Cam Rayner

[danster168]

Errr...I had Sam Taylor and Uniacke ahead of Rayner. Fritsch below him and I stand by that.

Lol. Fritsch kicks 6 in granny's, Rayner had 6 kicks total. and played spare man in defence at times.

If you're not going to admit you got Rayner drastically wrong then you're just being to proud.

 

[Dazb86]

Errr...I had Sam Taylor and Uniacke ahead of Rayner. Fritsch below him and I stand by that.

Fritsch below him?



Fritsch has been a leading goal kicker multiple times in a top 4 side, kicked 6 in a grand final and is genuinely consistent with his performance.

 

[HereIGoAgain]

This thread is the Demon fans Grand Final.

 

[MisterMarcus]

I’m surprised Old Mate is posting here.

I thought he’d have died of auto-erotic asphyxiation by now….

 

[danster168]

Fritsch below him?



Fritsch has been a leading goal kicker multiple times in a top 4 side, kicked 6 in a grand final and is genuinely consistent with his performance.

haha, don't worry, he's just trolling on that one. Not to mention making the AA squad.

 

[Dazb86]

haha, don't worry, he's just trolling on that one. Not to mention making the AA squad.

If you swapped Fritsch for Rayner then Melbourne don't win a flag IMO

 

[Chism]

If a Victorian team took him at #1 they would be crucified on here for decades. Funny how when an interstate team takes him he is largely ignored outside of this 1 thread really.

Biggest bust ever for a No1 draft pick.

 

[SSSSSS]

If a Victorian team took him at #1 they would be crucified on here for decades. Funny how when an interstate team takes him he is largely ignored outside of this 1 thread really.

Biggest bust ever for a No1 draft pick.

Lol did you forget about Jack Watts.

 

[danster168]

If you swapped Fritsch for Rayner then Melbourne don't win a flag IMO

If we swapped Fritsch for Rayner next season, we'd be bottom 4.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Lol. Fritsch kicks 6 in granny's, Rayner had 6 kicks total. and played spare man in defence at times.

If you're not going to admit you got Rayner drastically wrong then you're just being to proud.

I had already conceded earlier based on this year I had him too high at pick 9. He has had a patchy finals series but not without credit. There is a long way to go in his career. I still believe he can be a big impact player in big games but today is a reasonably serious setback to that assessment.

 

[danster168]

If a Victorian team took him at #1 they would be crucified on here for decades. Funny how when an interstate team takes him he is largely ignored outside of this 1 thread really.

Biggest bust ever for a No1 draft pick.

Nah apparently because he is strong and powerful and plays well twice a year that he is 'an impact player'. Oh and it's not about disposals, it's about impact lol

 

[danster168]

I had already conceded earlier based on this year I had him too high at pick 9. He has had a patchy finals series but not without credit. There is a long way to go in his career. I still believe he can be a big impact player in big games but today is a reasonably serious setback to that assessment.

yeah, eventually he will play well in a big game. As did Gary Rohan who eventually played well.

He was the Leon Davis medallist tonight.

 

[The King!]

Was shocking today , but so was the 2 time brownlow winner

 

[Chism]

Nah apparently because he is strong and powerful and plays well twice a year that he is 'an impact player'. Oh and it's not about disposals, it's about impact lol

Interstate supporters are a different breed and that is for sure.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Fritsch below him?



Fritsch has been a leading goal kicker multiple times in a top 4 side, kicked 6 in a grand final and is genuinely consistent with his performance.

Fritsch can play his role but he has built his reputation on easy receives. He is not a high level player, just a good finisher if the midfield is well on top.

 

[iBeng]

Danster leading the charge to have Cam discharged from the AFL for crimes against the sport.

 

[Chism]

Was shocking today , but so was the 2 time brownlow winner

 

[BubbleBass]

Put in a worst grand final effort then Meat Loaf

 

[matty lloyd the champ]

You get the sense that alot of people fall in love with what Rayner could be and ignore the type of player he is now.

Alot of the players in the Rayner mold, explosive, big bodied, hits the scoreboard get this type of favourable perception from fans.

For Essendon, Archie Perkins is that type of player. Strong in the contest, has flashes of brilliance, athletic but does not put it together on a consistent basis. Granted he is only in his 3rd season but he is one example.

 

[Lets Roar like '44]

Put in a worst grand final effort then Meat Loaf

Yep put in a shocker.

 

[Daka]

Was shocking today , but so was the 2 time brownlow winner

That's why he won't be revered like some other winners.

 

[schmuttt]

Lol did you forget about Jack Watts.

Rayner is literally invisible most weeks and barring his first season every year the club he’s been at has made finals. Has had a way better environment than Watts to develop in and has been worse imo

 

[fpm84]

The Leon Davis medalist for sure today.
Promised heaps, but was worse than useless.

Did you not watch Hipwood?

 

[SSSSSS]

Rayner is literally invisible most weeks and barring his first season every year the club he’s been at has made finals. Has had a way better environment than Watts to develop in and has been worse imo

Nah there is no way in hell Rayner comes close to Watts.

Watt's was one of the most hyped number 1s in history.

 

[Kipz]

Thought Starcevich, Zorko and Hipwood were a lot worse.