List Mgmt. Carlton's 2018 Draft Thread II

[gardiner stand]

Sydney Stack misses altogether.

Didn't one of us have him in the top 10?

There must have been some serious concerns about him.

Ablett said on the Foxtel coverage that he was a good kid,shame he’s missed out

 

[Arr0w]

Surprised you are joining the chorus for a project ruck. With Kreuze and Harry covering the ones, with a number of
development games for TDK, we will have trouble finding ruck minutes for the developing TDK, Lobbe, Phillips and
even Levi. No room for another ruck, despite the imbalanced age profile.

I never think short term needs Coona, when it comes to drafting. Drafting a tall or ruckman, should be viewed as a replacement, 4 years down the track

I think, Lobbe, MK, Phillips, Levi will all be gone by then, unless the clubs has plans to target an existing ruckman in the next 2 years, but that can be flawed list management

 

[TerryWallet]

Ablett said on the Foxtel coverage that he was a good kid,shame he’s missed out

He also said wtte that this is a message to all kids that if you're not committed at all times then you are likely writing your death knell these days.

He also strongly intimated this re Stack during the Carnival.

Ablett runs the WA junior program.

 

[Robbo's my hero]

The only thing better than the draft is witnessing the roller coaster ride of emotions from Jimmae

It could have been worse. Your cousins horse could have won the 6th at Townsville today paying $60 for the win.

 

[murphster]

Disappointed for Sam Fisher thought he deserved a slot as a rookie would have preferred him over Bugg boy. We still have another spot I wonder if we are saving it for SSP period, must be.
Maybe giving Fisher & Blakey another week to fight it out for the last spot.

 

[Arr0w]

Smelling a project ruckman/tall and a goal kicking mid

hmmmmm Goddard and Bugg, not the 2 I had in mind, but does give us coverage

Especially KPD, where we are paper thin

 

[I bleed Blue]

Very disappointed for fisher. Would like to see us reward from within.

Hope another club takes him in the mid season draft and he turns into the next lambert.

 

[murphster]

Disappointed for Sam Fisher thought he deserved a slot as a rookie would have preferred him over Bugg boy. We still have another spot I wonder if we are saving it for SSP period, must be.
Maybe giving Fisher & Blakey another week to fight it out for the last spot.

Nope I’m wrong forgot Owies that’s 41 senior and 4 rookies. Full House.

 

[RedFury]

Meh. Gotta admit Blakey and Fisher would have excited me a lot more. I know it's a list balance thing but ...

 

[Soapy V]

I thought Blakey might get picked but I'm happy with what happened. Makes sense

 

[gardiner stand]

Can’t get excited about Goddard. Collingwood is desperate for KPD’s and could’ve got him as a delisted free agent,that says something. I don’t rate him at all but good luck to him and I hope he proves me wrong

 

[gardiner stand]

hmmmmm Goddard and Bugg, not the 2 I had in mind, but does give us coverage

Especially KPD, where we are paper thin

Macreadie miles better than Goddard

 

[Bamboo Harvester]

FFS

FFS x 2

Bugg I can maybe understand....but Goddard???? Why the **** then did we draft BSOS??

 

[Arr0w]

Macreadie miles better than Goddard

You know that can change quickly, either way, we now have appropriate options

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Nope I’m wrong forgot Owies that’s 41 senior and 4 rookies. Full House.

Owies is Cat B and outside the list is he not?

 

[Jimmae]

FFS x 2

Bugg I can maybe understand....but Goddard???? Why the **** then did we draft BSOS??

I understand both, I just feel we didn't need to make both moves, particularly Bugg (and I'm frustrated we hamstrung ourselves with a few contracts). Ben will start in the defensive group, but he'll be an option up forward. Three or four of Kerr, Levi, Phillips and Lobbe will go at the end of next year.

For the 2019 season, I just hope Jack is playing midfield.

Owies is Cat B and outside the list is he not?

Yup, we're at 40/3/1 right now.

 

[The Bighouse]

Nope I’m wrong forgot Owies that’s 41 senior and 4 rookies. Full House.

Owies is a Cat B,not included

 

[Blue_Fusion]

Am I missing something or did Stack not get drafted at all?? I didn't think much of him from what I saw (which admittedly wasn't much) but there were quite a few predicting he'd go somewhere in the 2nd round. If he hasn't even been rookied, I wonder what would have caused the clubs to stay away...

 

[Robbo's my hero]

Am I missing something or did Stack not get drafted at all?? I didn't think much of him from what I saw (which admittedly wasn't much) but there were quite a few predicting he'd go somewhere in the 2nd round. If he hasn't even been rookied, I wonder what would have caused the clubs to stay away...

Things didn’t stack up.

 

[Blue_Fusion]

Things didn’t stack up.

Shit, you got onto that one pretty quickly

 

[passmark]

Sydney Stack misses altogether.

Didn't one of us have him in the top 10?

There must have been some serious concerns about him.

Must be bad. WA teams avoided him like the plague.

Pity for the kid, from the sounds of it footy is the only decent thing in his life.

 

[Soapy V]

Since the end of the season we have done incredibly well

Trade, Staff and the Draft. Nailed it.

Well done Blues. Future looks bright

 

[TooBlue14]

At least Goddard and Bugg are only rookies. The most spectacular stuff up of SOS’s regime was putting O’Shea onto the main list.

We only put him on main list because Brisbane were going to take him in the rookie draft pick 1.

 

[The Dominator7]

DOn't like our rooks at all...I wanted us to consider Goddard or K Collins as a rookie - we've taken both with Collins signed to the NB's.

If all fit - next years talls in the 2's
Back: BSOS / Collins / H-Mac / Goddard
Rucks: Lobbe / Phillips
Fwd: TDK / Levi / Kerr

That's a lot of man flesh, even if some will be gone at end of 2019

 

[TooBlue14]

Sydney Stack misses altogether.

Didn't one of us have him in the top 10?

There must have been some serious concerns about him.

About as bad as picking bailey smith at 1 with his (can’t leave Vic) medical condition. Lol.