List Mgmt. Carlton's 2018 Draft Thread II

[TerryWallet]

Everyone's getting into comfortable positions in the draft for the players they want. This is the market working more efficiently.

Absolutely. Much better for each Clubs ability to manage their own list management.

 

[Jimmae]

Stack, Turner, Reid and McKenzie still on the board here...

 

[CFC18]

Cavarra the first mature player picked? Shows that there was no better value to extract than the pick #42 we got from Geelong, despite some criticism.

 

[TerryWallet]

Foot was one who i had pegged as missing out.

Sydney have just gone speed on speed on speed the last few drafts. Interesting.

 

[The Bighouse]

Cavarra the first mature player picked? Shows that there was no better value to extract than the pick #42 we got from Geelong, despite some criticism.

Actually the 6th one, our 2 + 3 for the GCFC

 

[The Bighouse]

Foot was one who i had pegged as missing out.

Sydney have just gone speed on speed on speed the last few drafts. Interesting.

Was thinking Foot may have been one of the Vic Country kids we were looking at.

 

[jj1978]

Odds Dodo bids for BSOS at pick 60??

 

[Arr0w]

Turner might go in the next 3-4 picks

 

[Jimmae]

Odds Dodo bids for BSOS at pick 60??

Doesn't matter, only deletes our last pick (73)

 

[The Bighouse]

Odds Dodo bids for BSOS at pick 60??

Had just eyed that off as well.

 

[TooBlue14]

Imagine the pressure applied to the Crows if they start with a poor season and Carlton looks on the improve... the Adelaide ferals will be going nuts!

First 12 games for Adelaide

Hawks (H) - 50/50
Sydney (A) - L
Geelong (H) - L
North (A) - 50/50
GC (H) - W
Saints (A) - W
Freo (A) - W
Port (A) - L
Bris (A) - 50/50
Eagles (H) - L
Melb (A) - L
GWS (H) - 50/50

Adelaide after 12 could be as bad as 3-9. They could start 0-3 even 0-4 as North have had their number lately and often start the year really well. SOS will be rubbing his fingers together by the bye. Thanks Adelaide.

 

[The Bighouse]

Will Walker
Riley Bowman
Anyone else likely?

 

[Arr0w]

Saints must really think they are a chance to make the 8 given the mature age players they are taking, good luck

 

[CFC18]

Actually the 6th one, our 2 + 3 for the GCFC

Touché

 

[Jimmae]

Turner might go in the next 3-4 picks

What's seeing McKenzie slide so much? Production by foot?

 

[My Hat]

Reckon this Stocker trade is a perfect example of SOS's buy low, sell high philosophy.

Buy low: We apparently rated Stocker in the top 10, so to get him at 19 is a big discount. If it's true that Richmond were going to take him with their next pick then we literally got him at the lowest possible pick.

Sell high: Injuries had a big impact on us this year, making us look worse than we really are. The gap between where we think we're placed internally and where others expect us to be next year is significant, which means this year is probably the best possible time to trade out our future first in terms of maximising its value.

And if the situation within Adelaide is as bad as people say, then picking up their future first could turn out to be another example of SOS buying low.

 

[The Bighouse]

Saints must really think they are a chance to make the 8 given the mature age players they are taking, good luck

They’ve done this before too - goodbye Scotty on that occasion.

 

[Jimmae]

Really strange draft from Brisbane, though I like Joyce @ 40

 

[footyfan1978]

should bid on Brownless when it our turn

 

[gardiner stand]

First 12 games for Adelaide

Hawks (H) - 50/50
Sydney (A) - L
Geelong (H) - L
North (A) - 50/50
GC (H) - W
Saints (A) - W
Freo (A) - W
Port (A) - L
Bris (A) - 50/50
Eagles (H) - L
Melb (A) - L
GWS (H) - 50/50

Adelaide after 12 could be as bad as 3-9. They could start 0-3 even 0-4 as North have had their number lately and often start the year really well. SOS will be rubbing his fingers together by the bye. Thanks Adelaide.

I wish they would be 3-9 but I doubt it

 

[Jimmae]

should bid on Brownless when it our turn

Won't matter unless the Cats only plan on having 38 on the list. Bid matching is now free from this point, costing a team's last pick.

Pies are going to get a good player for a song at pick 98, with Atunaisa Bosenavulagi still on the board.

Khamis will also be a solid get for the Dogs for pick 75.

 

[The Grover]

Who are chances for our pick? Any small forwards?

 

[TerryWallet]

Saints must really think they are a chance to make the 8 given the mature age players they are taking, good luck

My mind is boggled.

But then again, my sig.

 

[Arr0w]

What's seeing McKenzie slide so much? Production by foot?

Not sure, I think he is good by foot, short and long and has a high DE%

 

[Jimmae]

Marty Hore? Dees are desperate for defensive reinforcements.