Captains Captains Thread

[PAFC27]

Got all three but Cogs has the best venue history, recent history, career average and highest ceiling of them all. VC locked in.

Danger C

 

[VSTone]

Taranto VC / Danger C at the moment.

 

[kraka]

hard to believe that Danger is a POD now
C it is !

 

[bl4ke]

Kelly or Cogs

 

[PAFC27]

Kelly or Cogs

I'm super huge on Cogs tonight

 

[bl4ke]

I'm super huge on Cogs tonight

Yeah you'd think Clarke would go to Kelly?

 

[PAFC27]

Yeah you'd think Clarke would go to Kelly?

No idea I haven't even considered Dylan Clarke as I don't rate him as a tagger. But you'd think so and Cogs has the added benefit of going up forward/tagging somebody else

 

[Lyyynnnchy]

No idea I haven't even considered Dylan Clarke as I don't rate him as a tagger. But you'd think so and Cogs has the added benefit of going up forward/tagging somebody else

Cogs' score has been severely affected by taggers in the past

 

[PAFC27]

Cogs' score has been severely affected by taggers in the past

And so have the others. You can really throw a blanket over all three but I'm gonna back the guy with the highest venue and opponent average and hope that he dishes out something close to the 192 he did under a month ago

 

[Lyyynnnchy]

And so have the others. You can really throw a blanket over all three but I'm gonna back the guy with the highest venue and opponent average and hope that he dishes out something close to the 192 he did under a month ago

You've convinced me

 

[JADED]

GWS already played bombers round 1.
Cogs 162, Taranto 137
Kelly DNP
Merrett 50 with DeBoer tag.

Few differences this time.

 

[powerrrrrrrrrrrr]

Who gets the VC tonight with half my midfield playing. Kelly, Taranto, cogs or Merrett?

Leaning towards Taranto but chances are I’ll pick the Lowest scorer of the 4!

 

[TheRednWhite]

Ah this is going to be like the adel vs rich game a few weeks ago. I had Houli VC hoping to get a leg up and everyone else went Brouch VC and got rewarded with 130. I'll have Taranto and Cogs this week and have to choose Taranto VC, Cogs will go huge and Taranto sub 100.

 

[TheRednWhite]

Who gets the VC tonight with half my midfield playing. Kelly, Taranto, cogs or Merrett?

Leaning towards Taranto but chances are I’ll pick the Lowest scorer of the 4!

Jelly>Taranto>Cogs>Zach

 

[redrex94]

Taranto or J.Kelly as Vice?

Taranto named in the back lines for some fun..? had it on him based on their scores against each other recently but just flicked it to Kelly. Thoughts?

 

[TheRednWhite]

Taranto or J.Kelly as Vice?

Taranto named in the back lines for some fun..? had it on him based on their scores against each other recently but just flicked it to Kelly. Thoughts?

yeah Jelly is hard to go past as VC. Taranto has gone under 100 a few times, Jelly doesn't look like he'll go under 110 for the rest of the year. Taranto probably slightly higher ceiling due to his tackling but not much in it. Think Jelly is the safer 130 tonight

 

[powerrrrrrrrrrrr]

Who gets the VC tonight with half my midfield playing. Kelly, Taranto, cogs or Merrett?

Leaning towards Taranto but chances are I’ll pick the Lowest scorer of the 4!

Knew it, picked the wrong one!

 

[Alvin Purple]

Mmm went Kelly for VC, told myself 120 was the line.

Guess I will take it but just have a feeling Dramafield might go huge on the big Friday Night stage

 

[TheRednWhite]

I'm going to cave and captain Danger, seems the popular pick...I told myself I would never do it again and would captain Grundy or Gawn for the rest of the year. Can see it already now, Danger starts on fire and then cops a knock to the knee. Goes off but then comes back on with strapping and parks himself inside fwd 50. Kicks 2 but only gets 80 fantasy points. Grundy meanwhile does what he usually does, gets his 120, and I'll be wondering why I punish myself every week with captains.

 

[Zevon]

Really want to go Duncan as a unique little captain option but every time I’ve tried something similar this season the popular captain choice has gone into full on beast mode. Feels like if I go with Duncan then Danger will be on about 110 at half time, all my league opponents will have the C on him, and I’ll sit there saying “you idiot” to myself for the whole night.

 

[DynamiteDons]

Really want to go Duncan as a unique little captain option but every time I’ve tried something similar this season the popular captain choice has gone into full on beast mode. Feels like if I go with Duncan then Danger will be on about 110 at half time, all my league opponents will have the C on him, and I’ll sit there saying “you idiot” to myself for the whole night.

Yeah i want to do something similar but just dont want it to backfire ahaha

 

[SloaneysDanger]

I feel like Danger will beat 120 but he's so injury prone I'm not sure if it's worth gambling and not taking Kelly's 120.

 

[Chris99]

I feel like Danger will beat 120 but he's so injury prone I'm not sure if it's worth gambling and not taking Kelly's 120.

Take the 120. Its safe as houses and a very respectable captain score.

 

[Chris99]

Macrae or Boak? I can't split them at all. Will be raining quite hard, but both tackle. Boak gets his goal a game, but my mind goes back to macare last year v port in the wet where he was on like 44 through the first quarter.

 

[bl4ke]

Still really undecided by the "safe" popular Danger pick, or the in form Macrae