- Apr 21, 2010
- 583
- 813
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Bosa is a homophobe and a racist I hope Brodie is a better human
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Bosa is a homophobe and a racist I hope Brodie is a better human
September Update:
1. Matt Rowell
2. Dylan Williams
3. Noah Anderson
4. Brodie Kemp
5. Devan Robertson
6. Fischer McAsey
7. Luke Jackson
8. Will Gould
9. Hayden Young
10. Lachie Ashe
11. Tom Green
12. Liam Henry
13. Harry Schoenberg
14. Dylan Stephens
15. Sam DeKonning
16. Finn MaGinniss
17.Sam Flanders
18. Caleb Serong
19. Ky Pickett
20. Charlie Comben
21. Elijah Taylor
22. Trent Rivers
23. Jeremy Sharp
24. Nick Bryan
25. Cody Weightman
Very tough to order. I have significant queries over every player. I know you could say that about every draftee in every year, but i say that on a comparitive scale. Really interested to see if all the phantom's and public recruiters opinions largely merge as the draft nears like normal this year, or if large divergences occur.
Can only go with your own opinion, and this is mine at this stage.
September Update:
1. Matt Rowell
2. Dylan Williams
3. Noah Anderson
4. Brodie Kemp
5. Devan Robertson
6. Fischer McAsey
7. Luke Jackson
8. Will Gould
9. Hayden Young
10. Lachie Ashe
11. Tom Green
12. Liam Henry
13. Harry Schoenberg
14. Dylan Stephens
15. Sam DeKonning
16. Finn MaGinniss
17.Sam Flanders
18. Caleb Serong
19. Ky Pickett
20. Charlie Comben
21. Elijah Taylor
22. Trent Rivers
23. Jeremy Sharp
24. Nick Bryan
25. Cody Weightman
Very tough to order. I have significant queries over every player. I know you could say that about every draftee in every year, but i say that on a comparitive scale. Really interested to see if all the phantom's and public recruiters opinions largely merge as the draft nears like normal this year, or if large divergences occur.
Can only go with your own opinion, and this is mine at this stage.
Thoughts on Cody Weightman?
I was half thinking he would suit what we need if we got Papley and traded down to a 2nd rounder. Say our first this year and next for Swans 2nd and Papley.
I remember reading Weightman has some x factor, pace and goal sense which suits us
Would love to draft Weightman.
Interesting that he models his game on Papley.
Nickname has to be 'flea' right?
Robertson any chance to slip to a mid to late second rounder?September Update:
1. Matt Rowell
2. Dylan Williams
3. Noah Anderson
4. Brodie Kemp
5. Devan Robertson
6. Fischer McAsey
7. Luke Jackson
8. Will Gould
9. Hayden Young
10. Lachie Ashe
11. Tom Green
12. Liam Henry
13. Harry Schoenberg
14. Dylan Stephens
15. Sam DeKonning
16. Finn MaGinniss
17.Sam Flanders
18. Caleb Serong
19. Ky Pickett
20. Charlie Comben
21. Elijah Taylor
22. Trent Rivers
23. Jeremy Sharp
24. Nick Bryan
25. Cody Weightman
Very tough to order. I have significant queries over every player. I know you could say that about every draftee in every year, but i say that on a comparitive scale. Really interested to see if all the phantom's and public recruiters opinions largely merge as the draft nears like normal this year, or if large divergences occur.
Can only go with your own opinion, and this is mine at this stage.
Robertson any chance to slip to a mid to late second rounder?
Obviously not imo, seeing as i have him at 5. There will be a lot of variance in opinion this year imo. He may be closer to 20 than 5 in some opinions, but i'd be hugely surprised if he wasn't a 1st Rounder on draft night.
It will be interesting where we actually end up picking this year. I can't see us going to the draft with pick 8.
I will be very surprised if we hold pick 8 come draft day, though I think we will still have a presence within the first round.
Will be very interesting to see how things unfold over the next few weeks.
I will be very surprised if we hold pick 8 come draft day, though I think we will still have a presence within the first round.
Will be very interesting to see how things unfold over the next few weeks.
Yeah i'm pretty confident we will bring forward a pick again thru the trade period or on draft night again. I think we'll do this for 3 years which began last year with Stocker. Bringing our future forward 12 months when we are looking to climb.
Silvagni has studied draft techniques in great detail over in the states preparing for this time in our build.
I agree we will have a presence somewhere in the 1st round.
Not sure there's any real right or wrong with draft rankings this year LM as after the first half a dozen it does become pretty rubbery. Just some thoughts on a few.It has been a long time between drinks. This is my latest update with a heap more data. General thoughts below
- Even across the board with a wide variety of rankings depending on personal preference.
- Complete lack of real tall forwards
- Plenty of risky picks that could go bang depending on team and their development
- Not massive depth on initial observation
- Rowell - A lock to be a solid player, maybe just not the best of the bunch
- Anderson - I certainly have not seen his best efforts, just not sure what the hype is about
- Serong - Small and kicking is an issue
- Young
- Rowell
- Green
- Ash
- Anderson
- Flanders
- Rivers
- Kemp
- Gould
- Henry
- Stephens
- Robertson
- Maginess
- Serong
- Worrell
- Sharp
- McAsey
- Williams (This could leave egg on my face)
- Jackson
- Taylor
- Bianco
- Day
- Bergman
- Jones (Pure upside here, I would want some medicals on his body development potential)
- Weightman
- De Koning
- Ruscoe (I would gladly select him higher but he may drift a little)
- Rantell
- Schoenberg
- Taheny (Potential to make me look silly)
- Stephens (Not enough data to really make a proper judgement, but based on others thoughts, he will be around here)
- O'Neill
- Mead
- Brock Smith
- Comben
- Bryan
- Garcia
- Dow
- Pickett
- Pasini
Brock Smith - Is one that people will say "how the fu** did he go at Pick 30+". Spent quite a bit of the year playing as a lock-down defender and less time in the midfield yet his numbers have all still trended up in the right direction. While he's not quite Ash, he still provides good run out of the back half and his disposal by hand and foot is reasonably solid. I see plenty of growth and development in Smith.
I believe the WA Colts GF is televised in your neck of the woods today. Your thoughts would be good once its run & won.I'm a huge Smith fan, he just impresses me big time. I've just not had the balls to place him higher as he does not seem to be getting the press.
Brock Smith, Jones, Rantall are my bandwagons in the second round, if a club reaches for any of those names, I would not complain.
If we miss out on Papley and take pick 8 to the draft, what's everyone's thoughts on taking Cody Weightman? Might be a bit of a reach but he's a gun small forward which is exactly what we need, has plenty of X-Factor.