carlton v richmond midfields

[Barry Zuckercorn]

Cousins is at least an 8.5
He is a better player then most the people listed however injuries hold him back. Judd is not a 10 at this point in time i would have him at 9.
Cotchin should be 7 at least, foley is better than murphy and gibbs imo and you have rated him lower then both.

I would also not have gibbs and murphy at the same rating as a player like joel corey, they're not quite there yet.

Of course all this depends on who you count as midfielders and how deep you go. It also depends how much wieght you put on potential compared to what a player has proven.

Hahahaha

Now we know why Richmond picked him... Apparently he's still an 8.5 even after over a year out of the game and battling a drug addiction.

Oh, I nearly forgot that other little gem about Cousins. How he's sustained something like 6 hammy injuries in the last 12 games he's player. Bloody hell Richmond... You thought you were the smart ones by picking him up

Is it any wonder this club just seems to get nowhere for 3 decades now?

As for the poll results, massive LOLZ! Shows you can fool most of the people some of the time.

Carlton's midfield isnt the best in the league just yet (and may never be) but it is clearly superior to Richmonds.

 

[Kappa Tau]

This poll is a joke, juddy could earn the 4 points on his own against the whole richmond team

 

[inthesong]

Put simply Richmonds midfield doesnt have the polish or skill level that Carltons has, Yes they may have some talented and fast players running through there but they dont have the skill or hardened bodies required to make a massive impact at the highest level, yet.. i say yet because given time they can be a very good outfit

Blues comfortably for now.