Carlton's Recruiting

[TheBushranger]

haha if Anthony is soo soo good as you seem to think.. why wasnt he debutant this year?

Bower played two games of afl, shut down micky o in one of them.
Stanley was a alright vfl player.
Bower showed ********loads more!

For the reasons I stated previously.

 

[Jeremias]

And you say I have no idea?

Yes, that's exactly what we are saying. And we are correct. You are clueless.

 

[TheBushranger]

Yes, that's exactly what we are saying. And we are correct. You are clueless.

No, all you are blind with optimism after so many poor seasons. Your poor recruiting will not help.

 

[Jeremias]

No, all you are blind with optimism after so many poor seasons. Your poor recruiting will not help.

Open your eyes, you aren't blind-you're just too stupid to know how to open your eyes.


You have asked questions of me, and I have answered, and proved you wrong. You are just too easy. Collingwood's kids are incredibly inferior to Carlton's. In fact, I suggest that this thread was fuelled by immense jealousy. Quite understandable, too.

 

[Melbdave81]

And Im speaking more of the 05 and 06 drafts

how would you know anything about the 06 draft, it happened last saturday!!!

Just some stats for you from this years DC.

Joe Anderson was ranked 6 in the beep test and Hampson ran 3 seconds for the 20 metre sprint. Not bad mate given that that is all you base your ideas about players on!!

 

[TheBushranger]

Open your eyes, you aren't blind-you're just too stupid to know how to open your eyes.


You have asked questions of me, and I have answered, and proved you wrong. You are just too easy. Collingwood's kids are incredibly inferior to Carlton's. In fact, I suggest that this thread was fuelled by immense jealousy. Quite understandable, too.

My God, our kids s*** all over yours, I guarantee that our next premiership comes before yours. That is a given.
And no, just because you say something does not mean that is right. So you have not proved me wrong at all.

 

[TheBushranger]

And Im speaking more of the 05 and 06 draftsquote]

how would you know anything about the 06 draft, it happened last saturday!!!

Just some stats for you from this years DC.

Joe Anderson was ranked 6 in the beep test and Hampson ran 3 seconds for the 20 metre sprint. Not bad mate given that that is all you base your ideas about players on!!

It's not all I base my ideas on, but for the positon Bowers is to play, he is severely lacking in the fundamental qualities.

 

[Jeremias]

My God, our kids s*** all over yours, I guarantee that our next premiership comes before yours. That is a given.
And no, just because you say something does not mean that is right. So you have not proved me wrong at all.

Your kids ******** all over ours? Name your best 5 kids, I guarrantee they are inferior to ours.

Our next premiership will come before yours. The colliwobbles are not a myth, they are a reality. We are pretty safe.

I don't need to prove you wrong. I've just helped you prove yourself to be a moron. Not that you needed much help...

 

[TheBushranger]

Your kids ******** all over ours? Name your best 5 kids, I guarrantee they are inferior to ours.

Our next premiership will come before yours. The colliwobbles are not a myth, they are a reality. We are pretty safe.

I don't need to prove you wrong. I've just helped you prove yourself to be a moron. Not that you needed much help...

Gibbs and Murphy are your top two kids, and you could mount an argument that they are better than our top two (they probably are). However, after that, our kids are all better than yours.

 

[Melbdave81]

It's not all I base my ideas on, but for the positon Bowers is to play, he is severely lacking in the fundamental qualities.

And in your esteemed opinion, what position does BOWER (not Bowers) play in

 

[TheBushranger]

And in your esteemed opinion, what position does BOWER (not Bowers) play in

Defence. You say he could play on a wing, but he is not a midfielder.

 

[Jeremias]

Gibbs and Murphy are your top two kids, and you could mount an argument that they are better than our top two (they probably are). However, after that, our kids are all better than yours.

As I have already requested, name your best 5 kids. Or are you too scared to do so? Thst wouldn't surprise me...

 

[Melbdave81]

Gibbs and Murphy are your top two kids, and you could mount an argument that they are better than our top two (they probably are). However, after that, our kids are all better than yours.

You still havent named your top 5 from 05/06

 

[one_twelve112]

Gibbs and Murphy are your top two kids, and you could mount an argument that they are better than our top two (they probably are). However, after that, our kids are all better than yours.

Kids like who? You display all the typical Collingwood supporter traits: Little logic/sense, poor judgement, ignorance, jealousy, half a mouthful of teeth, and a criminal history no doubt....p.s. are you logged in from Centrelink?

 

[Jeremias]

Defence. You say he could play on a wing, but he is not a midfielder.

Well done-this is the first correct thing you have said in this thread.

 

[Melbdave81]

Defence. You say he could play on a wing, but he is not a midfielder.

Ok, so why can a guy in his second game shut down one of the games best mid-sized forwards who is both quick and elusive, not play in defense. Your confusing me Bushie??

 

[TheBushranger]

As I have already requested, name your best 5 kids. Or are you too scared to do so? Thst wouldn't surprise me...

Thomas, Pendlebury, T Cloke, Brown, Reid, Rusling, Egan, H Shaw, Anthony, O'Brien, M Clarke, Swan make up a pretty exciting future.

 

[Jeremias]

Ok, so why can a guy in his second game shut down one of the games best mid-sized forwards who is both quick and elusive, not play in defense. Your confusing me Bushie??

You're speaking too logically for him to understand...

 

[TheBushranger]

Ok, so why can a guy in his second game shut down one of the games best mid-sized forwards who is both quick and elusive, not play in defense. Your confusing me Bushie??

Thats where he will play, but he won't play the position well.

 

[Jeremias]

Thomas, Pendlebury, T Cloke, Brown, Reid, Rusling, Egan, H Shaw, Anthony, O'Brien, M Clarke, Swan make up a pretty exciting future.

Can't you count? I said top 5. Nominate your top 5, and we will compare.

 

[blueheart]

Your kids ******** all over ours? Name your best 5 kids, I guarrantee they are inferior to ours.

Our next premiership will come before yours. The colliwobbles are not a myth, they are a reality. We are pretty safe.

I don't need to prove you wrong. I've just helped you prove yourself to be a moron. Not that you needed much help...

CARLTON KIDS COLLINGWOOD KIDS
Murphy >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Thomas
Gibbs >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Reid
Walker >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Rusling
Kennedy >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Pendlebury
Bower >>>>>>>>>>>> Stanley
Betts >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Egan
Simpson >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>O'Brien
Blackwell <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< H.Shaw ( ok you win one )
Waite >>>>>>>>>>>>>> T.Cloke
Fisher >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ( oops no more good kids )

Future looking pretty bleak for the pies

 

[TheBushranger]

Can't you count? I said top 5. Nominate your top 5, and we will compare.

Are we counting this years draft or not?

 

[Jeremias]

Thats where he will play, but he won't play the position well.

He has played the position well in his first 2 games in his career. He has shown absolutely nothing to suggest he will go backwards, rather that he will be an excellent player. Too much for you to handle?

 

[Jeremias]

Are we counting this years draft or not?

Absolutely. Go ahead.

 

[TheBushranger]

CARLTON KIDS COLLINGWOOD KIDS
Murphy >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Thomas
Gibbs >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Reid
Walker >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Rusling
Kennedy >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Pendlebury
Bower >>>>>>>>>>>> Stanley
Betts >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Egan
Simpson >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>O'Brien
Blackwell <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< H.Shaw ( ok you win one )
Waite >>>>>>>>>>>>>> T.Cloke
Fisher >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ( oops no more good kids )

Future looking pretty bleak for the pies

Thomas > Walker
Egan > Betts
Pendlebury > Simpson
T Cloke > Kennedy
H Shaw > Blackwell
O'Brien > Bower

Waite and Fisher are no longer kids.
If you go on that presumption,
Didak > FIsher
Fraser > Waite