SBYM
Fish, chips, cup o' tea, Mary @#? Poppins. London!
Mate Buckley was up there with Hird.
Swan??
Lol
Brownlow votes, apparently...
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Mate Buckley was up there with Hird.
Swan??
Lol
It's unfathomable the amount of hatred and bias against Buckley on a public forum. Whether it be his playing career or his coaching career.
Is there anyone else people have wished so much evil towards and pleasure when things haven't gone to plan?
Not rating Buckley as highly as Collingwood supporters is not hatred or bias. It is merely opinion.It's unfathomable the amount of hatred and bias against Buckley on a public forum. Whether it be his playing career or his coaching career.
Is there anyone else people have wished so much evil towards and pleasure when things haven't gone to plan?
Having that opinion also doesn't mean any of what I've said isn't true either.Not rating Buckley as highly as Collingwood supporters is not hatred or bias. It is merely opinion.
Michael Voss is the #1 player since 2000
That is just so wrong.
Switch teams and Collingwood probably wins the flags.
Brisbane would not have coped with look at me Buckley in the same side as Akermanis.
'The only pack Bucks went into was a pack of twisties, Swan has been Eddiewoods best centreman of the last 40 years, and yes I'm old.
I thought that title went to Paynton Manning.
opps sorry wrong board...... by the way Tommy says hi.
Apologies to those scratching heads ...its an in joke.
Jest aside Voss was the leading Mid in his era.
It's an even bigger outrage that he didn't have Lenny Hayes in his list.
He destroyed Selwood when they went head to head as inside mids, he was BOG in the 2009 GF until Bartel tagged him and won the Norm Smith in 2010.
Wasn't even the best midfielder in his team.
The bias of Collingwood supporters does not equate to fact.Wouldn't of even made a prelim. Voss as a player had nothing on Buckley.
Voss captained 3 premiership teams.Must have been a hard gig captaining the Lions team, 3 Brownlow medalists in their midfield, All Australian players on every line, hardly ever getting tagged because you're not the most damaging mid in Your own team etc etc.
Yet, he's appartently a better player and captain than Buckley even though as a player he was statistically inferiour in every area and as a captain he got kissed on tbe dick more than any captain before him.
Just our of curiosity, who captained more finals wins out of the 2? Can't be bothered looking it up but it must have been close.
And if the Lions merger never happened he would've been lucky to have captained one.Voss captained 3 premiership teams.
Not even close.
Opinion does not require bias.And if the Lions merger never happened he would've been lucky to have captained one.
Gotta say mate, for someone "unbiased" like your good self you do seem pretty vested in this topic.
Voss 13 from 16Must have been a hard gig captaining the Lions team, 3 Brownlow medalists in their midfield, All Australian players on every line, hardly ever getting tagged because you're not the most damaging mid in Your own team etc etc.
Yet, he's appartently a better player and captain than Buckley even though as a player he was statistically inferiour in every area and as a captain he got kissed on tbe dick more than any captain before him.
Just our of curiosity, who captained more finals wins out of the 2? Can't be bothered looking it up but it must have been close.
The hatred of Collingwood/Buckley bashers does not equate to fact either.The bias of Collingwood supporters does not equate to fact.
Voss 13 from 16
Buckley 5 from 9
Pretty close. Maybe if you take out the Coll vs Briz games it gets closerMust have been a hard gig captaining the Lions team, 3 Brownlow medalists in their midfield, All Australian players on every line, hardly ever getting tagged because you're not the most damaging mid in Your own team etc etc.
Yet, he's appartently a better player and captain than Buckley even though as a player he was statistically inferiour in every area and as a captain he got kissed on tbe dick more than any captain before him.
Just our of curiosity, who captained more finals wins out of the 2? Can't be bothered looking it up but it must have been close.
Nick Maxwell had captained more finals wins than Buckley. He must be a better player too.Pretty close. Maybe if you take out the Coll vs Briz games it gets closer
Wasn't the one making the captaincy argument, just laughing at it backfiring.Nick Maxwell had captained more finals wins than Buckley. He must be a better player too.
And this is in the same line as what Collingwood supporters argue with Buckley.It's an even bigger outrage that he didn't have Lenny Hayes in his list.
He destroyed Selwood when they went head to head as inside mids, he was BOG in the 2009 GF until Bartel tagged him and won the Norm Smith in 2010.
He was simply asking the question, and I simply answered it. Not trying to add to any arguments.Wasn't the one making the captaincy argument, just laughing at it backfiring.
FWIW I have Buckley & Voss in the top 5 easily. Both were good goal kickers & had ability to play forward. Huge asset and advantage to just your standard possession gathering mid.