Can Sam Walsh be the GOAT?

[bresker]

Even if it's a troll thread, two years ago it had enough merit for posters to actively discuss the issue on the main board. Now it belongs a sub-Bay 13 museum of ridicule.

 

[RCAB]

Even if it's a troll thread, two years ago it had enough merit for posters to actively discuss the issue on the main board.

No it didn't.

It was purely to make a parody of the ND goat thread.

Ultimately the OP knew that SW would never be the goat, but thought that by posting this, it would bring light on how ridiculous Daicos been the goat question was.

This wasn't a backfire because SW never got close to GOAT status, but ultimately because ND might potentially be a GOAT and is tracking to be one. So ultimately this is essentially a "backfire by association".

The thread was started two years ago and has only 17 pages, it was never legitimately discussed or considered.

 

[Orange crush]

No it didn't.

It was purely to make a parody of the ND goat thread.

Ultimately the OP knew that SW would never be the goat, but thought that by posting this, it would bring light on how ridiculous Daicos been the goat question was.

This wasn't a backfire because SW never got close to GOAT status, but ultimately because ND might potentially be a GOAT and is tracking to be one. So ultimately this is essentially a "backfire by association".

The thread was started two years ago and has only 17 pages, it was never legitimately discussed or considered.

We need a serious Murphy Reid GOAT thread

 

[scott2clarkson]

I'm in the no vote!
He seemed really slow yesterday.
Maybe his back is still giving him trouble.
Vossy needs to blood the kids. As in bringing in more kids.

 

[Blue1980]

I think he will just be a solid good to very good player from here on out. Injuries and the club in general turning him into Marc Murphy 2.0

 

[bresker]

GOAT doing goat things.

The GOAT of first quarters .

 

[bzparkes]

GOAT doing goat things.

The GOAT of first quarters .

Already put out to pasture in the 2nd quarter though

 

[bresker]

The GOAT feasts early & then he rests.

 

[bungalow_bill]

Was GOATing big time in the 1st. Practically unstoppable. Was he tagged out of it or is it a fitness issue?

 

[kreuze_missile]

You are all writing the Gary Ayres Medallist and 1x All Australian off too soon.

I have faith. He will come good.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Was GOATing big time in the 1st. Practically unstoppable. Was he tagged out of it or is it a fitness issue?

They are an elite first quarter side

 

[Chief]

They are an elite first quarter side

Not the question that was asked. This isn't the banter thread.

 

[Chief]

Chronz - Be careful...

 

[dean33]

They are an elite first quarter side

100%.
If we have another pandemic and the afl reduce all games to 30mins the blues will be unstoppable.
Really they are just a world calamity from domination.

 

[Chief]

100%.
If we have another pandemic and the afl reduce all games to 30mins the blues will be unstoppable.
Really they are just a world calamity from domination.

Still not the banter thread...

 

[Chronz]

Chronz - Be careful...

Hi Chief, what's going on today m8?

 

[Chief]

Hi Chief, what's going on today m8?

 

[dean33]

Still not the banter thread...

Apologies, I thought looking at the thread title it was.

 

[Chief]

Apologies, I thought looking at the thread title it was.

In which part of your post did you mention Sam Walsh, hmmmm?

 

[Art Vandelay_]

You are all writing the Gary Ayres Medallist and 1x All Australian off too soon.

I have faith. He will come good.

Would want to get a move on to be the 'goat'. 26 this season and only 1 AA.
Would need to get near the 7,8 time AA players to even be in the conversation.

 

[bresker]

GOAT , meet Daddy GOAT

 

[UltraEgo]

hey WalshistheGOAT