Again it is not 'my logic' i was replying to the OP who was claiming Dunstall never managed to do it. This was not my way of talking down Dusty it is pointing out how stupid it is to claim Dunstall was a 'workman like player'Well then your argument about a player leading a bad team to a flag doesn't make any sense. Because let's be honest, no "bad" teams win flags, they're all extremely bloody good. So you can't pot Dusty for never having done it, because no-one else has done it either.
What's funny is you completely dismissed my reasoning that Dusty led us to a flag in 2017. All the crap we went through in 2016 combined with what most were calling an average to poor list. And Dusty led the on-field charge for us back up the ladder. You can't deny that.
If winning Colemans and B&F's in premiership years is not 'carrying a team' neither is anything else.
What you were is pretty irrelevant to what you were in 2017. I could just as easily point to flags in 19 and 20 and a prelim in 18 to prove you were a stacked team.