Club Focus Carlton 2020 - Williams, Fogarty, Saad, Durdin, Carroll

[Jeremias]

Data from footywire. To check the draft order (updated weekly) see the thread here.

 

[Jeremias]

OK, time for Carlton's club focus thread.

See below for a summary of Carlton's player contract situations, as well as information about experience, ages and heights.

The data has been taken from FootyWire, and the spreadsheet will update itself when FootyWire is updated. It may contain some errors, and unfortunately we do not have the ability to update them so we just have to deal with what we're given.




According to this data, Carlton are:
- 10th tallest, averaging 188cm
- 15th heaviest, averaging 85.3kg
- 3rd youngest with an average age of 23.7 years
- 2nd least experienced, averaging 60.1 career games

Your picks in the first five rounds of the 2019 national draft are:
1st round pick (tied to Adelaide - currently pick 11)
3rd round pick (tied to Carlton - currently pick 38)
3rd round pick (tied to Adelaide - currently pick 47)
4th round pick (tied to GWS - currently pick 68)
5th round pick (tied to Adelaide - currently pick 83)

To check the draft order (updated weekly) see the thread here.

Key questions and discussion topics:

1) Who retires, who is traded, and who is re-signed?

2) What do you see as the gaps in the list? How could those gaps be filled? Via trade or from the draft?

3) What will it take to get it all done, given the current trade and draft value on hand?

 

[Jeremias]

My (brief) current thoughts:

1.

Retire - Kade Simpson
Delist - Darcy Lang, Matthew Lobbe, Jarrod Pickett, Andrew Phillips. Kym Lebois
Re-Sign - Jack Silvagni, Matthew Kennedy, Matthew Kreuzer, Liam Jones, Angus Schumacher, Jarrod Garlett, Caleb Marchbank, David Cuningham, Patrick Kerr, Dale Thomas, Levi Casboult, Hugh Goddard

2.

For mine there are three main gaps -

1) Experience
2) Small forwards
3) Outside run

And if we make the above changes, another gap appears -

4) Backup rucks

I suspect all of the above can and will be looked at via trade and free agency first. There are plenty of options out there but I'll throw a couple of names into the mix to get the discussion started.

Small forwards - Tom Papley, Jamie Elliott, Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti
Outside run - Brad Hill, Ed Langdon, Lewis Taylor, Brandon Ellis, Harry Cunningham
Rucks - Reilly O'Brien, Darcy Cameron, Max Lynch, Zac Smith

Lack of experience will fix itself naturally as we continue to get games into the kids we've spent a few years now recruiting heavily. But there are plenty of other names worth discussing - be it a superstar like Coniglio, veterans like Nathan Jones or David Mundy, or countless other players currently out of contract who we may look to bring in relatively cheaply - as we did with Newman last year.

3.

What will it take to get it all done?

We've been pretty open about going after mature talent now after spending a few years hitting the draft heavily. And we're not going to muck around - all draft picks would be on the table, and we know we've got plenty of cash to attract free agents.

Keen to hear your thoughts

 

[branedotorg]

Ruck is the big one for me. Kruezer is great but 30 and seems injured alot and tdk is still a baby though promising.

 

[SickQwon]

OUT:

Delist:
Matthew Lobbe
Angus Schumacher
Darcy Lang
Jarrod Pickett (retired)
Kym Lebois
Thomas Bugg (retired)
Jarrod Garlett
Alex Fasolo (Did not trigger his 2nd and 3rd year clause)

Retire:
Kade Simpson (May be offered a 1 year deal)
Dale Thomas

Free Agency:
Levi Casboult (Reportedly triggered a 1 year clause in his contract)

IN:

Trade:
Brad Hill (Fremantle) = 2nd Round Pick + Future 2nd Round Pick. (Not linked to anymore)
Darcy Cameron (Swans) = Future 3rd
Tom Papley (Swans) = Adelaide's 1st Round Pick + Swap of later picks
*New* Ed Langdon (Fremantle) = 2nd Round Pick
*New* Jack Martin (Gold Coast) = Future 2nd + Swap of later picks

Free Agency
Stephen Hill
Brandon Ellis (Richmond)
Cameron Ellis-Yolmen (Adelaide)
Adam Tomlinson (GWS)
*New* Stephen Coniglio (GWS)

Draft picks:
68, 83, 92

 

[Jeremias]

Ruck is the big one for me. Kruezer is great but 30 and seems injured alot and tdk is still a baby though promising.

If we get rid of both Lobbe and Phillips it's certainly a position we'll need to bolster.

We'll have Kreuzer (who just re-signed for 2020) and TDK but not much other than part-timers in between.

We don't need a superstar but someone who can hold the fort whilst TDK develops. Would be happy enough with any of the 4 I mentioned in the OP, with Cameron having already been linked.

 

[Buzzasto DaSilva]

OUT:

Delist:
Matthew Lobbe
Angus Schumacher
Darcy Lang
Jarrod Pickett (retired)
Kym Lebois
Thomas Bugg (retired)
Jarrod Garlett

Retire: (Hopefully keep)
Kade Simpson
Dale Thomas

Free Agency:
Levi Casboult

IN:

Trade:
Darcy Cameron (Swans) = Future 3rd
Brad Hill (Fremantle) = 2nd Round Pick + Future 2nd Round Pick
Tom Papley (Swans) = Adelaide's 1st Round Pick

Free Agency
Stephen Hill
Brandon Ellis
Cameron Ellis-Yolmen
Adam Tomlinson

Draft picks:
68, 83, 92

Those changes would make Carlton a significantly better side. Papley will be very tough however.

What do you think Tomlinson is worth in terms of a contract?

 

[Foucault1989]

Those changes would make Carlton a significantly better side. Papley will be very tough however.

What do you think Tomlinson is worth in terms of a contract?

I don't know if us Carlton fans can do the Tomlinson dance again. He is the new Pavlich...always seemingly on the radar

 

[james Dean]

How Fasolo got a 3 year contract is a travesty

 

[Arr0w]

Real test of our improvement will be from here to the end of the season. At this stage the progress of the rebuild is firmly on track

 

[getgaff]

CARLTON

High number of out of contract players here and some that can be considered lucky to get an extra year

Re-signings are as follows: Jack Silvagni, Kennedy, Jones, Marchbank, Newman, Cuningham, Phillips, Kerr, Cottrell, DeLuca, Gibbons, Simpson, Casboult & Thomas (rolling one years)

No real surprises in the re-signing I don't think. Silvagni I think has done enough this year to get an extension, needs to solidify a role in the 22 but.

The next handful up to Phillips just makes sense to give them multiple year extensions.

Phillips is definitely still required as back up for Kruezer, 2 year extension wouldn't be out of place. Kerr is worth a re-signing, hopefully it comes with some increased senior opportunity in 2020 if he is up to it.

The SSP and mid year signings can all get re-signed as rookies and or get elevated to senior list status. Deluca under the most pressure of the 3 I think.

Thomas is still OK with rolling contracts and Casboult the same as depth and experience. Simpson if he wants it is guaranteed of another year until he reaches the end.


TRADE

Wait and see which un-contracted players requests a move. Think stability is required but and wouldn't go trading away players unnecessarily.


DE-LIST

De-listings I have: Darcy, Lang, Angus Schumacher (re-rookie???), Jarrod Garlett, Matthew Lobbe, Hugh Goddard, Kym Lebois (re-rookie???

Lang is a possibility to get a rolling extension for some experience around a younger team, same with Schumacher who has the traits to persist with but is line ball.

Lebois hasn't come along as hoped for. Think his skill set is still required at the Blues however it will be a decision on if he can improve enough.

The Garlett experiment hasn't been fruitful unfortunately. Lobbe is probably in the de-list / retire category, better off getting a younger ruck in from the juniors that can be developed or a state league guy that is ready for the next step.

Goddard unfortunately hasn't worked either. Could be a player that is offered up to a team looking for KPD depth for peanuts

 

[branedotorg]

getgaff
phillips and lobbe both gone - trade for a new mid age ruck.

think casboult might go for a bigger final contract given his huge improvement this last year.

deluca hasn't shown much for me but gibbons i'd give two years.

think schumacher gets an extension but not a long one.

 

[Tandy]

Any takers for daisy

 

[bmaurizio]

If we can add Stephen Coniglio and Jack Martin to our midfield just watch Charlie , Mitch , Matt and Harry have a frolic up front.
The young midfielders will develop nicely too, Walsh, Dow , SPS, Setterfield, Stocker, Fisher and O’Brien too. Stephen & Jack would obviously be sensational additions to any team in the competition.
We’d be playing finals in a couple of years.

 

[HirdyLannister]

If we can add Stephen Coniglio and Jack Martin to our midfield just watch Charlie , Mitch , Matt and Harry have a frolic up front.
The young midfielders will develop nicely too, Walsh, Dow , SPS, Setterfield, Stocker, Fisher and O’Brien too. Stephen & Jack would obviously be sensational additions to any team in the competition.
We’d be playing finals in a couple of years.

If Carlton land cogs and martin, player retention is going to be an issue in the coming years. You can't keep all those players you've listed.

 

[Elmer_Judd]

If Carlton land cogs and martin, player retention is going to be an issue in the coming years. You can't keep all those players you've listed.

Yes we can. We have some creative accountants down at IKON Park..

 

[Red Bull]

If Carlton land cogs and martin, player retention is going to be an issue in the coming years. You can't keep all those players you've listed.

Any loses in the future will be well compensated.
Silvagni has planned and built the list from basically ground zero.
Docherty and Cripps were the only 2 players with long term futures when the plan was tabled.

 

[zeggie]

Fasolo is on a 1 year conditional contract, not on a 3 year contract, and most certainly will not have met his trigger for a 2nd year.

 

[Lore]

Daisy retires

'Bitter disappointment': Daisy reluctantly retires after no Carlton contract

Dale Thomas not closing the door on extending his 257-game career after not being renewed by Blues

www.afl.com.au

 

[Lore]

Jack Silvagni re-signed

Resurrected Blue blood re-signs to keep famous family name alive at Carlton

Jack Silvagni has been rewarded with a new deal after a recent purple patch

www.afl.com.au

 

[Jeremias]

Wasn't really ever in doubt, but it's great to have Jack locked away for another two seasons.

Has improved enormously in 2019.

 

[Lore]

AFL website has an article about players who are still out-of-contract as of this morning. We don't have 2019 player threads for any of these guys atm.

Out of contract: Matthew Cottrell, Josh Deluca, Jarrod Garlett, Mick Gibbons, Hugh Goddard, Patrick Kerr, Kym LeBois, Matthew Lobbe, Andrew Phillips, Angus Schumacher, Kade Simpson

"Simpson is set to continue into an 18th season, as AFL.com.au reported last week, while Levi Casboult satisfied a trigger in his contract that will earn him a deal for 2020. Gibbons hasn't missed a game since being picked up in the pre-season supplemental selection period and will be retained, and mid-season draftee Deluca is expected to receive another year. However, first-year Blue Alex Fasolo has retired. Phillips has a one-year offer in front of him, while Kerr and Schumacher are hopeful of staying on after showing promise in the VFL."

Re-sign or let go? Your club's out-of-contract players

R23 not only marks the end of the season for 10 clubs, but it’s also the last chance for many footballers to press their claims for a new contract

www.afl.com.au

 

[Pablito]

You would think based on the above list we lose Garlett, Kerr, Lebois, Lobbe and maybe Schumacher. On top of losing Pickett right after the mid season draft (Bugg was replaced) and retiring Daisy and Fas, that's 7-8 changes to the list.

I doubt any player is traded out.

 

[Mr.X]

Any truth in the whisper that Mitch McGovern may be shopped around?

 

[Mister Carlton]

Any truth in the whisper that Mitch McGovern may be shopped around?

Who wants that spud?