List Mgmt. Carlton's 2019 Draft Thread

[GT619]

AFL.com.au's guru provides his latest update ahead of the NAB AFL Draft
http://m.afl.com.au/news/2019-11-26/cal-twomeys-late-mail-mcasey-the-wildcard-in-top-10

 

[LemmingMaster]

Pick 9 for 14 and 17 would not be stupid?

Thinking we could gain both Robertson and Rivers.

Maybe even Robertson and Weightman/Bergman/Taylor/

Those two combinations are not the worst I've heard. The only real players that I really want if they slip is Ash and Young.

 

[windows1]

Pick 9 for 14 and 17 would not be stupid?

Thinking we could gain both Robertson and Rivers.

Maybe even Robertson and Weightman/Bergman/Taylor/

Those two combinations are not the worst I've heard. The only real players that I really want if they slip is Ash and Young.

You don’t want Stephens?

I’d be stunned if Cats did that trade btw.

 

[Stamos]

You don’t want Stephens?

I’d be stunned if Cats did that trade btw.

Cats won’t pay that much, and I think they, and we, are only doing the trade if McAsey is on the board, which means Stephens is already gone

 

[The Smoking Gun]

No, but they may just entertain:

Pick 9 & Future 1st to Cats > Picks 14, 17 & 24 to Blues.

Trent Rivers, Cooper Stephens and Elijah Taylor will do just nicely thank you very much.

 

[Stamos]

No, but they may just entertain:

Pick 9 & Future 1st to Cats > Picks 14, 17 & 24 to Blues.

Trent Rivers, Cooper Stephens and Elijah Taylor will do just nicely thank you very much.

I’d suggest that both clubs would be more likely to trade 9 for 14/17 and Cats future 1st

 

[TerryWallet]

I’d suggest that both clubs would be more likely to trade 9 for 14/17 and Cats future 1st

I think the Cats want to turn 2 this years picks into 1. They've stated as such ever since they did the Kelly trade. If McAsey is there, they could just come with 14 and 17. 14 and 24 may be all they offer, but according to Twomey we have already knocked back 15 and 20 from GC, so it may take 14 and 17 for McAsey.

Remember, when you can put a definate name to a pick it becomes more valuable. If they both covet McAsey, and GC offer their picks, which they already have, Geelong have to trump them.

Will be interesting if McAsey gets thru to us. Don't think he will though.

 

[MileHigh]

Lob does damage?

Thrived under Teague.

 

[LemmingMaster]

You don’t want Stephens?

I’d be stunned if Cats did that trade btw.

I guess I prefer the two player option instead.
I could be wrong about Stephens, but I have not fallen in love with him. I really needed to watch more of his SANFL games.

 

[HaydossJ]

Around 3.1 for 20.

Ie: slowish. He doesn’t play quite that slow but he’s got poor straight line speed.

FWIW the 20 metre sprint isn't a great measure of football speed. Football isn't played in straight lines. Running patterns and change of direction is more important.

Also, Jack Watts (2.82) was faster than Gary Rohan (2.95) and Patrick Dangerfield (2.92) https://www.dynamicfootyskills.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/Testing-comparision-tables.pdf

I wouldn't worry about his combine results too much.

 

[murphster]

I like it. Perfect fit for our team with O'brien on the other wing.

Will push into the centre square at times but may not need him there all that much with Stocker, Dow, Setterfield, Cripps and Walsh.

Would be nice to see if we can get back into the late first round and take Cooper Stephens.

The Stephens Stephens double would round off our midfield nicely.

Yep I think Cooper Stephens will be the bargain of the draft, would be in the top echelon if he played the full year I would love for SOS to do a Stocker trade to land him. Also if Robertson does slide could see SOS doing same for him.

 

[murphster]

Pick 9 for 14 and 17 would not be stupid?

Thinking we could gain both Robertson and Rivers.

Maybe even Robertson and Weightman/Bergman/Taylor/

Those two combinations are not the worst I've heard. The only real players that I really want if they slip is Ash and Young.

Would be a great result LM let’s hope McAsey is still on the board at 9 and it will get done.

 

[murphster]

No, but they may just entertain:

Pick 9 & Future 1st to Cats > Picks 14, 17 & 24 to Blues.

Trent Rivers, Cooper Stephens and Elijah Taylor will do just nicely thank you very much.

Hey Gun you planning on doing any training reports and photos this year, it was you that did the photos last year wasn’t it?

 

[skadoosh]

From barass70 's post earlier it seems we're using our pick 9. No mention from him of a possibility of a pick swap.

 

[murphster]

Did anyone else see that West Coast are looking at taking Jarrod Pickett in the SSP period, apparently he has been doing a personalised training plan and will start training with the Weagles after the drafts, are they out of there minds he just does not have the drive to be an AFL player.

On another note I see that Brendan AhChee got delisted by Weagles with a promise to take him in the rookie draft if he has no other suitors, also Hamish Brayshaw, wondering whether he might be not a bad option with our last pick in the draft or as a rookie, he definitely has the talent and it wouldn’t surprise me if Brisbane picked him up to go with his brother.

 

[Stamos]

From barass70 's post earlier it seems we're using our pick 9. No mention from him of a possibility of a pick swap.

He mentioned the guys we like. If Crows don’t take McAsey, likely they’re all gone by our pick, and GC, Cats, Port come hard for #9 to get McAsey

 

[Percy2257]

Serong

Oh no. Another Geelong Grammar boy. Give us a talented Mongrel instead please

 

[Bamboo Harvester]

Oh no. Another Geelong Grammar boy. Give us a talented Mongrel instead please

That's funny, I thought he was a Warragul/Gippsland boy who boarded at Geelong Grammar for a couple of years for his education....

Anyway, who do you have in mind Perc?

 

[HavUEvaSeenTheRain]

I think the Cats want to turn 2 this years picks into 1. They've stated as such ever since they did the Kelly trade. If McAsey is there, they could just come with 14 and 17. 14 and 24 may be all they offer, but according to Twomey we have already knocked back 15 and 20 from GC, so it may take 14 and 17 for McAsey.

Remember, when you can put a definate name to a pick it becomes more valuable. If they both covet McAsey, and GC offer their picks, which they already have, Geelong have to trump them.

Will be interesting if McAsey gets thru to us. Don't think he will though.

Depending on who we are targeting it is still very possible that 14 and 24 is better then 15 and 20. Ports 16 and 18 might actually be better for who we are targeting.

 

[BigBreakfast]

Oh no. Another Geelong Grammar boy. Give us a talented Mongrel instead please

Have you seen his games or even his highlights? Plenty of skill and mongrel there.
Great hands too and can take a grab. Satisfies our needs and great talent.

 

[Jimmae]

Trade 9 to Gold Coast...

Kemp, Sharp, Dow/Honey, Bryan

let's go

 

[mediumsizered]

2019 Draft Central Phantom Draft

THE 2019 AFL National Draft is just a couple of days away and it is clear that trying to work out which clubs favour which players is incredibly difficult given the evenness of the draft crop outside the first round. Even inside the first round, preferences will play a huge role in where players...

afl.draftcentral.com.au

This phantom draft has us getting Serong, Cahill & Chirgwin.

 

[Jimmae]

2019 Draft Central Phantom Draft

THE 2019 AFL National Draft is just a couple of days away and it is clear that trying to work out which clubs favour which players is incredibly difficult given the evenness of the draft crop outside the first round. Even inside the first round, preferences will play a huge role in where players...

afl.draftcentral.com.au

This phantom draft has us getting Serong, Cahill & Chirgwin.

Why are we constantly getting linked to every small forward and general defender under the sun? Makes no sense.

 

[GT619]

From barass70 's post earlier it seems we're using our pick 9. No mention from him of a possibility of a pick swap.

he replied to me saying Serong so I’ll back him in

 

[GT619]

Oh no. Another Geelong Grammar boy. Give us a talented Mongrel instead please

Caleb has mongrel in his dna