure this thread is about future predictions gone awry.

What I do is look at what David King says and then think the opposite

Oh if Jordan Lewis said it then its gospel.
The guy is the best midfielder of this century. Not a contest, no one even comes close.

To intimate he had no impact on games is purely and simply put. Erroneous.
The only somewhat reasonable argument to make is that he wasn't the right choice for them in 2010 as they were going to lose 20 games a season for about 3 years or so.

It's still an utterly woeful call. Will end up a HoF legend and be considered the best of his era.

 

[WillHayward]

Is this just in order of goals kicked?

I personally wouldn't have Taylor Walker in "Category 1" if Roughead, Fevola and Brown are in "Category 2".

Walker has been amazing (and miles in front of McKay regardless) but I'd porobably take the other 2 ahead of him slightly (or at least in the same category as him). Fevola kicked a similar amount of goals in much less games with much better season tallies (99, 89, 84, etc whilst Walker kicked 60+ twice and never 80). Roughead was a multiple AA (Walker once), Coleman medallist (Walker not) and kicked only slightly less goals despite 2 years at CHB, 2 years as a 2nd ruck, time in the midfield, etc. All about the same level IMO.

Not sure about timelines but I reckon Barry Hall deserves to be in the convo and if it fits 20 years (some overlap, some not), Warren Tredrea and Matthew Richardson also.

Either way - McKay is not in the ball park - wouldn't even have him ahead of the next rung like Curnow, Daniher, etc.

Just goals kicked yes

But it's not like McKay or Curnow offer anything outside goals kicked.

Calling them "great fwds of the last 20 years" is absolutely bonkers and only the most nuffy one eyed Blues would even consider it.

Just reveals how thick McLure really is.